Showing posts with label women in politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label women in politics. Show all posts
Monday, December 1, 2008
The Year of the Woman... kind of?
Reuters reports: Women see Clinton job as triumph, disappointment
Labels:
feminism,
hillary clinton,
women in politics
Sunday, April 6, 2008
Gender Hits The Campaign Trail
Finally. I've read a few hints here and there that pundits think Clinton "should be" playing the gender card. Obviously, with Obama trying as hard as he can not to play the race card it seems like the wrong concept. I still think it is the right one, and a very valid one. I still believe that in terms of social change and positive impact, electing a woman president is a bigger deal. The "historic" element of the 2008 presidential campaign has finally been blown wide open (it was really there all the time) so why not capitalize on it? Obama is certainly capitalizing on his "brilliant" handling of the race question with his "genius" speech.
At any rate, you be the judge. Gender is hitting the Clinton campaign:
Unfair double standard hurts Sen. Clinton
Will Hillary Clinton Lose Because Of Her Gender?
Democratic women who support Clinton rallied in front of the State House
Men, it's not your place to tell Clinton to quit the race
At any rate, you be the judge. Gender is hitting the Clinton campaign:
Unfair double standard hurts Sen. Clinton
Will Hillary Clinton Lose Because Of Her Gender?
Democratic women who support Clinton rallied in front of the State House
Men, it's not your place to tell Clinton to quit the race
Labels:
campaign 2008,
hillary clinton,
US Politics,
women in politics
Thursday, March 20, 2008
Of Course They Have To Bring Up Lewinsky
So, the character assassins are already jumping all over Hillary Clinton's recently published schedules as First Lady. They are saying, in essence, Hillary's schedules don't show any evidence for or against her claims of experience. What is clearly illuminated is her driver's seat role in early health care policy initiatives. It is also noted that after the failure of the Task Force on National Health Care Reform to get Clinton's reforms passed into law, Hillary's schedules become much more discreet.
Let's not forget that Bill Clinton was harshly criticized for granting a key position to the First Lady, and Billary was born. Hillary had to step back into a more traditional role publicly to stave off undermining effects. Bill Clinton's approval ratings hit an all time low of 36% in mid-1993, in part due to allegations that Hillary was the "shadow president." This was further underscored by a ruling of the D.C. Circuit court that the First Lady can be considered a government official. I believe it is clear that Bill and Hillary have always been close political partners, and in order to preserve that partnership, Hillary had to look more traditional and keep her advisory role strictly private.
Hateful little twists are being thrown out as well, chiefly the revelation that Hillary was in the White House at the same time as Bill Clinton was having sex with Monica Lewinsky. I fail to see how that has anything to do with it, as Hillary has said in her own memoirs that she heard it from Bill first, and that it was a difficult time that she persevered through. This is little more than mud slinging, fueled by American love of reality-TV style politics.
This brings me to my point. What if Hillary stayed with Bill because she loves him? The idea that infidelity is a deal breaker in what was already a 20+ year relationship, that has yielded great successes for both of them, is pretty narrow minded. Infidelity ranks fairly low in divorce causes, 4 out of 10 marriages in America end in divorce, and yet, the moral voice condemns the Clintons for staying together. The definition of marriage and partnership is reduced to one single defining factor: physical monogamy. The Lewinsky scandal was latched onto by a GOP-controlled Congress and spin control was entirely in the hands of Bill Clinton's political adversaries. It was used as a smoke screen by both sides. I find the public butchering of Bill and Hillary's marriage ridiculous, and I don't see anything wrong with them deciding to stay together based on shared values, shared goals, and shared success. So what if it is a business partnership? It's a very potent one. The whole issue of the sincerity of their commitment to each other has been focussed on Bill's sexual appetites, when it is clear that those are not a top shelf issue to either of them. And why does it have to be? Plenty of people make politically or financially motivated marriages, and never look back. Marriage itself began as a form of barter, of coalition building, and of financial partnering. Moral pontifications aside, marriage is a legal contract between two consenting adults that legally and financially binds them to each other. Prenuptial contracts would not exist if this were not the basis of marriage. The fact that marriages are often solemnized by a religious authority does not alter the very visceral reality of marriage schematics. Marriage is a partnership that, while it often implies sexual exclusivity, is not solely defined by it. Bill and Hillary made a decision that their marriage was more beneficial to them than separation. What's wrong with that?
The gender schematic is in play here, too. Bill gets street credit for his sexual adventures. Hillary gets slammed for excusing it. Anyone who listened to the radio in 1997-99 heard DJs and radio commentators chuckling about Bill "getting some" and endless pontification about the play-by-play of his encounters with Lewinsky. People were salivating over the scandal. Meanwhile Hillary was getting called on left and right to condemn Bill, called troglodytic by feminists, and painted as the dishonest one. Excuse me? Bill was the one screwing around. Hillary's "stand by your man" stance on the matter was portrayed as tacit approval of his philandering, when in reality, it was probably the only viable choice. I believe what it shows is that Hillary was more committed to preserving Bill's presidency than making a point. Harshly dragging the private details of their marriage into the public light was a mean and intentional ploy by Clinton haters. Hillary has been fairly candid that it was a difficult decision, but it was hers to make. I find it hard to believe that love, or at least an intense respect for each other, was not a determining factor.
Really, what if Hillary actually loves Bill? Is that so hard to believe? I think that the Clinton marriage and how it played out in the Clinton administration drew a sharp contrast to traditional views on both marriage and the presidency. Hillary challenged the traditional role of First Lady. She was a symbol of a strong woman in a strong partnership. What politician would openly say they expected their wife to confine herself to arranging flowers, staying home, and entertaining guests? And yet, that is the model we expect the premier couple in America to emulate. Hillary broke out of that model, and the world went crazy. In spite of his damaging effect on the Democratic campaign, Bill Clinton would be an asset to Hillary's presidency. The balancing act involved is that every president has been hesitant to seem like they are taking direction from another president. And Hillary is married to one of them, who would be back in the daily grind. Even now, when Hillary's image is getting smeared all over the place, people still like Bill. I can't count how many people I have heard and read saying, "I'd vote for Bill Clinton again." This is where gender comes into it, where the double standard of gender politics is playing a key role. Everyone knows Hillary had Bill's ear during his presidency, but because her schedules as First Lady show she did her job, that means she didn't do anything else? The schedules may not prove anything, but they don't disprove it, either.
