Showing posts with label US Politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label US Politics. Show all posts
Sunday, December 13, 2009
well if I can't have it all, I'm taking my toys and going home
Iran offers some of its uranium and the US refuses because it's not all of it. On the grounds that a partial transfer still leaves Iran enough uranium to construct a bomb. Um... isn't letting them keep all of it leaving them enough uranium to make a bomb? More than one bomb? So, it's all or nothing now? What are we? An only child? I guess we are since Barack Obama has declared the US the "only superpower." I suppose that means we can continue the US foreign policy tradition of playground politics. I guess they didn't notice that Ahmadinejad just had a highly publicized love fest with Hammas. But they're not interested in building a bomb... no, no! Goodness me! They want nuclear energy. Mm-hm.
Labels:
ahmadinejad,
hammas,
iaea,
iran,
nuclear disarmament,
US Politics,
USA
Monday, March 23, 2009
Bipartisanship: So much for that.
Again, allow me to agree with Jay Cost at RealClearPolitics who
says:
says:
Thus, bipartisanship is of little political use to him now. As a rallying cry against the Bush administration, which pulled the policy needle to the right, it was extremely helpful. However, not any more. When the "old categories" suddenly give you an opening, why "transcend" them? Why court the other side, which will only slow you down and moderate your programs? Instead, the politically savvy move is to do exactly what Obama has done: stuff bipartisanship, see how much you can squeeze out of Congress before the next "correction," and get your name into the history books.
I expect politicians of both parties to do this. Their commitment to bipartisanship is typically situational: they praise it when they're in the minority, then forget it when they're in the majority. Of course, Obama promised to be above politics as usual. That's why he pursued his party's nomination against Hillary Clinton, whose experience was greater but who had the "taint" of politics on her. Obama didn't have the taint, and assured us he never would.
So much for that.
Monday, February 2, 2009
Hillary Makes A Power Grab
And we thought the vitriol would be between President Obama and Secretary Clinton. Not so, and who would of thought it would be between Clinton & Geithner? The Team of Rivals is about to hit their first disagreement: who gets to lead on China policy? As the New York Times reported four days ago, the jockeying for Cabinet preeminence has begun. Clinton has been talking about China since her confirmation hearing (and before, in her presidential campaign) and has called for a "comprehensive approach" to China. First and foremost, this is a clear break from the Bush administration's take on Sino-American policy, which focussed almost entirely on economics. Today, Clinton is hosting a closed meeting (calling it a "working lunch" in the State Dept. schedule brief) with Geithner, which coupled with the staggered announcements coming out now of Sec. Clinton's Asian Tour this month, would indicate that this meeting will be mostly about China. Geithner apparently has Chairman of the House of Representatives Financial Services Committee Barney Frank, Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke, Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. Chairman Sheila Bair and Comptroller of the Currency John Dugan, all on his dance card for today as well. The rest of Secretary Clinton's day is dominated by her own swearing in ceremony and reception, where no doubt some fuller announcement will be made about her travels this month.
Wednesday, June 4, 2008
It Aint Over Til The Lady In The Pantsuit Sings
Here is what may be the final irony of the Democratic presidential contest: even though it appears Barack Obama has solidly won the nomination, Hillary Clinton can still make or break his candidacy. This puts her in a very precarious position, however, where she also stands a chance of ruining her own career. Clinton was unequivocally clear that she was making no decisions the night of the final primaries, and has remained officially mum so far today. She and Obama are both in Washington addressing the AIPAC conference followed by a stop in the Senate for a budget vote. No doubt there will be a private sit-down before the end of the day.
Clinton is not out of options, although many of them are undesirable. Regardless, she has the leverage to get just about any concession she wants. Here are a few:
The obvious, Obama offers Clinton the VP spot.
This would be the quick and dirty way to unify the party. There are negatives, but the positives may be found to outweigh them. The media is saying Bill Clinton is the major negative to that ticket. I believe it would be a mistake for Obama to let that sentiment get too much sunshine; starting a General Election campaign by publicly insulting a vastly popular former President -- the only Democratic President in this generation or more -- would be toxic. I believe the true negative is the combined fear that a) Clinton would be too ambitious an understudy and b) she could dampen Obama's liberal image. The positives of course are a much easier path to wooing Clinton's supporters, chiefly the blue collar, women, Latinos and probably the Jewish vote, too. Clinton's voting coalition of formidable, and many of them prefer her not because she is her, but because Obama is him.
Take it to the Convention
Admittedly, this is one of those undesirable options. Regardless of that, Clinton is fully within her rights to continue her campaign and instigate a floor fight. Her claim to a popular win is solid, and while the Democratic nomination is based on delegates, this does not mean she cannot contest the seating of them, and attempt to sway the Convention in her favor. Nancy Pelosi and Howard Dean have long been trumpeting the "will of the people" which is, in reality, quite a different thing from the the will of the state parties that assign delegates. In more than one state Clinton won the popular vote, but Obama picked up more delegates, and the argument that this is contrary to the will of the people is certainly valid. Of course the negatives of this are very real, very dangerous, and make the likelihood of a Convention battle very low. I believe Clinton knows this, and unless there is some extremely compelling reason to throw down the gauntlet, she will not take this road.
Run as an Independent
Another undesirable and highly unlikely option, but one that has floated around enough that it should get some discussion. Doing this would most likely accomplish only one thing: securing the Presidency for John McCain. It would also destroy Clinton politically unless by a true miracle she won. Now, that would be history. Clinton has a huge political machine at her disposal, and stands to be the unrivaled superpower of the Senate as it stands now, but all of that is beholden to the Democratic party, and dyed in the wool Democrats would desert her in droves. Clinton's appeal in this area (right leaning Dems and left leaning Republicans) would be much better used to cut into McCain's support base than to launch an Independent campaign.
Harness the momentum of her campaign and use it
I know that sounds vague, but there are many ways she could do this. Obama has already mentioned Vice President, Health Secretary, and any number of other potent roles inside his cabinet. Clinton could easily pitch for President Pro Tempore of the Senate, or might even be able to muscle her way to Senate Majority Leader. Secretary of State might not be such a bad place for her, either. No matter what she does, as long as she uses her visibility and leverage to help get Obama elected, she will heal whatever divisions are seen between her and Obama. There is also the rumor that she may consider running for Governor in New York State, although I find that the most unlikely of her general options. Clinton before anything else, is a Washington Politician, and is very cognizant of the spotlight being brighter in the capital. She is a big game hunter in that way, enjoys her work, and knows she has the most influence right where she is.
If she wants to survive politically, and keep her hopes alive for another Presidential run in 2012 or 2016, she needs to navigate carefully. If Obama loses in November, with or without her on the ticket, the main question will be, "Was it Hillary's fault?" John Kerry tried to blame John Edwards for his loss in '04, and even though that is likely not true, it cast a long shadow over Edwards. One thing to watch for: who delivers the keynote address at the Convention this year? I'd lay money on Clinton; in fact, I would bet it will be very high on her list of demands preceding a concession-endorsement of Obama.
Clinton is not out of options, although many of them are undesirable. Regardless, she has the leverage to get just about any concession she wants. Here are a few:
The obvious, Obama offers Clinton the VP spot.
This would be the quick and dirty way to unify the party. There are negatives, but the positives may be found to outweigh them. The media is saying Bill Clinton is the major negative to that ticket. I believe it would be a mistake for Obama to let that sentiment get too much sunshine; starting a General Election campaign by publicly insulting a vastly popular former President -- the only Democratic President in this generation or more -- would be toxic. I believe the true negative is the combined fear that a) Clinton would be too ambitious an understudy and b) she could dampen Obama's liberal image. The positives of course are a much easier path to wooing Clinton's supporters, chiefly the blue collar, women, Latinos and probably the Jewish vote, too. Clinton's voting coalition of formidable, and many of them prefer her not because she is her, but because Obama is him.
Take it to the Convention
Admittedly, this is one of those undesirable options. Regardless of that, Clinton is fully within her rights to continue her campaign and instigate a floor fight. Her claim to a popular win is solid, and while the Democratic nomination is based on delegates, this does not mean she cannot contest the seating of them, and attempt to sway the Convention in her favor. Nancy Pelosi and Howard Dean have long been trumpeting the "will of the people" which is, in reality, quite a different thing from the the will of the state parties that assign delegates. In more than one state Clinton won the popular vote, but Obama picked up more delegates, and the argument that this is contrary to the will of the people is certainly valid. Of course the negatives of this are very real, very dangerous, and make the likelihood of a Convention battle very low. I believe Clinton knows this, and unless there is some extremely compelling reason to throw down the gauntlet, she will not take this road.