Let's not forget that Bill Clinton was harshly criticized for granting a key position to the First Lady, and Billary was born. Hillary had to step back into a more traditional role publicly to stave off undermining effects. Bill Clinton's approval ratings hit an all time low of 36% in mid-1993, in part due to allegations that Hillary was the "shadow president." This was further underscored by a ruling of the D.C. Circuit court that the First Lady can be considered a government official. I believe it is clear that Bill and Hillary have always been close political partners, and in order to preserve that partnership, Hillary had to look more traditional and keep her advisory role strictly private.
Hateful little twists are being thrown out as well, chiefly the revelation that Hillary was in the White House at the same time as Bill Clinton was having sex with Monica Lewinsky. I fail to see how that has anything to do with it, as Hillary has said in her own memoirs that she heard it from Bill first, and that it was a difficult time that she persevered through. This is little more than mud slinging, fueled by American love of reality-TV style politics.
This brings me to my point. What if Hillary stayed with Bill because she loves him? The idea that infidelity is a deal breaker in what was already a 20+ year relationship, that has yielded great successes for both of them, is pretty narrow minded. Infidelity ranks fairly low in divorce causes, 4 out of 10 marriages in America end in divorce, and yet, the moral voice condemns the Clintons for staying together. The definition of marriage and partnership is reduced to one single defining factor: physical monogamy. The Lewinsky scandal was latched onto by a GOP-controlled Congress and spin control was entirely in the hands of Bill Clinton's political adversaries. It was used as a smoke screen by both sides. I find the public butchering of Bill and Hillary's marriage ridiculous, and I don't see anything wrong with them deciding to stay together based on shared values, shared goals, and shared success. So what if it is a business partnership? It's a very potent one. The whole issue of the sincerity of their commitment to each other has been focussed on Bill's sexual appetites, when it is clear that those are not a top shelf issue to either of them. And why does it have to be? Plenty of people make politically or financially motivated marriages, and never look back. Marriage itself began as a form of barter, of coalition building, and of financial partnering. Moral pontifications aside, marriage is a legal contract between two consenting adults that legally and financially binds them to each other. Prenuptial contracts would not exist if this were not the basis of marriage. The fact that marriages are often solemnized by a religious authority does not alter the very visceral reality of marriage schematics. Marriage is a partnership that, while it often implies sexual exclusivity, is not solely defined by it. Bill and Hillary made a decision that their marriage was more beneficial to them than separation. What's wrong with that?
The gender schematic is in play here, too. Bill gets street credit for his sexual adventures. Hillary gets slammed for excusing it. Anyone who listened to the radio in 1997-99 heard DJs and radio commentators chuckling about Bill "getting some" and endless pontification about the play-by-play of his encounters with Lewinsky. People were salivating over the scandal. Meanwhile Hillary was getting called on left and right to condemn Bill, called troglodytic by feminists, and painted as the dishonest one. Excuse me? Bill was the one screwing around. Hillary's "stand by your man" stance on the matter was portrayed as tacit approval of his philandering, when in reality, it was probably the only viable choice. I believe what it shows is that Hillary was more committed to preserving Bill's presidency than making a point. Harshly dragging the private details of their marriage into the public light was a mean and intentional ploy by Clinton haters. Hillary has been fairly candid that it was a difficult decision, but it was hers to make. I find it hard to believe that love, or at least an intense respect for each other, was not a determining factor.
Really, what if Hillary actually loves Bill? Is that so hard to believe? I think that the Clinton marriage and how it played out in the Clinton administration drew a sharp contrast to traditional views on both marriage and the presidency. Hillary challenged the traditional role of First Lady. She was a symbol of a strong woman in a strong partnership. What politician would openly say they expected their wife to confine herself to arranging flowers, staying home, and entertaining guests? And yet, that is the model we expect the premier couple in America to emulate. Hillary broke out of that model, and the world went crazy. In spite of his damaging effect on the Democratic campaign, Bill Clinton would be an asset to Hillary's presidency. The balancing act involved is that every president has been hesitant to seem like they are taking direction from another president. And Hillary is married to one of them, who would be back in the daily grind. Even now, when Hillary's image is getting smeared all over the place, people still like Bill. I can't count how many people I have heard and read saying, "I'd vote for Bill Clinton again." This is where gender comes into it, where the double standard of gender politics is playing a key role. Everyone knows Hillary had Bill's ear during his presidency, but because her schedules as First Lady show she did her job, that means she didn't do anything else? The schedules may not prove anything, but they don't disprove it, either.
Sunday, March 16, 2008
Next In The Ring: Ferraro vs. Wright
I believe I have succeeded fairly well in my pledge to not attack Barack Obama personally. I have attacked his positions, his campaign claims and some personality characteristics (chiefly what I see as insulting arrogance) that I find unappealing. But, I have tried to stay away from personal slurs or attacks on his personal life or family (although I did call Michelle Obama a bitch, and I'll stick by that one. I've called Hillary Clinton a bitch too, in her defense.) I believe that Barack Obama has deeply felt and sincere personal convictions and I applaud him for those. I also believe that he has worked hard in his career to do what he feels is right, and has been the champion of many worthy political moments.
So there are no surprises, I'll give something away up front: Yes, I am about to defend Geraldine Ferraro. If you read this, examine my claims and my rationale, and read it without the "My Preferred Candidate Filter," and still disagree with me, fine. Everyone is entitled to their opinion, as Ferraro has dramatically pointed out by saying, "I’m exercising my First Amendment rights. If they don’t like it, tough." [SOURCE] I believe the First Amendment is taking a front seat in the race argument that Ferraro brought to the forefront. Certainly Rev. Wright is quite aware of those rights and exercises them with zeal.
What I find ironic is that there is no direct link between Ferraro and Wright, and yet the two are now inexorably related. What I find further and more ironic, is that Wright's blatant anti-white racism is what turned the tide on justifying Ferraro, who claims she is being attacked because she is white. As I have not gone to Rev. Wright's church personally, and certainly never with Barack Obama, I have no idea if he did or did not hear these sentiments, as he claims. Downplaying Wright is pretty much the only way Obama can go on this. Straight up denouncing him would be very ugly for all kinds of reasons. But, obviously, he also has to distance himself from such inflammatory behavior.
I believe the core issue here is religion, not race. The fact that Wright's style of ministry is in essence Black Evangelism makes race the visual focus. I do not agree. I think the question Wright has our subconscious stewing on is, "Can we elect a president whose religion is radical in some way?" As far as the GOP goes, Mitt Romney had some pretty good ideas, but in the end his religion was the deal breaker. Religious convictions give us broad stroke ideas about a person's character. When religious convictions are used to portray a presidential candidate positively, there is ample justification for seeing the details.
It is hard to imagine Barack Obama was unaware of Wright's beliefs. Obama has attended Wright's church for 20 years, was married by him, his children were baptized by Wright, and he cites the Reverend as the inspiration for a book title. Wright was a member of Obama's campaign committee, and as early as June 2007, the campaign was doing damage control on Wright's potential impact. Unfortunately, the Democratic campaign tried so hard to keep race and gender out of it, that it is now the only place left to go. If Wright had never had an official place on the campaign staff to begin with, it would be a lot easier to downplay Wright's importance to Obama.
I don't want to demonize Wright. His preaching style is iconic, and he clearly cares very deeply for his congregation and for the well being of the African American community. The text of his "Audacity of Hope" sermon is really quite moving. Also, I agree with Wright about a few things. I don't think his social commentary is all that far off the mark, although his rabid honkey-hating does irritate. However, I do think on March 12th, only 4 days ago, Wright crossed the line by focusing his anti-white sermonizing against Hillary Clinton. There is no way Wright did not know what he was doing. He is a very intelligent man who has been directing the moral convictions of a large religious community for multiple decades. He also leveled a biting attack on Bill Clinton, claiming, "Hillary is married to Bill, and Bill has been good to us. No he ain’t! Bill did us, just like he did Monica Lewinsky. He was riding dirty.” [SOURCE] Like him or not, claiming that Bill Clinton was not good for African Americans is pretty hard to justify. He came out swinging for minorities in general and African Americans were some of Clinton's most devoted constituents. This was very clearly a calculated attack by Wright.
The question is, how much do we hold Obama accountable for Wright? Hillary Clinton was immediately called to kick Ferraro off the campaign bus, and a failure to do so was spun as a "campaign killer." Geraldine Ferraro is not Clinton's chief religious adviser, and her role in the Clinton campaign was minor. Honestly, Ferraro is a dinosaur who represents one of the worst Democratic defeats in recent history. Her presence in the campaign at all was chiefly symbolic -- she was a woman on a presidential ballot. Wright, on the other hand, represented a major part of Obama's image, which was propelled into the limelight by the need for reassurances that Obama was not secretly Muslim. Obviously, Obama is not Muslim. Obviously he is a Christian, has a respectable / acceptable moral code. But, if Obama is going to put Wright forward as, "an old uncle who says things I don’t always agree with," [SOURCE] we also rightly should ask, "So what do you agree with?" Obviously Wright's "damn the white man" sentiments aren't enough for Obama to quit going to church. So, we are faced with a presidential candidate who had said Ferraro's racist remarks should be ignored, but has as a role model a minister who regularly sermonizes race politics.
Race is a deciding issue in this campaign, like it or not. Geraldine Ferraro was certainly unrefined in pointing it out, but she's not wrong. Gender is a deciding factor, too. I find any claims that blacks are not voting for Obama because he's black and women are not voting for Clinton because she's a woman to be ludicrous. I don't think they are the biggest deciding factors, although I do believe they are the cause of it all. A political campaign whose historic significance is based solely on the race and gender of the presumed winners cannot exclude these factors in the outcome. Both Obama and Clinton will be cast as "champions" of their respective minorities. Obama represents post-race America, where we can have a black president at all. Clinton represents post-war of the sexes, where we can have a woman president at all. The irony is that either of them is challenged to seem like they have eclipsed their minority rather than avenged it. Wright is certainly casting Obama as an avenger, and has probably hurt Obama by putting him on a razor edge. He can't risk being seen as Afro-centric, but he also can't alienate the black vote by denouncing his church and what has long been a popular sentiment in Black Evangelism: damn the white man. This is a pretty unfair position to put anyone in, and it has got to sting, coming from the home front.
Unfortunately, because Obama jumped on Clinton to denounce Ferraro, Obama now has to answer the same questions about Wright. Clinton has smartly distanced herself from the Wright situation all together. This is something for Obama to sort out, it is personal to him, and it is not something the Clinton campaign is going to use as fodder. Of course people are implying Clinton is leaving it alone because it doesn't need any help to explode. I think this is a nasty and divisive argument. It's a damned if you do, damned if you don't situation for Clinton. Obviously, she is not going to get involved. There are so many reasons not to, and so many land mines if she does, it would be foolish to do anything but stay mute. No doubt, it is helping Clinton's image overall. She can't be blamed for it any more than Obama can be blamed for benefiting from Clinton-damaging scandals. While Clinton's response to Ferraro's comments was labeled as tepid, she did indicate first and most strongly that, "It's regrettable that any of our supporters — on both sides, because we both have this experience — say things that kind of veer off into the personal." [SOURCE]. Both candidates have started to advocate for laying off each other. I think this is the only encouraging sign in what is becoming a lurid and cutting campaign on both sides.
So there are no surprises, I'll give something away up front: Yes, I am about to defend Geraldine Ferraro. If you read this, examine my claims and my rationale, and read it without the "My Preferred Candidate Filter," and still disagree with me, fine. Everyone is entitled to their opinion, as Ferraro has dramatically pointed out by saying, "I’m exercising my First Amendment rights. If they don’t like it, tough." [SOURCE] I believe the First Amendment is taking a front seat in the race argument that Ferraro brought to the forefront. Certainly Rev. Wright is quite aware of those rights and exercises them with zeal.