Run as an Independent
Another undesirable and highly unlikely option, but one that has floated around enough that it should get some discussion. Doing this would most likely accomplish only one thing: securing the Presidency for John McCain. It would also destroy Clinton politically unless by a true miracle she won. Now, that would be history. Clinton has a huge political machine at her disposal, and stands to be the unrivaled superpower of the Senate as it stands now, but all of that is beholden to the Democratic party, and dyed in the wool Democrats would desert her in droves. Clinton's appeal in this area (right leaning Dems and left leaning Republicans) would be much better used to cut into McCain's support base than to launch an Independent campaign.
Harness the momentum of her campaign and use it
I know that sounds vague, but there are many ways she could do this. Obama has already mentioned Vice President, Health Secretary, and any number of other potent roles inside his cabinet. Clinton could easily pitch for President Pro Tempore of the Senate, or might even be able to muscle her way to Senate Majority Leader. Secretary of State might not be such a bad place for her, either. No matter what she does, as long as she uses her visibility and leverage to help get Obama elected, she will heal whatever divisions are seen between her and Obama. There is also the rumor that she may consider running for Governor in New York State, although I find that the most unlikely of her general options. Clinton before anything else, is a Washington Politician, and is very cognizant of the spotlight being brighter in the capital. She is a big game hunter in that way, enjoys her work, and knows she has the most influence right where she is.
If she wants to survive politically, and keep her hopes alive for another Presidential run in 2012 or 2016, she needs to navigate carefully. If Obama loses in November, with or without her on the ticket, the main question will be, "Was it Hillary's fault?" John Kerry tried to blame John Edwards for his loss in '04, and even though that is likely not true, it cast a long shadow over Edwards. One thing to watch for: who delivers the keynote address at the Convention this year? I'd lay money on Clinton; in fact, I would bet it will be very high on her list of demands preceding a concession-endorsement of Obama.
Wednesday, May 7, 2008
The Obama Effect Is Back From The Shop
This has got to be the quietest post-primary day of the cycle. There is a palpable hush across the media feeds, and both Democratic campaigns. A broad Google search for either "Hillary Clinton" or "Barack Obama" produce a paltry handful of results less than 12 hours old. Not even a handful really, one each. I am on at least a dozen Clinton-friendly mailing lists and about half that many Obama lists, and I have not gotten one email from either of them this morning. Normally, it's about one each or more per day, ready for the 8-9am readers. Even the crackpots at MoveOn are silent this morning (note that they spent their day yesterday trying to convince me to play the "Bush-McCain Game," like anyone who supports MoveOn needs reminders of their similarities.) Nothing from the DNC mailing lists.
It's like people are surprised by the results from North Carolina and Indiana, stunned even. This is what surprises me. For as long as there have been viable polls, it has been predicted that the May 6th primaries would be a split. Possibly, Clinton's campaign mismanaged expectations in North Carolina, but let's not forget that Ace Smith, Clinton's NC campaign director unequivocally indicated Clinton could not win NC. Let's also not forget that Obama's campaign circulated a memo predicting a 7-point win in Indiana, which they certainly did not get. Barack Obama himself also said that Indiana would be the "tie breaker" between Pennsylvania and North Carolina, which, according to that logic, would mean Clinton won yesterday overall.
Of course that isn't what happened. What happened is this: Obama overperformed and Clinton underperformed. The usual demographic divide happened. Even though Clinton won the white vote by a crushing margin in NC, the black vote and the under 30 crowd carried Obama to a big win. Clinton's victory statewide in Indiana was actually quite convincing as well, but once again, Obama stacked up big, urban victories that dwindled the final numbers down to roughly a 2 point spread. What's interesting is how wrong the pollsters were. They have fairly consistently under-predicted for Clinton and over-predicted for Obama, and this time the results were opposite.
But, is the end result actually all that different from what we knew was going to happen? Or is it the sudden lack of available delegates now, on May 7th? Last night just under half the delegates still up for grabs between now and the first week of June got handed out. Clinton's popular vote arguments got a serious hit to the belly. The Obama Effect seems to be back from the shop.
Calls for Clinton to quit the race are going to get loud and serious now. The cancellation of all her Wednesday events seems to indicate that she herself is at least weighing the options. In the small hours of the night, the Clinton campaign did announce a couple events down the road, but this is likely "insurance" posturing, and could change. If Clinton can keep her campaign afloat one more week, we might see a new flush of momentum. If she can get to the West Virginia primary on May 13th, where it is a fair estimate that she will score a true landslide (a 30 to 40 point lead) we might see new resolve. A huge win in West Virginia would not do much for the delegate count, but not much would at this point, unless Clinton won all six remaining primaries in the 80% range. But, a landslide win in West Virginia would give vitality back to the campaign, and would create momentum going into contests where she still has a chance to prove her electability case, and to keep her campaign alive long enough to see the resolution to the Michigan-Florida debacle.
I believe at this point, superdelegates are waiting for all the contests to play out. Howard Dean has stayed firm in his belief that all states should have their say, but that very shortly after all primaries are concluded, superdelegates should make their decisions known. I believe there is ample argument that it could still go either way. What matters at this point is two-fold: first, can Clinton keep her campaign alive long enough to outlive the cries to fold, and second, can the candidates keep their campaigns focussed on the issues and the full play-off instead of dissolving back into the bitter infighting of March and April? The media is (and has been) saying, "We need the black vote to win," and it's true. But, they also need the white vote, and Obama has not closed that deal yet. There are still runs to be scored. There is still a clock to run down. People like this contest, they enjoy the competition, and I see no real imperative for one or the other to call it quits this close to the end.
It's like people are surprised by the results from North Carolina and Indiana, stunned even. This is what surprises me. For as long as there have been viable polls, it has been predicted that the May 6th primaries would be a split. Possibly, Clinton's campaign mismanaged expectations in North Carolina, but let's not forget that Ace Smith, Clinton's NC campaign director unequivocally indicated Clinton could not win NC. Let's also not forget that Obama's campaign circulated a memo predicting a 7-point win in Indiana, which they certainly did not get. Barack Obama himself also said that Indiana would be the "tie breaker" between Pennsylvania and North Carolina, which, according to that logic, would mean Clinton won yesterday overall.
Of course that isn't what happened. What happened is this: Obama overperformed and Clinton underperformed. The usual demographic divide happened. Even though Clinton won the white vote by a crushing margin in NC, the black vote and the under 30 crowd carried Obama to a big win. Clinton's victory statewide in Indiana was actually quite convincing as well, but once again, Obama stacked up big, urban victories that dwindled the final numbers down to roughly a 2 point spread. What's interesting is how wrong the pollsters were. They have fairly consistently under-predicted for Clinton and over-predicted for Obama, and this time the results were opposite.
But, is the end result actually all that different from what we knew was going to happen? Or is it the sudden lack of available delegates now, on May 7th? Last night just under half the delegates still up for grabs between now and the first week of June got handed out. Clinton's popular vote arguments got a serious hit to the belly. The Obama Effect seems to be back from the shop.
Calls for Clinton to quit the race are going to get loud and serious now. The cancellation of all her Wednesday events seems to indicate that she herself is at least weighing the options. In the small hours of the night, the Clinton campaign did announce a couple events down the road, but this is likely "insurance" posturing, and could change. If Clinton can keep her campaign afloat one more week, we might see a new flush of momentum. If she can get to the West Virginia primary on May 13th, where it is a fair estimate that she will score a true landslide (a 30 to 40 point lead) we might see new resolve. A huge win in West Virginia would not do much for the delegate count, but not much would at this point, unless Clinton won all six remaining primaries in the 80% range. But, a landslide win in West Virginia would give vitality back to the campaign, and would create momentum going into contests where she still has a chance to prove her electability case, and to keep her campaign alive long enough to see the resolution to the Michigan-Florida debacle.
I believe at this point, superdelegates are waiting for all the contests to play out. Howard Dean has stayed firm in his belief that all states should have their say, but that very shortly after all primaries are concluded, superdelegates should make their decisions known. I believe there is ample argument that it could still go either way. What matters at this point is two-fold: first, can Clinton keep her campaign alive long enough to outlive the cries to fold, and second, can the candidates keep their campaigns focussed on the issues and the full play-off instead of dissolving back into the bitter infighting of March and April? The media is (and has been) saying, "We need the black vote to win," and it's true. But, they also need the white vote, and Obama has not closed that deal yet. There are still runs to be scored. There is still a clock to run down. People like this contest, they enjoy the competition, and I see no real imperative for one or the other to call it quits this close to the end.
Labels:
barack obama,
campaign 2008,
DNC,
hillary clinton,
US Politics
Saturday, May 3, 2008
Is Clinton The Real Unifier?
I have long been saying that voters are considering presidential hopefuls Obama, Clinton and McCain on a Liberal-Moderate-Conservative scale, in that order, independent of party affiliation. McCain is playing a balancing act, putting his "maverick" image out to the public and courting the conservatives on the inside of the GOP. Obama, on the opposite end, is challenged to maintain his liberal image without seeming too divorced from the bread-and-butter concerns of middle America. This allows Clinton to slide right in between them and frame herself as the true "compromise candidate." It also opens her to attacks on all sides. Liberals slam her for doing what you are supposed to do in a presidential campaign: use your resources to win; conservatives slam her for her obvious departures and disagreements with how Republicans have been running the country for the last 8 years.
Ironically, both Democratic candidates have been friendlier toward McCain than each other. This is changing since it has become obvious that people are tired of the negative campaigning. Obama has repeatedly spoken for unity in November, and yesterday Clinton (finally) said that if Obama gets the nomination she will "work her heart out for him." Admittedly, it is easier for her to say now that she is on her way to being the perceived front runner again. However, the same could be said for Obama, calling for party unity, at a time when he was soaring on public opinion. The Illinois senator has also repeatedly accused Clinton of using GOP tactics against him, and many people believe that the "vast right wing conspiracy" (a term ironically coined by Clinton) is currently conspiring for Clinton.
My first question is: just what are "GOP tactics" and if this "Rove Playbook" exists, I'd like to see a copy of it, because it seems to me it has been pretty effective. Maybe Democrats should take a lesson from the other side of aisle. The last time I was old enough to vote for a Democrat that actually won an election was 16 years ago, or 12 if you count Bill's second term. Since the Rove comparisons have fallen largely on deaf ears, Obama has now begun comparing Clinton's campaign strategy to McCain's, which I think is backwards. Obama has seized on the proposed Gas Tax Holiday that both Clinton and McCain support and he opposes to frame Clinton as a "defector." In reality, I think it was McCain co-opting a Democratic strategy, which is very good for his (illusory) moderate image. I find it an erroneous comparison, in fact, I find the idea that there is any specific and particular way you should run a presidential campaign silly.
I believe the main conceit of liberals is not their ideas, but the attitude that the rest of the world would see it their way if they would just "wake up" or if they were not so "ignorant." Maybe this is the conceit of every broad group of people. Regardless, the liberal vs. conservative dynamic in American politics always falls along these lines. We are told that liberals want change, implying that change would be good for everyone. We are told conservatives fear and abhor change because it will undermine our social structure and destroy "the establishment."
I believe Clinton represents the closest thing to a true bipartisan presidency we can hope for. I've said this before, but allow me to reiterate: Obama wants us to believe he is the "change" candidate and the one who will bring a spirit of cooperation to government, yet he holds the most liberal voting record in the Senate. Clinton represents liberal ideal for individuals, and very moderate ideals for government. Her voting record shows that she is a party-line Democrat, but she has crossed the aisle quite a few times in order to achieve goals she believed were for the best. Obama has made gestures in this area, but has continually withdrawn when it was time to put his name on bipartisan compromises.
The Weekly Standard recently published an article called An Exceedingly Strange New Respect, and while it points out why Clinton is gaining respect from the GOP and conservatives, I believe it also points out the growing respect for her overall. They make a very compelling case for the idea that the 2008 campaign itself has transformed Clinton into what she claims to be based on her past experiences. She's shown toughness, resilience, and tenacity, and moreover, she has demonstrated that she will not be forced to back down by the loud clamor of dissent, something every president faces. I would ask: isn't being respected by the GOP a key factor in encouraging cooperation? When Obama calls for change and unity and makes sweeping promises of compromise and shared responsibility, this is actually (as I have said before) code for: I will encourage bipartisan cooperation in my administration. But would he? Or does he simply believe that by virtue of being President he will be able to strongarm the GOP into submission? They do not like him; the GOP sees Obama as a threat, as a reversal of their efforts, and the end of conservative dominance of government. That's great right? I don't think so. I'm not sure we need another president that half the country hates. I'm not sure we're really ready for the kind of fight Obama will have to fight. There are much more pressing issues facing America than the Red & Blue Divide. Why not go with the candidate who's already purple?
Clinton has a very liberal background. Back in the '60s and '70s, she would have been in the front row of every Obama rally chanting, "Yes we can, yes we can." But the Woodstock era politics largely failed. What is really different now, forty years later? We're still fighting other people's wars. We're still detaining political prisoners without trial or representation. We're still killing the environment. We're still allowing radical religious governments to dictate our foreign policy. We're still in bed with the oil companies and the drug companies and the huge mega corporations that drive our economy. Senator Clinton lived through all of that, and her politics have been tempered by it. She has slowly slid closer to the middle and has dedicated her efforts to areas where a difference can still be made. She has embraced modern politics and modern ideas of compromise, and understands that sometimes you have to pick your battles. She is not seeking to upset the balance, only to refocus. What's wrong with that? Not radical enough? Do we really need another radical in the Oval Office? Obama is the Anti-Bush, which is precisely what makes him such an attractive option, but I don't believe the reality of an Obama presidency would deliver on his huge campaign promises. Clinton has not made any of these sweeping claims. Her most radical promise is a plan to provide health care for every American, which Obama has the audacity to call a bad idea.
Clinton represents a very interesting dichotomy. On the one side, her social programs are almost Communist, but she has presented a very conservative stance on war and foreign relations, citing US military might as her method of restoring America's preeminence worldwide. She has been widely attacked for what is being spun as a nuclear threat to Iran, when if truth, that is exactly what we would do if Iran launched an attack on Israel, which they have repeatedly made overtures toward. Clinton is not trigger happy, and I very much doubt she would authorize a full scale nuclear assault on Iran, unless they used nuclear weapons first. Moreover, using the very real threat of US military superiority is a valid and often used tactic, and one that is embraced by both Democrats and Republicans. Clinton sees an America that prioritizes itself, and its citizens. She wants to see every American have health care, better jobs, and stronger families. She also wants to see an America that takes its responsibility to the world seriously, instead of treating the world like its playground. If we have to puff up our feathers and pound our chests and strut around a little bit to get that done, she is willing to do so, and Americans like that. Support for Iraq is very low, and everyone knows it is a terrible situation for everyone involved. This does not mean other threats are not real, or that we should not get involved. Clinton understand this as well, although she may not fully understand Iraq. She does understand we need to get out, and we need to do so in an orderly fashion, and at the end of the day, that is what matters.
Clinton is making friends on the other side of the aisle, drawing support from the GOP, and solidifying her middle class base. This sparks all kinds of controversy, and opens the door for her to be cast as a secret Republican or worse. I find it unspeakably odd that we spend so much time wistfully imagining a united America, where we all get along and every politician's first priority is the good of all, and yet we reject politicians who are moderates. We want these uber-liberal politicians to create a common ground when they have as little common ground with the average American as the uber-conservative.
The Presidency is like a turn-based video game where competing sides "get their turn," and Democrats feel that their turn was stolen from them in 2000, and again in 2004, although they cannot deny the reality that Bush actually won in '04. Regardless, the Democrats now have an even greater sense that the Presidency is rightfully theirs this time around. I believe that Bill Clinton announced Hillary's candidacy in 1992 when he declared you get "two for the price of one," and later threw the entire force of the White House behind her 2000 Senate run. This is the source of the disparity between Hillary and the Democratic party, the largely unspoken accusation that focusing on Hillary's senate campaign compromised the necessary focus to get Al Gore elected. Because of the political and media firestorm created by the Gore-Bush race, we have forgotten that Gore had already greatly distanced himself from Bill long before the 2000 campaign, and it was seen as a career move for Gore, to keep his nose clean so to speak. He cannot fully blame the Clintons. You can't have your cake and eat it too, step back from the President when it is politically expedient, then expect him to prioritize you when it's convenient. It's certainly not very consistent with the loyalty model the Clintons expect. Hillary's sense of entitlement to the Presidency is completely in line with the Democratic party's own attitudes, but Al Gore casts a long shadow. However, I believe party leadership is also cognizant of the risk of alienating the Clinton machine, and while this has been held up as a reason to dislike Hillary even more, it also represents a very real network of political power and capability that could be put back into direct control of the White House, something the DNC greatly desires. Obama lacks this kind of extended network, which would require a good deal more effort on the part of party leadership to ensure smooth transition to solid Democratic control.
So, like her or not, Clinton is forming a large base of support, has shown extreme potency, and is now even attracting fans inside the GOP. What's bad about that? Isn't it the real goal? To draw everyone together? Or do we mean, we'll draw Democrats together? Perhaps what the party fears is the return of the New Democrats to power. The critics of the New Democrats, and Bill Clinton who was the DLC Chair until his 1992 presidential campaign, cite the perceived failures of NAFTA as the reason the New Dems are wrong. I find this erroneous as well, and would point to the overall success of Bill's presidency as the proof. People fear "dynasty building" as well, the idea that a second Clinton is in some way building a presidential dynasty comparable to the Bush regime. This logic completely ignores the fact that Clinton politics and Bush politics are very different creatures, draws another false comparison. The deeper you look into it, the more it looks like the Democratic party actually fears change, the realignment of the party toward the middle. And yet, isn't that exactly what we need? Isn't the endless tug of war in Congress and the White House tired yet? A centrist president is exactly what we need.