What I find ironic is that there is no direct link between Ferraro and Wright, and yet the two are now inexorably related. What I find further and more ironic, is that Wright's blatant anti-white racism is what turned the tide on justifying Ferraro, who claims she is being attacked because she is white. As I have not gone to Rev. Wright's church personally, and certainly never with Barack Obama, I have no idea if he did or did not hear these sentiments, as he claims. Downplaying Wright is pretty much the only way Obama can go on this. Straight up denouncing him would be very ugly for all kinds of reasons. But, obviously, he also has to distance himself from such inflammatory behavior.
I believe the core issue here is religion, not race. The fact that Wright's style of ministry is in essence Black Evangelism makes race the visual focus. I do not agree. I think the question Wright has our subconscious stewing on is, "Can we elect a president whose religion is radical in some way?" As far as the GOP goes, Mitt Romney had some pretty good ideas, but in the end his religion was the deal breaker. Religious convictions give us broad stroke ideas about a person's character. When religious convictions are used to portray a presidential candidate positively, there is ample justification for seeing the details.
It is hard to imagine Barack Obama was unaware of Wright's beliefs. Obama has attended Wright's church for 20 years, was married by him, his children were baptized by Wright, and he cites the Reverend as the inspiration for a book title. Wright was a member of Obama's campaign committee, and as early as June 2007, the campaign was doing damage control on Wright's potential impact. Unfortunately, the Democratic campaign tried so hard to keep race and gender out of it, that it is now the only place left to go. If Wright had never had an official place on the campaign staff to begin with, it would be a lot easier to downplay Wright's importance to Obama.
I don't want to demonize Wright. His preaching style is iconic, and he clearly cares very deeply for his congregation and for the well being of the African American community. The text of his "Audacity of Hope" sermon is really quite moving. Also, I agree with Wright about a few things. I don't think his social commentary is all that far off the mark, although his rabid honkey-hating does irritate. However, I do think on March 12th, only 4 days ago, Wright crossed the line by focusing his anti-white sermonizing against Hillary Clinton. There is no way Wright did not know what he was doing. He is a very intelligent man who has been directing the moral convictions of a large religious community for multiple decades. He also leveled a biting attack on Bill Clinton, claiming, "Hillary is married to Bill, and Bill has been good to us. No he ain’t! Bill did us, just like he did Monica Lewinsky. He was riding dirty.” [SOURCE] Like him or not, claiming that Bill Clinton was not good for African Americans is pretty hard to justify. He came out swinging for minorities in general and African Americans were some of Clinton's most devoted constituents. This was very clearly a calculated attack by Wright.
The question is, how much do we hold Obama accountable for Wright? Hillary Clinton was immediately called to kick Ferraro off the campaign bus, and a failure to do so was spun as a "campaign killer." Geraldine Ferraro is not Clinton's chief religious adviser, and her role in the Clinton campaign was minor. Honestly, Ferraro is a dinosaur who represents one of the worst Democratic defeats in recent history. Her presence in the campaign at all was chiefly symbolic -- she was a woman on a presidential ballot. Wright, on the other hand, represented a major part of Obama's image, which was propelled into the limelight by the need for reassurances that Obama was not secretly Muslim. Obviously, Obama is not Muslim. Obviously he is a Christian, has a respectable / acceptable moral code. But, if Obama is going to put Wright forward as, "an old uncle who says things I don’t always agree with," [SOURCE] we also rightly should ask, "So what do you agree with?" Obviously Wright's "damn the white man" sentiments aren't enough for Obama to quit going to church. So, we are faced with a presidential candidate who had said Ferraro's racist remarks should be ignored, but has as a role model a minister who regularly sermonizes race politics.
Race is a deciding issue in this campaign, like it or not. Geraldine Ferraro was certainly unrefined in pointing it out, but she's not wrong. Gender is a deciding factor, too. I find any claims that blacks are not voting for Obama because he's black and women are not voting for Clinton because she's a woman to be ludicrous. I don't think they are the biggest deciding factors, although I do believe they are the cause of it all. A political campaign whose historic significance is based solely on the race and gender of the presumed winners cannot exclude these factors in the outcome. Both Obama and Clinton will be cast as "champions" of their respective minorities. Obama represents post-race America, where we can have a black president at all. Clinton represents post-war of the sexes, where we can have a woman president at all. The irony is that either of them is challenged to seem like they have eclipsed their minority rather than avenged it. Wright is certainly casting Obama as an avenger, and has probably hurt Obama by putting him on a razor edge. He can't risk being seen as Afro-centric, but he also can't alienate the black vote by denouncing his church and what has long been a popular sentiment in Black Evangelism: damn the white man. This is a pretty unfair position to put anyone in, and it has got to sting, coming from the home front.
Unfortunately, because Obama jumped on Clinton to denounce Ferraro, Obama now has to answer the same questions about Wright. Clinton has smartly distanced herself from the Wright situation all together. This is something for Obama to sort out, it is personal to him, and it is not something the Clinton campaign is going to use as fodder. Of course people are implying Clinton is leaving it alone because it doesn't need any help to explode. I think this is a nasty and divisive argument. It's a damned if you do, damned if you don't situation for Clinton. Obviously, she is not going to get involved. There are so many reasons not to, and so many land mines if she does, it would be foolish to do anything but stay mute. No doubt, it is helping Clinton's image overall. She can't be blamed for it any more than Obama can be blamed for benefiting from Clinton-damaging scandals. While Clinton's response to Ferraro's comments was labeled as tepid, she did indicate first and most strongly that, "It's regrettable that any of our supporters — on both sides, because we both have this experience — say things that kind of veer off into the personal." [SOURCE]. Both candidates have started to advocate for laying off each other. I think this is the only encouraging sign in what is becoming a lurid and cutting campaign on both sides.
Friday, March 14, 2008
Decoding Pelosi
With her election as Speaker, she is the first woman, the first Californian, and the first Italian-American to hold the Speakership. She is the second Speaker from a state west of the Rocky Mountains, with the first being Washington's Tom Foley, who was the last Democrat to hold the post before Pelosi. As Speaker of the House, Pelosi ranks second in the line of presidential succession, following Vice President Dick Cheney. She is therefore the highest-ranking woman in the history of the U.S. Government. -Wikipedia.org
When she was elected as Speaker, Pelosi clearly weighed in that this was a victory for women. She said in her acceptance speech, "This is a historic moment — for the Congress, and for the women of this country. It is a moment for which we have waited more than 200 years. Never losing faith, we waited through the many years of struggle to achieve our rights. But women weren't just waiting; women were working. Never losing faith, we worked to redeem the promise of America, that all men and women are created equal. For our daughters and granddaughters, today, we have broken the marble ceiling. For our daughters and our granddaughters, the sky is the limit, anything is possible for them." -The San Fransisco Chronicle
Pelosi is sort of the "clean Clinton." She's got a history of getting elected instead of appointed. She has never participated in a candidate debate. She has a history of landslide victories. She seems to have a monogamous and happy marriage. In her marriage, she is the political big wig, and did not stand on her husband's shoulders to get where she is. Nationally she is seen as a liberal, although her constituents consider her moderate. She is a strong and popular advocate for women in politics. In spite of what should be a clear-cut case for supporting Clinton (including her constituency supporting Clinton), it must sting a little bit to see Clinton take the limelight as the "first."
I think the arguments that Pelosi is supporting Obama secretly or that she would benefit politically by supporting him are little more than rumors. I'd say Pelosi's Freudian slip in referring to Clinton's campaign as the "Clinton Administration" here, certainly shows that she has at least envisioned Clinton as president. Further, rumors that Obama should pick Pelosi as VP are pretty silly. First of all, why would Pelosi give up her place as Speaker on the chance of becoming Vice President, a political post of questionable influence, with term limits, and one that would only bring her one step closer to the presidency? She would be stepping out of the legislative process, which is where she has the most of her influence. Ignoring for a moment the fact the VP picks really have very little to do with the outcome of presidential elections, Pelosi also isn't a great choice for either Obama or Clinton. She doesn't represent strength in either candidate's weak areas, her performance as Speaker has been less than stellar, and she stands to gain a lot more for herself by staying right where she is. Ignoring also the few pointed departures from her usual liberalism, Pelosi seems like a sensible and dedicated Democrat with the best interests of her party and the people in general at heart. In her NECN (New England Cable News) interview, Pelosi said, "We must have a Democratic president." She also stressed her uncommitted status and distanced herself from the campaign completely.
Pelosi wears many hats right now. As Speaker she is primarily concerned with Democratic control of the House. As Permanent Chair of the 2008 Convention, she is concerned with the integrity of the process. And as a superdelegate, she is concerned with picking the best candidate for president. I think Pelosi is doing what she knows is safest and staying out of it.
Clinton and Pelosi have both stood out as Bush critics. Obama and Pelosi both enjoy very liberal images in general. Pelosi has taken a lot of criticism for putting the kabosh on impeachment proceedings against Bush. I believe Pelosi understood that this would have been a waste of effort. Only 2 presidents have been impeached and both were acquitted by the Senate, stayed in office, and experienced increased popularity and power in Congress due to it. To get Bush out of office, Democrats would have had to give almost every second of their time and muster their entire constituencies. Pelosi saw upcoming battles for control of Congress, and the early stirrings of a very important presidential election as bigger issues, and no doubt they are. Bush was already a second-term president by the time all this came into play, which meant he was on the way down anyway. His approval ratings were so low by 2006 there was little point to getting rid of him. Passing up the shiny prize of impeaching Bush in favor of more realistic and likely long-term gains was the much wiser sentiment, even though it cost her some of her liberal image, and got her soundly chewed out by her home constituents. Pelosi can take the hit. In 20 years, she has never faced a serious challenge to her seat.
Pelosi's main problem is eroding approval ratings of the Democratic Congress since she became Speaker. Failure to effectively challenge Bush is cited as the cause. More specifically, failure to push the current administration's hand on settling affairs in Iraq. There is an argument that Pelosi would be biased toward Obama because of his stronger claims to being anti-war than Clinton. I'm not convinced he is all that anti-war, and agree with this article that asserts Obama has been inconsistent on his Iraq position. I also believe that in spite of Obama's slight lead in the Iraq debate, Pelosi shares many more commonalities with Clinton both in position and plan. Her constituency supports Clinton by and large. She shares a view with Clinton on the importance of this election for women. I also think that Clinton's vocal support of Pelosi's role in Syria indicates the two share a view on foreign relations schematics as well. Pelosi referred to her "gut" in her weekly press conference yesterday, and I think her gut says go with Hillary. Pelosi pretty strongly put forth her experience as the reason they should believe her. She said there wasn't time for her to share her "lifetime" of knowledge. Pelosi understands that tenure and backing of the party line make a recipe for success, both of which Clinton has over Obama. While Pelosi will no doubt remain neutral, I suspect her superdelegate vote will go to Clinton eventually.
That could change before it's all said and done. I think her many and possibly conflicting roles inside the party are going to lead her to back whoever fronts the strongest case by August. I can see a conforming support of Obama, versus what I think is fair to call a natural support for Clinton. No one is anxious to jump on the Hillary bandwagon, for fear of looking corrupted, versus how readily people are flocking to Obama. If I were the most powerful Democrat in government I would be wary of both: looking corrupt or looking fleeced by a cult.
To wrap up, I would like to point out what Pelosi has actually said. After all, she did say, "I just speak, you interpret."
"We must have a Democratic president," [source]
I think this clearly identifies Pelosi's priority: winning in November. She may be uninvolved in the campaign now, but that is going to change on August 29th. The only person she is going to hand over the title of "most powerful Democrat in America" to is the next President. This is a major throwdown to the GOP, the kind she has been criticized for not offering up to now. No matter who the nominee is, Pelosi will come out swinging. If the GOP does by some miracle win in November, her political power, and the chances of retaining it, are in extreme jeopardy. In this vein, Pelosi stands to lose a lot more than either Clinton or Obama in a worst case scenario. They'll still have careers with a chance of getting better.