Ironically, both Democratic candidates have been friendlier toward McCain than each other. This is changing since it has become obvious that people are tired of the negative campaigning. Obama has repeatedly spoken for unity in November, and yesterday Clinton (finally) said that if Obama gets the nomination she will "work her heart out for him." Admittedly, it is easier for her to say now that she is on her way to being the perceived front runner again. However, the same could be said for Obama, calling for party unity, at a time when he was soaring on public opinion. The Illinois senator has also repeatedly accused Clinton of using GOP tactics against him, and many people believe that the "vast right wing conspiracy" (a term ironically coined by Clinton) is currently conspiring for Clinton.
My first question is: just what are "GOP tactics" and if this "Rove Playbook" exists, I'd like to see a copy of it, because it seems to me it has been pretty effective. Maybe Democrats should take a lesson from the other side of aisle. The last time I was old enough to vote for a Democrat that actually won an election was 16 years ago, or 12 if you count Bill's second term. Since the Rove comparisons have fallen largely on deaf ears, Obama has now begun comparing Clinton's campaign strategy to McCain's, which I think is backwards. Obama has seized on the proposed Gas Tax Holiday that both Clinton and McCain support and he opposes to frame Clinton as a "defector." In reality, I think it was McCain co-opting a Democratic strategy, which is very good for his (illusory) moderate image. I find it an erroneous comparison, in fact, I find the idea that there is any specific and particular way you should run a presidential campaign silly.
I believe the main conceit of liberals is not their ideas, but the attitude that the rest of the world would see it their way if they would just "wake up" or if they were not so "ignorant." Maybe this is the conceit of every broad group of people. Regardless, the liberal vs. conservative dynamic in American politics always falls along these lines. We are told that liberals want change, implying that change would be good for everyone. We are told conservatives fear and abhor change because it will undermine our social structure and destroy "the establishment."
I believe Clinton represents the closest thing to a true bipartisan presidency we can hope for. I've said this before, but allow me to reiterate: Obama wants us to believe he is the "change" candidate and the one who will bring a spirit of cooperation to government, yet he holds the most liberal voting record in the Senate. Clinton represents liberal ideal for individuals, and very moderate ideals for government. Her voting record shows that she is a party-line Democrat, but she has crossed the aisle quite a few times in order to achieve goals she believed were for the best. Obama has made gestures in this area, but has continually withdrawn when it was time to put his name on bipartisan compromises.
The Weekly Standard recently published an article called An Exceedingly Strange New Respect, and while it points out why Clinton is gaining respect from the GOP and conservatives, I believe it also points out the growing respect for her overall. They make a very compelling case for the idea that the 2008 campaign itself has transformed Clinton into what she claims to be based on her past experiences. She's shown toughness, resilience, and tenacity, and moreover, she has demonstrated that she will not be forced to back down by the loud clamor of dissent, something every president faces. I would ask: isn't being respected by the GOP a key factor in encouraging cooperation? When Obama calls for change and unity and makes sweeping promises of compromise and shared responsibility, this is actually (as I have said before) code for: I will encourage bipartisan cooperation in my administration. But would he? Or does he simply believe that by virtue of being President he will be able to strongarm the GOP into submission? They do not like him; the GOP sees Obama as a threat, as a reversal of their efforts, and the end of conservative dominance of government. That's great right? I don't think so. I'm not sure we need another president that half the country hates. I'm not sure we're really ready for the kind of fight Obama will have to fight. There are much more pressing issues facing America than the Red & Blue Divide. Why not go with the candidate who's already purple?
Clinton has a very liberal background. Back in the '60s and '70s, she would have been in the front row of every Obama rally chanting, "Yes we can, yes we can." But the Woodstock era politics largely failed. What is really different now, forty years later? We're still fighting other people's wars. We're still detaining political prisoners without trial or representation. We're still killing the environment. We're still allowing radical religious governments to dictate our foreign policy. We're still in bed with the oil companies and the drug companies and the huge mega corporations that drive our economy. Senator Clinton lived through all of that, and her politics have been tempered by it. She has slowly slid closer to the middle and has dedicated her efforts to areas where a difference can still be made. She has embraced modern politics and modern ideas of compromise, and understands that sometimes you have to pick your battles. She is not seeking to upset the balance, only to refocus. What's wrong with that? Not radical enough? Do we really need another radical in the Oval Office? Obama is the Anti-Bush, which is precisely what makes him such an attractive option, but I don't believe the reality of an Obama presidency would deliver on his huge campaign promises. Clinton has not made any of these sweeping claims. Her most radical promise is a plan to provide health care for every American, which Obama has the audacity to call a bad idea.
Clinton represents a very interesting dichotomy. On the one side, her social programs are almost Communist, but she has presented a very conservative stance on war and foreign relations, citing US military might as her method of restoring America's preeminence worldwide. She has been widely attacked for what is being spun as a nuclear threat to Iran, when if truth, that is exactly what we would do if Iran launched an attack on Israel, which they have repeatedly made overtures toward. Clinton is not trigger happy, and I very much doubt she would authorize a full scale nuclear assault on Iran, unless they used nuclear weapons first. Moreover, using the very real threat of US military superiority is a valid and often used tactic, and one that is embraced by both Democrats and Republicans. Clinton sees an America that prioritizes itself, and its citizens. She wants to see every American have health care, better jobs, and stronger families. She also wants to see an America that takes its responsibility to the world seriously, instead of treating the world like its playground. If we have to puff up our feathers and pound our chests and strut around a little bit to get that done, she is willing to do so, and Americans like that. Support for Iraq is very low, and everyone knows it is a terrible situation for everyone involved. This does not mean other threats are not real, or that we should not get involved. Clinton understand this as well, although she may not fully understand Iraq. She does understand we need to get out, and we need to do so in an orderly fashion, and at the end of the day, that is what matters.
Clinton is making friends on the other side of the aisle, drawing support from the GOP, and solidifying her middle class base. This sparks all kinds of controversy, and opens the door for her to be cast as a secret Republican or worse. I find it unspeakably odd that we spend so much time wistfully imagining a united America, where we all get along and every politician's first priority is the good of all, and yet we reject politicians who are moderates. We want these uber-liberal politicians to create a common ground when they have as little common ground with the average American as the uber-conservative.
The Presidency is like a turn-based video game where competing sides "get their turn," and Democrats feel that their turn was stolen from them in 2000, and again in 2004, although they cannot deny the reality that Bush actually won in '04. Regardless, the Democrats now have an even greater sense that the Presidency is rightfully theirs this time around. I believe that Bill Clinton announced Hillary's candidacy in 1992 when he declared you get "two for the price of one," and later threw the entire force of the White House behind her 2000 Senate run. This is the source of the disparity between Hillary and the Democratic party, the largely unspoken accusation that focusing on Hillary's senate campaign compromised the necessary focus to get Al Gore elected. Because of the political and media firestorm created by the Gore-Bush race, we have forgotten that Gore had already greatly distanced himself from Bill long before the 2000 campaign, and it was seen as a career move for Gore, to keep his nose clean so to speak. He cannot fully blame the Clintons. You can't have your cake and eat it too, step back from the President when it is politically expedient, then expect him to prioritize you when it's convenient. It's certainly not very consistent with the loyalty model the Clintons expect. Hillary's sense of entitlement to the Presidency is completely in line with the Democratic party's own attitudes, but Al Gore casts a long shadow. However, I believe party leadership is also cognizant of the risk of alienating the Clinton machine, and while this has been held up as a reason to dislike Hillary even more, it also represents a very real network of political power and capability that could be put back into direct control of the White House, something the DNC greatly desires. Obama lacks this kind of extended network, which would require a good deal more effort on the part of party leadership to ensure smooth transition to solid Democratic control.
So, like her or not, Clinton is forming a large base of support, has shown extreme potency, and is now even attracting fans inside the GOP. What's bad about that? Isn't it the real goal? To draw everyone together? Or do we mean, we'll draw Democrats together? Perhaps what the party fears is the return of the New Democrats to power. The critics of the New Democrats, and Bill Clinton who was the DLC Chair until his 1992 presidential campaign, cite the perceived failures of NAFTA as the reason the New Dems are wrong. I find this erroneous as well, and would point to the overall success of Bill's presidency as the proof. People fear "dynasty building" as well, the idea that a second Clinton is in some way building a presidential dynasty comparable to the Bush regime. This logic completely ignores the fact that Clinton politics and Bush politics are very different creatures, draws another false comparison. The deeper you look into it, the more it looks like the Democratic party actually fears change, the realignment of the party toward the middle. And yet, isn't that exactly what we need? Isn't the endless tug of war in Congress and the White House tired yet? A centrist president is exactly what we need.
Thursday, May 1, 2008
Wright's Gift Is To McCain, Not Clinton
I have waited a few days to comment on the reemergence of Jeremiah Wright into the Democratic campaign schematic. When I first watched Wright's comments on Monday, April 28th at the National Press Club in Washington D.C., something strange happened to me. I first discovered there was a new Wright splash by reading a news article from a Google search for "Barack Obama," something I do daily. Reading the headlines, it started to dawn on me, This is serious. As I read further, I realized I needed to go find the video and watch it, hear the tone of voice, see the body language, make a judgment on my own before I read much more opinion. I am skeptical of all news, I needed to see it for myself.
As I watched the video, I realized I had that sinking feeling you get when something terrible has happened. My hands were shaking. I thought to myself, Why am I reacting like this? Answers started to race through my head, but ultimately I realized I was reacting to Wright's hostility, and to the naked hatred toward America, toward white people, even toward Barack Obama. Wright was speaking with the ire of the betrayed, but the person he was betraying was himself. Any damage control his week long speaking tour had done was annihilated.
I immediately thought to myself, Why would he do it?
This was an unequivocal condemnation of Barack Obama, and an absolutely no doubt reaffirmation of the worst case reality of who Wright is, and what his beliefs are. Simultaneously I realized, no matter how Obama handles it, there can be no good result for him. Rev. Wright drew a line in the sand. Was this the "sea changer" everyone has been waiting for, that everyone said could never happen? There are very good reasons to be confident in Obama's ability to overcome adversity on the campaign trail. However, the Wright blow may have been the knockout Clinton can't seem to score. Immediately, headlines started calling it a "gift to Clinton" and asking, Is Wright Working For Clinton? I say, if it was a gift to anyone, it was to McCain and to the GOP, who had already dealt a low blow with race baiting ads. Clinton was already pulling ahead of both McCain and Obama in national and state level head to heads before the Wright explosion. Poll results that include April 28th are when Obama started to slip behind McCain, which tells me the GOP made the real gain from it.
The conclusion I came to was this: maybe Wright thinks it would be better for his cause if Obama lost, even if that means McCain would win. Race baiting works both ways. Maybe inflaming the race controversy is what Wright wants. I believe we can agree that race inequality is still a major problem in America. It is wrong to assume Obama and Wright have the same mission. Obama is running for President. Wright is a black advocate who has dedicated his life to the African American community. Yes, he's angry, inflammatory and divisive, and you can't really blame him. But this means he has different priorities, and maybe the crash and burn of Obama's presidential hopes offers more pique to racial issues than electing a black man would. Obama has said, "He does not speak for me," and soundly denounced him. This gives Wright fuel in two new ways. First, he can still damn America for rejecting a black man. And, he can damn Obama for abandoning his church and say, "If he had stuck with us..." I have not been able to find any new polls, but I guarantee this is going to cost Obama some of the black vote on Tuesday. Electing a black man could easily be seen as a "good enough" gesture on the part of white America, and derail real progress. I have no doubt that Wright wishes to see greater division, greater conflict, and greater urgency added to race issues. The greater the conflict, the greater the solutions, the more serious and real it seems. Most things get worse before they get better, and I believe Wright wants it to get worse. I don't agree with him, but I think it's a valid point of view. In spite of the pretty face we put on race relations in America, there are deep racist sentiments and huge cultural divisions in our country, that are easily ignited. Revolutionaries and agitators use these tactics all the time.
Obama now faces a personal conflict that I have seen all along. He has framed himself as the post-racial candidate, the unifier, the person who can bring real change to America. I believe up to this point, he has been able to take the black vote for granted, has not had to address why, the obvious, because he is black. Now, we see him vehemently denounce the beliefs of his pastor of twenty years, but because of that long relationship, and his previous creative dodging of the issue, we have to wonder what's true. Is Wright wrong now when he was expressing valid anger before? I believe the issue for Obama is not if he agrees with Wright or not, it is that his trustworthiness has been challenged.
Up to now, Obama's honesty armor had very few dings in it, but the Wright scandal overall has cast doubt and suspicion over him. Wright completely dismissed the claim that Obama has never heard his anti-American rantings. Now, it is up to voters to decide how they feel about it, and it is hurting him. It is also hurting him at a time when Clinton is gaining, riding momentum from a six-week winning streak. This creates a perception that it's Clinton's fault, but Wright was the author of this, both times. Obama made his bed the first time around by dancing around Wright and redirecting the debate to the broader issue of race. It all seemed like a good idea at the time, it seemed Obama has shaken off the Wright problem. No such luck, as the Reverend would not be denied, and blew up the controversy exponentially, resulting in a political nuclear bomb for Obama. Wright has given validity to all other challenges to Obama's integrity, chiefly the Ayers problem. I personally find Obama's association with Ayers quite a bit more disturbing than Wright. And, the extremity of Obama's perceived "religion" is drawn into question. Ask Mitt Romney what being in an extreme religion does to a political campaign. Obama just got blacker to white people and whiter to black people. It's a very serious problem, and one that I am not sure his campaign knows how to handle. It also represents the first serious stumbling point for his campaign strategists and PR team, who have been genius up to this point.
Is it over for Barack? I don't know, but I do know it is very bad news, and another bad week for the Illinois senator. He may still win the Democratic nomination, but the presidency? That picture is getting very bleak. On Tuesday when North Carolina and Indiana go to the polls, we'll see for sure. The results and the exit polls will tell the tale, as pollsters and pundits have been unable to do. I am withholding any predictions for the time being.
As I watched the video, I realized I had that sinking feeling you get when something terrible has happened. My hands were shaking. I thought to myself, Why am I reacting like this? Answers started to race through my head, but ultimately I realized I was reacting to Wright's hostility, and to the naked hatred toward America, toward white people, even toward Barack Obama. Wright was speaking with the ire of the betrayed, but the person he was betraying was himself. Any damage control his week long speaking tour had done was annihilated.
I immediately thought to myself, Why would he do it?
This was an unequivocal condemnation of Barack Obama, and an absolutely no doubt reaffirmation of the worst case reality of who Wright is, and what his beliefs are. Simultaneously I realized, no matter how Obama handles it, there can be no good result for him. Rev. Wright drew a line in the sand. Was this the "sea changer" everyone has been waiting for, that everyone said could never happen? There are very good reasons to be confident in Obama's ability to overcome adversity on the campaign trail. However, the Wright blow may have been the knockout Clinton can't seem to score. Immediately, headlines started calling it a "gift to Clinton" and asking, Is Wright Working For Clinton? I say, if it was a gift to anyone, it was to McCain and to the GOP, who had already dealt a low blow with race baiting ads. Clinton was already pulling ahead of both McCain and Obama in national and state level head to heads before the Wright explosion. Poll results that include April 28th are when Obama started to slip behind McCain, which tells me the GOP made the real gain from it.
The conclusion I came to was this: maybe Wright thinks it would be better for his cause if Obama lost, even if that means McCain would win. Race baiting works both ways. Maybe inflaming the race controversy is what Wright wants. I believe we can agree that race inequality is still a major problem in America. It is wrong to assume Obama and Wright have the same mission. Obama is running for President. Wright is a black advocate who has dedicated his life to the African American community. Yes, he's angry, inflammatory and divisive, and you can't really blame him. But this means he has different priorities, and maybe the crash and burn of Obama's presidential hopes offers more pique to racial issues than electing a black man would. Obama has said, "He does not speak for me," and soundly denounced him. This gives Wright fuel in two new ways. First, he can still damn America for rejecting a black man. And, he can damn Obama for abandoning his church and say, "If he had stuck with us..." I have not been able to find any new polls, but I guarantee this is going to cost Obama some of the black vote on Tuesday. Electing a black man could easily be seen as a "good enough" gesture on the part of white America, and derail real progress. I have no doubt that Wright wishes to see greater division, greater conflict, and greater urgency added to race issues. The greater the conflict, the greater the solutions, the more serious and real it seems. Most things get worse before they get better, and I believe Wright wants it to get worse. I don't agree with him, but I think it's a valid point of view. In spite of the pretty face we put on race relations in America, there are deep racist sentiments and huge cultural divisions in our country, that are easily ignited. Revolutionaries and agitators use these tactics all the time.
Obama now faces a personal conflict that I have seen all along. He has framed himself as the post-racial candidate, the unifier, the person who can bring real change to America. I believe up to this point, he has been able to take the black vote for granted, has not had to address why, the obvious, because he is black. Now, we see him vehemently denounce the beliefs of his pastor of twenty years, but because of that long relationship, and his previous creative dodging of the issue, we have to wonder what's true. Is Wright wrong now when he was expressing valid anger before? I believe the issue for Obama is not if he agrees with Wright or not, it is that his trustworthiness has been challenged.