"I think that ticket either way is impossible," [source]
Not, "I think Clinton-Obama is impossible," as the media is spinning it. Yes, that, but also, "I think Obama-Clinton is impossible." Pelosi has indicated that she thinks neither combination will happen and cited her "lifetime of political gut" as how she knows. I believe the reason she specifically cited Clinton as having ruled it out herself is because, of the two possible pairings, Clinton-Obama is the only one anyone could imagine. Obama did say, "Hillary would be on anyone's short list," but I doubt he would ask her and more I doubt she would accept. But, I don't think that is why Pelosi thinks it won't happen. I think she is looking at how seldom the top two contenders in a nomination race have paired up, and how even less often it has worked. Top two combo is not a winning strategy.
"Yes, there is going to be a dream team," [source]
No matter who is picked, Democrats are going to call it a dream team. They definitely aren't going to put forth a combined ticket like this, "Well, it's the best we could do. Good luck ya'll." Whoever claws their way to the top of the nominating process will be on the top of the ticket. Whoever is picked as VP will be the real McCain contrast. Neither Clinton nor Obama represents a strength to each other in that way. Both face different issues in creating strategies against McCain, and that is where the selection of a VP will really matter.
I'm surprised conspiracy theorists aren't already jumping all over Pelosi's certainty that any combination of Clinton and Obama will not happen. How does she know really? I've said how I thinks she knows, or at least what she means. Pelosi speaks. I interpret.
Monday, February 18, 2008
The Age of Woman
The current race inside the Democratic party, and the upcoming presidential campaign is being toted as "history making." Why? Because the assumption, on the liberal mind, and in the popular sentiment, is that the next President of the United States is going to be either a woman or a black man. As long as the next president is a Democrat, the United States is going to make the history books for finally doing something progressive in the Oval Office. Many countries have a thousand year lead on us in that race. Really, it's about time. America wants to position itself as a modern leader in world politics, but it can't give up its love of rich white men. That is about to change.
But, in spite of this, both democratic front runners are trying to downplay the race and gender issue. But are they? Hillary Clinton is counting on the women to support her, and Obama is enjoying what are being called "lopsided" victories because of the huge surge in African-American votes. Then, they start going after each other's base: the charismatic and handsome Obama is drawing votes from women, and Clinton is pulling support from black political heavy-weights, in spite of one highly visible African-American defector to the Obama camp. They've both grabbed a big name endorsement from the African-American pop culture: Oprah Winfrey weighing in (excuse the pun) for Obama and Maya Angelou for Clinton. We see the race polarization in campaign strategy as well: Obama has remained steady with campaign manager David Plouffe, a white man, and Clinton has replaced her campaign manager with a black woman and long-time Clinton supporter, Maggie Williams. The Clinton campaign can also boast historic first for women, harking back to Bill's presidency in the form of Madeline Albright and Janet Reno. Obama has wisely left the Woman Issue alone for the most part, as Clinton can easily trump him in that area a hundred times over. Regardless of this, feminists are abandoning Clinton left and right. Obama doesn't need to go there, as women are sliding his way readily. But what if Hillary did? She probably won't, though. I believe she is holding the feminist slant for the general election, when she will be up against (likely) McCain who is the poster boy for White Man Regime.
For the record, I personally believe that the 21st Century is the Era of Woman. Here's a short list of "firsts" for women worldwide:
*President of the Republic of Chile - Michelle Bachelet - March 2006
*Prime Minister of Jamaica - Portia Simpson-Miller - 2006
*Speaker of the House of Representatives: Nancy Patricia D'Alesandro Pelosi: 2007
*Secretary of State: Madeleine Korbel Albright: January 23, 1997 – January 19, 2001
*President of the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina - Borjana Krišto 2007
*Finland President - Tarja Halonen - 2000
*Finland Prime Minister - Anneli Jäätteenmäki - 2003
*Country of Georgia President - Nino Burjanadze (acting) - 2003
*Macedonia Prime Minister - Radmila Šekerinska (acting) - 2004
*Serbia Acting President - Nataša Mićić - 2002
*Ukraine Prime Minister - Yulia Tymoshenko - 2005
*Independent India President-Pratibha Patil - 2007
*Israel Acting President - Dalia Itzik - 2007
*South Korea Prime Minister - Han Myung-Sook - 2006
*Premier of Queensland - Anna Bligh - 2007
*Liberia President - Ellen Johnson-Sirleaf - 2006
*Mozambique Prime Minister - Luisa Diogo - 2004
I find it very alarming that there is any sort of call for feminists (female or male) to support Obama over Clinton. I believe it shows a very short sighted view, and that allowing the African-American equality agenda to upstage women's rights again is a bad move. With a few notable exceptions, the black agenda is a uniquely American problem, whereas women have thousands of years of prejudice and oppression and violence to overcome. Why do feminists fear Hillary? Is she too much like a man? Third Wave Feminists seem to think so. The nurturing stay-home mom who counts on her husband to tell her the news still supports Hillary, whereas the cutting edge feminists who defy categorization of any kind are coming out for Obama. It's a strange contrast. Regardless, the real sledgehammers, the feminist old school is still crying out for Hillary. Dolores Huerta, Maya Angelou, Gloria Feldt, Gloria Steinem and Madeleine Albright are saying, "We need a woman now."
Two years ago Hillary Clinton looked like The Answer to American politics. Why? Because she was respected Democrat, she had the experience, she was a vocal anti-Bush voice, and mostly because she is a woman. Then, enter Obama. Suddenly the Democratic race was polarized by the appearance an a black man who actually stands a chance to grab the Presidency. Like it or not, race and gender defined the campaign a long time ago, and still is. If Barack Obama was a white man his campaign would have folded a long time ago. It was the downfall of John Edwards, who publicly stated he was "getting out of history's way."