Up to now, Obama's honesty armor had very few dings in it, but the Wright scandal overall has cast doubt and suspicion over him. Wright completely dismissed the claim that Obama has never heard his anti-American rantings. Now, it is up to voters to decide how they feel about it, and it is hurting him. It is also hurting him at a time when Clinton is gaining, riding momentum from a six-week winning streak. This creates a perception that it's Clinton's fault, but Wright was the author of this, both times. Obama made his bed the first time around by dancing around Wright and redirecting the debate to the broader issue of race. It all seemed like a good idea at the time, it seemed Obama has shaken off the Wright problem. No such luck, as the Reverend would not be denied, and blew up the controversy exponentially, resulting in a political nuclear bomb for Obama. Wright has given validity to all other challenges to Obama's integrity, chiefly the Ayers problem. I personally find Obama's association with Ayers quite a bit more disturbing than Wright. And, the extremity of Obama's perceived "religion" is drawn into question. Ask Mitt Romney what being in an extreme religion does to a political campaign. Obama just got blacker to white people and whiter to black people. It's a very serious problem, and one that I am not sure his campaign knows how to handle. It also represents the first serious stumbling point for his campaign strategists and PR team, who have been genius up to this point.
Is it over for Barack? I don't know, but I do know it is very bad news, and another bad week for the Illinois senator. He may still win the Democratic nomination, but the presidency? That picture is getting very bleak. On Tuesday when North Carolina and Indiana go to the polls, we'll see for sure. The results and the exit polls will tell the tale, as pollsters and pundits have been unable to do. I am withholding any predictions for the time being.
Saturday, April 26, 2008
Dream Ticket? Again?
Let me begin by saying, "Bravo," to Sen. Obama. I just watched his speech in Kokomo, IN yesterday, replayed on CNN. Not only was it a good speech, but it was very excellent sportsmanship, something I find a critical component to fairness. He stated his support for party unity in the General Election, praised Sen. Clinton, then moved on to highlight their similarities, saying any differences between the two Democrats "paled in comparison" to their shared differences with Sen. McCain. I also watched Sen. Clinton's speech in Bloomington, and while she was clearly contrasting herself with Obama rather than McCain, she stuck to the issues. I believe both Democratic candidates have shown responsiveness to the negative effects of negative campaigning -- they've "listened to the boos," so to speak. Both of them should also be allowed a little forgiveness if they do spat here and there. Regardless of how either campaign tries to spin it, their primary opponents are still each other.
I want to talk about this "Dream Ticket" some more. I don't agree with Nancy Pelosi that it is necessarily a bad idea. The reason I point out Pelosi to disagree with is because I think her perspective is very interesting if you think about it. She must be torn in one way. Her constituency, California, supports Clinton by the broad strokes. However, I'd say in the fuzzy area of demeanor, she has indicated a leaning toward Obama. Pelosi has flexed her political muscles in subtle ways, stressing always the importance of a Democratic win in November. I find it curious that she is continually the one who is publicly commenting on the "Dream Ticket," and continually condemning it. Her role as Permanent Chair of the 2008 Democratic Convention puts her in a precarious position, but I think something she said that has been largely overlooked sheds light on her attitude: Pelosi did concede that if Obama and Clinton think the Dream Ticket is a good idea, "maybe it is." She indicated in no uncertain terms that the nominee should be allowed to pick their own running mate, and that "thrusting" the decision on them now was unfair. Both candidates have also indicated this same attitude, both have refused to answer questions about vice presidential choices at all.
The word "stalemate" is already hitting the media. Clinton's popular vote argument is very convincing for one reason alone: regardless of the rules which currently exclude Florida and Michigan from pledging delegates to a candidate, those votes were cast and represent the will of millions of voters. Two state Democratic parties broke the rules. Conscientious voters who went and voted when they had the chance to do so did not. This does not change Obama's delegate lead. What we are seeing already is a growing argument about what is the most accurate reflection of the will of the people: the delegate count or the raw votes. This argument was central to the General Election controversies of 2000, and the Supreme Court ultimately broke in favor of the electoral vote. It can only be salt on the wound that Florida is, once again, central to the conflict. Although it has quickly become a footnote to the overall situation, it cannot be ignored that a Republican controlled state is causing political problems for the Democratic party, again. The Supreme Court will not get to rule on this problem, however. Democrats have to work it out for themselves. Smartly, Clinton is allowing the delegate battles in Florida and Michigan to play out now largely in the background. Both states are lobbying the DNC for a reversal of the penalties on their states or a compromise, and will be petitioning the Rules & Bylaws committee soon. The underlying tension is increased by Clinton's strong performance in Florida against McCain, and the implication that disenfranchising Florida democrats early in the process would undermine potential successes in November.
Clinton's potent showing in head-to-heads vs. McCain (she loses by only 0.3%) in Florida shows the potential for a big upset; Florida is a solid Red state, and taking it from the GOP in November would be a huge advantage. Obama shows no such competitiveness in Florida, and also loses to McCain in Pennsylvania and Ohio, two more states Clinton wins convincingly. This, combined with the visceral reality of the popular vote are serious and compelling arguments. Democrats really cannot risk being seen as willfully excluding people from the process. On the other hand, Obama has an equally strong argument that the rules are the rules, everyone knew them, and following those rules, he is winning. It is ironic for both candidates. Obama, the unifier, says a million and a half votes don't count. Clinton, the underdog, is claiming to be the winner based on results she publicly said were "beauty contests." If Florida and Michigan prevail before the Rules & Bylaws committee, the popular vote count becomes even more valid. I see more indications that they will be included than not, and Democratic leadership showing attitudes of cooperation and open mindedness.
So, what happens if we get to June 3rd and it's a draw? I've seen the possibility of a statistical tie growing greater and greater with each contest. No one wants to talk about it because in one way it would be the worst possible outcome. Exit poll results indicate extreme loyalties to both candidates, and there can be no ignoring the all out war that is being waged in the blogsphere. The exit polls also indicate a hypocrisy in voting trends. The majority of exit polls indicate that race and gender had little to do with their choice, while voting trends clearly indicate women breaking for Clinton and African Americans breaking for Obama. More irony as well in their big bloc bases; Clinton is a member of the rich elite with lengthly involvement at the highest levels of government, but the working class and the lower educated prefer her. Obama comes from a very modest background and got most of his political training in the poor neighborhoods of Chicago, one of the ultimate working class cities, but the rich and affluent prefer him.
Even on the issues, I believe we see what amounts to a tie. Clinton is winning in general on the Economy and Health Care. This alone would be an argument greatly in favor of Clinton except for one thing: Iraq. Obama is clearly winning the Iraq debate on both fronts. The issues Republicans and Democrats vote on are different, but foreign relations are a shared issue almost all the time. Iraq is the #2 issue between both parties, and Obama has both a higher moral stance than Clinton and a more popular stance than McCain. Because she voted to authorize the war, Clinton faces a serious issue of voter confidence on Iraq, and this would be a serious liability against McCain. This is where the Independents come in, and where their bloc matters. If McCain can make Clinton look wishy washy or untrustworthy on foreign relations, her other arguments fall apart. One of Clinton's strengths is that she sees opportunities to dovetail many broad projects and policies together to increase the effectiveness of all of them. But, that also means you have to be willing to buy the whole package. So, although Clinton takes two out of three major issues for Democrats, the main debatable issue in the General Election will be Iraq, where Obama is the clear winner. Clinton's main counter to that will be the other shared issue, Experience, which has played itself out this election cycle in the "3am War." McCain has even co-opted the 3am catch phrase. Even though McCain does in fact have the most experience, Clinton will be much more able to neutralize that argument.
I see an image irony as well, that creates a sort of tie of its own. Clinton has called Obama's character into question based on his associations with less than desirable individuals, yet the Clinton's combined have a laundry list of shady associates. Conversely, Obama has sold himself as a bipartisan unifier and challenged Clinton on her voting record, when their voting records show that Clinton has sponsored much more bipartisan legislature than him; Obama in fact holds the current voting record for most liberal Senator. Again, ironically, Obama's uber-liberalism is what makes people believe he would straddle the aisle as President. Clinton has been caught in more than one "misstatement," on the campaign trail (which is code for "she lied") and this has underscored her low scores on trustworthiness, and is pointed to as one of the reasons she cannot seem to connect with people like Obama can. Clinton has addressed these indiscretions by saying, in essence, "Look, we're all tired. This is a very stressful time. We make mistakes." She has asked to be forgiven based on being human, offering a connection in the most ironic way. Lastly, there is arrogance vs. entitlement. I have long been criticizing Obama's arrogance. I believe he displays the sense of entitlement that Clinton is vetted for having. Moreover, Clinton's sense of entitlement to the Presidency is very much in line with the sentiment of the party in general, yet she looks like a crony for it. On the other hand, Obama's youthful and exuberant promises of hope and prosperity are precisely what makes him so attractive to voters, and a liability to the party. We love Obama because he is a true liberal, but that makes him a risky bet.
The backdrop of all of this is somewhere in the area of 30 million voters, double the voter turnout of any presidential primary. This is roughly equivalent to the jump in voter turnout between 2000 and 2004 in the general election, and can be taken as a very good sign. The Democratic party is also reporting record numbers of new registrants, also good. While voters are showing signs of fatigue in terms of paying attention, no one seems to want the contest to end prematurely. Everyone from the candidates to the party leaders to the exit pollers have indicated an interest in seeing the entire contest play out.
Let's talk about this Dream Ticket some more. Even after all this time, I think the main objection to the Dream Ticket is that the only way anyone can imagine a combined ticket is with Clinton on the top of it. Of course, as the race stands now, this would mean Obama would be conceding the race when he was ahead. This is the same argument Clinton has used for staying in the race this long, in spite of serious questions about her viability before March 4th. Now that she has won 4 out of the last 6 contests, is showing a very good chance of closing the popular vote gap, and has demonstrated a very valid big state strategy, the game is changed.
I see three scenarios where the Dream Ticket could happen. First, Clinton wins the delegate race, obviously with superdelegate backing, and offers the VP slot to Obama. I am sure he would take it if he knew he was out otherwise. Second, Clinton exercises her right to stay in the race, which is indisputably hers, and fully within the rules. She can force a brokered convention, regardless of what we think about if she should or not. She can do it. If she does, I could see a Clinton-Obama ticket emerging as the compromise to prevent a nasty floor battle in Denver. It would be very hard to spin this as a genuine pairing, and I believe it is what the party really fears. The question is also, if Clinton wins the superdelegate majority, how does she get it? She could surprise us. One thing that should not be forgotten is her tenacity. Clinton has jumped every hurdle, in spite of serious doubts every time. If Clinton wins the nomination, the onus will be heavy on her to prove she did it fairly. If Obama wins the nomination, I think there could be a third scenario: Obama offers the VP slot to Clinton. Conventional thinking says she would not take it. I don't know. I think, the same as I think about Obama, she would take it if she knew she was out otherwise. I name this one third however, because I think it is the least likely. I don't think the vice presidency holds much interest for Sen. Clinton, and her path will take her elsewhere if she is not the nominee. I also think that on a combined ticket, people would prefer Clinton-Obama. Compared to each other, people can't seem to decide, but together, Clinton's experience becomes a positive.
A combined ticket does seem like the best of both worlds. The issue, which has been spelled out plainly by both candidates is: I am running for president, not vice president. Pelosi is right to say it is unfair to pose these questions yet. But, a final irony is that the Dream Ticket would be a win-win compromise, but would require the front runner to concede. Again, let me reiterate, I believe the only realistic Dream Ticket, for all stated reasons, is Clinton-Obama, which means Clinton has to pull off a win. This means that Clinton's primary opponent is still Obama, which means she still has to campaign against him. With the GOP focusing on Obama, too, Clinton can reap the benefits, but has to do so 100% passively. A very delicate balancing act is beginning to play out. Both campaigns are sensitive to negative tactics now, but they cannot entirely abandon them. The answer to this is to start praising each other, and to focus on similarities, and the more they do that, the more this Dream Ticket is going to get talked about. I wouldn't be surprised to see it at least discussed, but the Democratic nomination has to be settled first.
I want to talk about this "Dream Ticket" some more. I don't agree with Nancy Pelosi that it is necessarily a bad idea. The reason I point out Pelosi to disagree with is because I think her perspective is very interesting if you think about it. She must be torn in one way. Her constituency, California, supports Clinton by the broad strokes. However, I'd say in the fuzzy area of demeanor, she has indicated a leaning toward Obama. Pelosi has flexed her political muscles in subtle ways, stressing always the importance of a Democratic win in November. I find it curious that she is continually the one who is publicly commenting on the "Dream Ticket," and continually condemning it. Her role as Permanent Chair of the 2008 Democratic Convention puts her in a precarious position, but I think something she said that has been largely overlooked sheds light on her attitude: Pelosi did concede that if Obama and Clinton think the Dream Ticket is a good idea, "maybe it is." She indicated in no uncertain terms that the nominee should be allowed to pick their own running mate, and that "thrusting" the decision on them now was unfair. Both candidates have also indicated this same attitude, both have refused to answer questions about vice presidential choices at all.
The word "stalemate" is already hitting the media. Clinton's popular vote argument is very convincing for one reason alone: regardless of the rules which currently exclude Florida and Michigan from pledging delegates to a candidate, those votes were cast and represent the will of millions of voters. Two state Democratic parties broke the rules. Conscientious voters who went and voted when they had the chance to do so did not. This does not change Obama's delegate lead. What we are seeing already is a growing argument about what is the most accurate reflection of the will of the people: the delegate count or the raw votes. This argument was central to the General Election controversies of 2000, and the Supreme Court ultimately broke in favor of the electoral vote. It can only be salt on the wound that Florida is, once again, central to the conflict. Although it has quickly become a footnote to the overall situation, it cannot be ignored that a Republican controlled state is causing political problems for the Democratic party, again. The Supreme Court will not get to rule on this problem, however. Democrats have to work it out for themselves. Smartly, Clinton is allowing the delegate battles in Florida and Michigan to play out now largely in the background. Both states are lobbying the DNC for a reversal of the penalties on their states or a compromise, and will be petitioning the Rules & Bylaws committee soon. The underlying tension is increased by Clinton's strong performance in Florida against McCain, and the implication that disenfranchising Florida democrats early in the process would undermine potential successes in November.
Clinton's potent showing in head-to-heads vs. McCain (she loses by only 0.3%) in Florida shows the potential for a big upset; Florida is a solid Red state, and taking it from the GOP in November would be a huge advantage. Obama shows no such competitiveness in Florida, and also loses to McCain in Pennsylvania and Ohio, two more states Clinton wins convincingly. This, combined with the visceral reality of the popular vote are serious and compelling arguments. Democrats really cannot risk being seen as willfully excluding people from the process. On the other hand, Obama has an equally strong argument that the rules are the rules, everyone knew them, and following those rules, he is winning. It is ironic for both candidates. Obama, the unifier, says a million and a half votes don't count. Clinton, the underdog, is claiming to be the winner based on results she publicly said were "beauty contests." If Florida and Michigan prevail before the Rules & Bylaws committee, the popular vote count becomes even more valid. I see more indications that they will be included than not, and Democratic leadership showing attitudes of cooperation and open mindedness.
So, what happens if we get to June 3rd and it's a draw? I've seen the possibility of a statistical tie growing greater and greater with each contest. No one wants to talk about it because in one way it would be the worst possible outcome. Exit poll results indicate extreme loyalties to both candidates, and there can be no ignoring the all out war that is being waged in the blogsphere. The exit polls also indicate a hypocrisy in voting trends. The majority of exit polls indicate that race and gender had little to do with their choice, while voting trends clearly indicate women breaking for Clinton and African Americans breaking for Obama. More irony as well in their big bloc bases; Clinton is a member of the rich elite with lengthly involvement at the highest levels of government, but the working class and the lower educated prefer her. Obama comes from a very modest background and got most of his political training in the poor neighborhoods of Chicago, one of the ultimate working class cities, but the rich and affluent prefer him.
Even on the issues, I believe we see what amounts to a tie. Clinton is winning in general on the Economy and Health Care. This alone would be an argument greatly in favor of Clinton except for one thing: Iraq. Obama is clearly winning the Iraq debate on both fronts. The issues Republicans and Democrats vote on are different, but foreign relations are a shared issue almost all the time. Iraq is the #2 issue between both parties, and Obama has both a higher moral stance than Clinton and a more popular stance than McCain. Because she voted to authorize the war, Clinton faces a serious issue of voter confidence on Iraq, and this would be a serious liability against McCain. This is where the Independents come in, and where their bloc matters. If McCain can make Clinton look wishy washy or untrustworthy on foreign relations, her other arguments fall apart. One of Clinton's strengths is that she sees opportunities to dovetail many broad projects and policies together to increase the effectiveness of all of them. But, that also means you have to be willing to buy the whole package. So, although Clinton takes two out of three major issues for Democrats, the main debatable issue in the General Election will be Iraq, where Obama is the clear winner. Clinton's main counter to that will be the other shared issue, Experience, which has played itself out this election cycle in the "3am War." McCain has even co-opted the 3am catch phrase. Even though McCain does in fact have the most experience, Clinton will be much more able to neutralize that argument.
I see an image irony as well, that creates a sort of tie of its own. Clinton has called Obama's character into question based on his associations with less than desirable individuals, yet the Clinton's combined have a laundry list of shady associates. Conversely, Obama has sold himself as a bipartisan unifier and challenged Clinton on her voting record, when their voting records show that Clinton has sponsored much more bipartisan legislature than him; Obama in fact holds the current voting record for most liberal Senator. Again, ironically, Obama's uber-liberalism is what makes people believe he would straddle the aisle as President. Clinton has been caught in more than one "misstatement," on the campaign trail (which is code for "she lied") and this has underscored her low scores on trustworthiness, and is pointed to as one of the reasons she cannot seem to connect with people like Obama can. Clinton has addressed these indiscretions by saying, in essence, "Look, we're all tired. This is a very stressful time. We make mistakes." She has asked to be forgiven based on being human, offering a connection in the most ironic way. Lastly, there is arrogance vs. entitlement. I have long been criticizing Obama's arrogance. I believe he displays the sense of entitlement that Clinton is vetted for having. Moreover, Clinton's sense of entitlement to the Presidency is very much in line with the sentiment of the party in general, yet she looks like a crony for it. On the other hand, Obama's youthful and exuberant promises of hope and prosperity are precisely what makes him so attractive to voters, and a liability to the party. We love Obama because he is a true liberal, but that makes him a risky bet.