I believe both candidates have been smart to downplay the race and gender issue now. They need that kind of focus for the General Election where either one of them will have "making history" on their side. However, the race really has been defined by it. As I have said, I feel that the Age of Woman has come, and it it time for a woman to lead this country. I feel that the glass ceiling of the White House is really for women, and if Hillary Clinton can punch through it, we will see real change. A victory for women in this arena will be the true polarization. If a woman can win the Presidency, they can win in every other arena too.
Vote Hillary!
But, in spite of this, both democratic front runners are trying to downplay the race and gender issue. But are they? Hillary Clinton is counting on the women to support her, and Obama is enjoying what are being called "lopsided" victories because of the huge surge in African-American votes. Then, they start going after each other's base: the charismatic and handsome Obama is drawing votes from women, and Clinton is pulling support from black political heavy-weights, in spite of one highly visible African-American defector to the Obama camp. They've both grabbed a big name endorsement from the African-American pop culture: Oprah Winfrey weighing in (excuse the pun) for Obama and Maya Angelou for Clinton. We see the race polarization in campaign strategy as well: Obama has remained steady with campaign manager David Plouffe, a white man, and Clinton has replaced her campaign manager with a black woman and long-time Clinton supporter, Maggie Williams. The Clinton campaign can also boast historic first for women, harking back to Bill's presidency in the form of Madeline Albright and Janet Reno. Obama has wisely left the Woman Issue alone for the most part, as Clinton can easily trump him in that area a hundred times over. Regardless of this, feminists are abandoning Clinton left and right. Obama doesn't need to go there, as women are sliding his way readily. But what if Hillary did? She probably won't, though. I believe she is holding the feminist slant for the general election, when she will be up against (likely) McCain who is the poster boy for White Man Regime.
For the record, I personally believe that the 21st Century is the Era of Woman. Here's a short list of "firsts" for women worldwide:
*President of the Republic of Chile - Michelle Bachelet - March 2006
*Prime Minister of Jamaica - Portia Simpson-Miller - 2006
*Speaker of the House of Representatives: Nancy Patricia D'Alesandro Pelosi: 2007
*Secretary of State: Madeleine Korbel Albright: January 23, 1997 – January 19, 2001
*President of the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina - Borjana Krišto 2007
*Finland President - Tarja Halonen - 2000
*Finland Prime Minister - Anneli Jäätteenmäki - 2003
*Country of Georgia President - Nino Burjanadze (acting) - 2003
*Macedonia Prime Minister - Radmila Šekerinska (acting) - 2004
*Serbia Acting President - Nataša Mićić - 2002
*Ukraine Prime Minister - Yulia Tymoshenko - 2005
*Independent India President-Pratibha Patil - 2007
*Israel Acting President - Dalia Itzik - 2007
*South Korea Prime Minister - Han Myung-Sook - 2006
*Premier of Queensland - Anna Bligh - 2007
*Liberia President - Ellen Johnson-Sirleaf - 2006
*Mozambique Prime Minister - Luisa Diogo - 2004
I find it very alarming that there is any sort of call for feminists (female or male) to support Obama over Clinton. I believe it shows a very short sighted view, and that allowing the African-American equality agenda to upstage women's rights again is a bad move. With a few notable exceptions, the black agenda is a uniquely American problem, whereas women have thousands of years of prejudice and oppression and violence to overcome. Why do feminists fear Hillary? Is she too much like a man? Third Wave Feminists seem to think so. The nurturing stay-home mom who counts on her husband to tell her the news still supports Hillary, whereas the cutting edge feminists who defy categorization of any kind are coming out for Obama. It's a strange contrast. Regardless, the real sledgehammers, the feminist old school is still crying out for Hillary. Dolores Huerta, Maya Angelou, Gloria Feldt, Gloria Steinem and Madeleine Albright are saying, "We need a woman now."
Two years ago Hillary Clinton looked like The Answer to American politics. Why? Because she was respected Democrat, she had the experience, she was a vocal anti-Bush voice, and mostly because she is a woman. Then, enter Obama. Suddenly the Democratic race was polarized by the appearance an a black man who actually stands a chance to grab the Presidency. Like it or not, race and gender defined the campaign a long time ago, and still is. If Barack Obama was a white man his campaign would have folded a long time ago. It was the downfall of John Edwards, who publicly stated he was "getting out of history's way."
I believe both candidates have been smart to downplay the race and gender issue now. They need that kind of focus for the General Election where either one of them will have "making history" on their side. However, the race really has been defined by it. As I have said, I feel that the Age of Woman has come, and it it time for a woman to lead this country. I feel that the glass ceiling of the White House is really for women, and if Hillary Clinton can punch through it, we will see real change. A victory for women in this arena will be the true polarization. If a woman can win the Presidency, they can win in every other arena too.
Vote Hillary!
Sunday, February 10, 2008
Behind the Lobster Curtain: Maine Predictions
Caucusing in Maine is so convoluted it is almost mystical. The weather is cold and unpredictable. Maine's 34 delegates have not been subject to a poll since October. The two Democratic front-runners have deployed powerful proxies to the state, with only scant personal appearances. The sharp focus on Maine politics feels like an invasion in a very private state.
Democrats overall have deep inroads in the Northeast. In Maine, home or retreat to many presidential families, the opinion of a president matters. Equally, in a state thriving with private and state colleges, young voters are listening. Maine is a working class state, and a very woman-friendly state politically. Let's not forget Margaret Chase Smith. Currently, the state has two powerful female legislators in office, one of them a former first lady of Maine. The state is about as white as a state gets, at roughly 97% white according to the 2000 Census, with women just over the edge at 52% of the population. Maine is not closed minded though, having had 2 Independent governors who were both wildly popular, and being one of the first states to defend equal rights for women, blacks, gays and to adopt pro-environment policy. Demographically, that is about as flat a playing field as you can hope for.
Maine should be Hillary Country. Obama has suffered in this region of the country. In spite of endorsements and poll spikes, the Illinois Senator has only won Connecticut, while Clinton has swept the rest of New England, where she is predicted to win in all three remaining contests(Maine, Rhode Island, and Vermont.) Governor John Baldacci (D-ME) has endorsed Senator Clinton, although none of the superdelegates from the state have publicly pledged (Baldacci is one of them.) One major newspaper, The Bangor Daily News published an article today not entirely endorsing Obama, but supporting him. This is no coincidence, as Obama's one campaign stop in Maine was in Bangor. Clinton has been to Maine twice, appearing in Orono and Lewiston, while Bill Clinton hit Portland, the largest population in the state. Chelsea Clinton is stumping hard for her mother, doing the college circuit in the state. She spoke at Bowdoin College last night, and has appearances throughout Sunday at Colby and the University of Southern Maine. Senator Kennedy (D-MA) is stumping for Obama, having already spoken in Portland, and is currently en route to Bates College.
This represents an interesting strategy by both Clinton and Obama. Chelsea is the Clinton answer to the youth vote. Kennedy is the Obama answer to institutional support. Could such a big state, with such a little vote, be the litmus test for both?
Let's look at the cons first. On the Clinton side, Chelsea does not draw the attention Kennedy does, and could be seen as a last ditch effort. On the Obama side, being from Maine, I can tell you people are asking, "What is a Massachusetts Senator doing campaigning in Maine?" While New England is seen as one cohesive unit, and it is in many ways, in Maine, they're called Massholes. It's a toss-up though. He is a Kennedy.
The pros are as follows. For Obama, there is his ability to sweep the vote. This has become such a dependable effect, that it cannot be ignored. Also, the Kennedy Factor cannot be ignored, although Clinton gave that assumption quite a blow in Mass. For Clinton, the women and the moderates are on her side. Maine has a reputation in both parties for being moderate; maybe ironic, all the major female figures in the state's politics have been Republican. The economic demographic is also on Clinton's side, so even if Kennedy can sway the rich Democrats away from her, that still leaves somewhere around 60% of state democrats on the Clinton side of the gymnasium.
So, what will happen in Maine?
Two major things. First, regardless of who wins, Maine is going to set the strategy of both campaigns for the rest of February and into March. Second, the likely winner will be Clinton. This is in keeping with the polls, the demographics, the endorsements, and most importantly, it is in keeping with Clinton's campaign record. If Clinton can pull of a comeback in Maine, this will help her in the rest of February, with upcoming contests where she is lagging. Lastly, a win in Maine would most likely silence the Kennedy camp; with Kennedy endorsements going to both campaigns already, if Clinton can pull off another win in Kennedy country, that issue might go away for her.
This is not the first time Maine has been important in national politics, and it will not be the last. This one came as a surprise, though. Only time will tell, but I am predicting a solid win for Senator Clinton.
Democrats overall have deep inroads in the Northeast. In Maine, home or retreat to many presidential families, the opinion of a president matters. Equally, in a state thriving with private and state colleges, young voters are listening. Maine is a working class state, and a very woman-friendly state politically. Let's not forget Margaret Chase Smith. Currently, the state has two powerful female legislators in office, one of them a former first lady of Maine. The state is about as white as a state gets, at roughly 97% white according to the 2000 Census, with women just over the edge at 52% of the population. Maine is not closed minded though, having had 2 Independent governors who were both wildly popular, and being one of the first states to defend equal rights for women, blacks, gays and to adopt pro-environment policy. Demographically, that is about as flat a playing field as you can hope for.
Maine should be Hillary Country. Obama has suffered in this region of the country. In spite of endorsements and poll spikes, the Illinois Senator has only won Connecticut, while Clinton has swept the rest of New England, where she is predicted to win in all three remaining contests(Maine, Rhode Island, and Vermont.) Governor John Baldacci (D-ME) has endorsed Senator Clinton, although none of the superdelegates from the state have publicly pledged (Baldacci is one of them.) One major newspaper, The Bangor Daily News published an article today not entirely endorsing Obama, but supporting him. This is no coincidence, as Obama's one campaign stop in Maine was in Bangor. Clinton has been to Maine twice, appearing in Orono and Lewiston, while Bill Clinton hit Portland, the largest population in the state. Chelsea Clinton is stumping hard for her mother, doing the college circuit in the state. She spoke at Bowdoin College last night, and has appearances throughout Sunday at Colby and the University of Southern Maine. Senator Kennedy (D-MA) is stumping for Obama, having already spoken in Portland, and is currently en route to Bates College.
This represents an interesting strategy by both Clinton and Obama. Chelsea is the Clinton answer to the youth vote. Kennedy is the Obama answer to institutional support. Could such a big state, with such a little vote, be the litmus test for both?
Let's look at the cons first. On the Clinton side, Chelsea does not draw the attention Kennedy does, and could be seen as a last ditch effort. On the Obama side, being from Maine, I can tell you people are asking, "What is a Massachusetts Senator doing campaigning in Maine?" While New England is seen as one cohesive unit, and it is in many ways, in Maine, they're called Massholes. It's a toss-up though. He is a Kennedy.
The pros are as follows. For Obama, there is his ability to sweep the vote. This has become such a dependable effect, that it cannot be ignored. Also, the Kennedy Factor cannot be ignored, although Clinton gave that assumption quite a blow in Mass. For Clinton, the women and the moderates are on her side. Maine has a reputation in both parties for being moderate; maybe ironic, all the major female figures in the state's politics have been Republican. The economic demographic is also on Clinton's side, so even if Kennedy can sway the rich Democrats away from her, that still leaves somewhere around 60% of state democrats on the Clinton side of the gymnasium.
So, what will happen in Maine?
Two major things. First, regardless of who wins, Maine is going to set the strategy of both campaigns for the rest of February and into March. Second, the likely winner will be Clinton. This is in keeping with the polls, the demographics, the endorsements, and most importantly, it is in keeping with Clinton's campaign record. If Clinton can pull of a comeback in Maine, this will help her in the rest of February, with upcoming contests where she is lagging. Lastly, a win in Maine would most likely silence the Kennedy camp; with Kennedy endorsements going to both campaigns already, if Clinton can pull off another win in Kennedy country, that issue might go away for her.
This is not the first time Maine has been important in national politics, and it will not be the last. This one came as a surprise, though. Only time will tell, but I am predicting a solid win for Senator Clinton.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)