The backdrop of all of this is somewhere in the area of 30 million voters, double the voter turnout of any presidential primary. This is roughly equivalent to the jump in voter turnout between 2000 and 2004 in the general election, and can be taken as a very good sign. The Democratic party is also reporting record numbers of new registrants, also good. While voters are showing signs of fatigue in terms of paying attention, no one seems to want the contest to end prematurely. Everyone from the candidates to the party leaders to the exit pollers have indicated an interest in seeing the entire contest play out.
Let's talk about this Dream Ticket some more. Even after all this time, I think the main objection to the Dream Ticket is that the only way anyone can imagine a combined ticket is with Clinton on the top of it. Of course, as the race stands now, this would mean Obama would be conceding the race when he was ahead. This is the same argument Clinton has used for staying in the race this long, in spite of serious questions about her viability before March 4th. Now that she has won 4 out of the last 6 contests, is showing a very good chance of closing the popular vote gap, and has demonstrated a very valid big state strategy, the game is changed.
I see three scenarios where the Dream Ticket could happen. First, Clinton wins the delegate race, obviously with superdelegate backing, and offers the VP slot to Obama. I am sure he would take it if he knew he was out otherwise. Second, Clinton exercises her right to stay in the race, which is indisputably hers, and fully within the rules. She can force a brokered convention, regardless of what we think about if she should or not. She can do it. If she does, I could see a Clinton-Obama ticket emerging as the compromise to prevent a nasty floor battle in Denver. It would be very hard to spin this as a genuine pairing, and I believe it is what the party really fears. The question is also, if Clinton wins the superdelegate majority, how does she get it? She could surprise us. One thing that should not be forgotten is her tenacity. Clinton has jumped every hurdle, in spite of serious doubts every time. If Clinton wins the nomination, the onus will be heavy on her to prove she did it fairly. If Obama wins the nomination, I think there could be a third scenario: Obama offers the VP slot to Clinton. Conventional thinking says she would not take it. I don't know. I think, the same as I think about Obama, she would take it if she knew she was out otherwise. I name this one third however, because I think it is the least likely. I don't think the vice presidency holds much interest for Sen. Clinton, and her path will take her elsewhere if she is not the nominee. I also think that on a combined ticket, people would prefer Clinton-Obama. Compared to each other, people can't seem to decide, but together, Clinton's experience becomes a positive.
A combined ticket does seem like the best of both worlds. The issue, which has been spelled out plainly by both candidates is: I am running for president, not vice president. Pelosi is right to say it is unfair to pose these questions yet. But, a final irony is that the Dream Ticket would be a win-win compromise, but would require the front runner to concede. Again, let me reiterate, I believe the only realistic Dream Ticket, for all stated reasons, is Clinton-Obama, which means Clinton has to pull off a win. This means that Clinton's primary opponent is still Obama, which means she still has to campaign against him. With the GOP focusing on Obama, too, Clinton can reap the benefits, but has to do so 100% passively. A very delicate balancing act is beginning to play out. Both campaigns are sensitive to negative tactics now, but they cannot entirely abandon them. The answer to this is to start praising each other, and to focus on similarities, and the more they do that, the more this Dream Ticket is going to get talked about. I wouldn't be surprised to see it at least discussed, but the Democratic nomination has to be settled first.
Labels:
barack obama,
campaign 2008,
hillary clinton,
nancy pelosi,
US Politics
Friday, April 25, 2008
Bits & Pieces, Evening Edition
- Now that it's become faux pas for the actual candidates to attack each other, the campaign staff are squaring off in public:
Geoff Garin, (Clinton) vs. David Plouffe, (Obama) - It seems Hillary got some oratory coaching. If she had been giving speeches like this since the beginning, she'd probably be way ahead.
- Here's an interesting SurveyUSA.com poll released about two hours before the polls closed in Pennsylvania. The broad strokes: the majority polled believe Clinton should stay in even if she loses PA, that the two should continue to run separate campaigns, but if they were to join up for the "dream team", the majority (particularly Democrats by 20 points) would prefer Clinton on the top of the ticket.
- Coincidence? Nancy Pelosi once again says the "dream ticket" is a bad idea.
- I'm not so sure what a bad idea the dream team is. It seems to me they've had worse ideas, and even worse ideas, even worse ones and another terrible idea, and another one, and another one here, not so long ago. It seems to me, the Democrats have had one good idea in the last 27 years, and his name was Clinton. In the last 45 years, we have only had 4 Democratic presidents, and only one of them served two full terms. It's been almost 40 years since we've had two consecutive Democratic presidents, and 147 years since we had a two Democrats in a row where the 2nd on actually won his first term (instead of succeeding a dead president.) I'm not sure the Democrats know what a good idea is or isn't. What's so wrong with this Dream Team?
Thursday, April 24, 2008
It's Time To Listen To The Boos
So, Sen. Obama claims to be the Great Unifier. Much of his campaign is premised on drawing people together, working for shared prosperity and shared goals. This is code for, "I will encourage and employ bipartisan policy in my Presidency." Ignoring the fact that, in our current political climate, this means huge disagreements, massively organized power struggles and endless bickering about balance and representation... I find it curious that Sen. Clinton is getting slammed for using "Republican" tactics in her Democratic campaign. Further, I find it curious that she is getting slammed for already being closer to the center than Obama. I wonder exactly what the Most Liberal Senator In America's plan is for drawing the GOP into his loving embrace?
Everyone has been waiting for the Obama Grand Slam and it has not come. He's had every chance to knock Clinton out of the race, and he can't do it. He's won more states, spend more money by 300%, and racked up a formidable delegate lead. He's clearly the more liberal, and clearly attracts a more educated crowd. This presumption however may be the problem: the very condescending implication that just because people with PhD's like him better, he'd be a better president. His lack of ability to close the deal with working class white voters is a very serious weakness, and one that is getting underscored a little heavier with each passing contest.
I don't think it says he would lose in November. I do believe that Democrats are going to vote Democrat in November, and the GOP is at a huge disadvantage. However, I do think that Clinton represents a known quantity, and stands a much better chance of avoiding "buyer's remorse" as President. She has not promised to salvage American souls. She has not promised to bring everyone together like a Coke commercial. She has taken a good deal of flak for negative campaigning (ignoring, again, that Obama has done exactly the same) but in reality, her campaign promises have stayed rooted in reality. She has said, "I will fix NAFTA, I will get health care for every American, and I will dovetail economic fixes with environmental fixes." Honestly, I think both of them are offering rhetoric on Iraq and not much else. They both say they are committed to ending the Iraq problem, and I honestly don't think it matters who did or didn't vote for it. It only matters what they will do, and they will do just about the same thing in that area. Obama's "change and hope" chant is starting to sound hollow, particularly after his clumsy handling of the "gods and guns" situation. He truly exposed an elitist and condescending view of the working class, the way only someone who started there and rose above it can.
Since the Pennsylvania primary, it has become abundantly clear to me that the Democratic race is no longer about the primaries. It is about convincing the superdelegates who to support. Likely, this has been true since Super Tuesday, but there were some fairly large states still to vote at that point, so we could tell ourselves it was about "the people." Now, we can spend the next 6 weeks micro-analyzing primary results, exit polls, and beating to death horses that we've already been riding for a year. There are no new arguments. There are no new news stories. The Al Gore rumors are cropping up again. The "will Dems destroy themselves" arguments are flying again. The Florida and Michigan arguments are getting the scabs picked off again.
I think the only safe and logical place for the Democratic battle to go is towards McCain and towards the issues. We've had a very big departure, as both Democratic candidates waded into a mud slinging fest between March 4th and April 22nd, the full spectrum of Silly Season. We all knew it was coming, both Dems and the GOP all warned about it, and yet we have the audacity to act surprised when it did. Come on. At this point, we have seen both Obama and Clinton multiple times get booed when they started ripping into each other, or even hinting that they might. Everyone's sick of it. The real damage to the Democratic campaign in November is not what either one of the current Democratic candidates may say and do to each other, but what they are doing to the image of the campaign itself. If they allow themselves to completely dissolve into further bickering and cherry picking of he-said/she-said, the image of Democrats in general is going to get hurt, maybe critically hurt. It's time to listen to the boos and refocus.
Eventually, either Clinton or Obama is going to be the Democratic nominee.
Let that one sink in for a second. At this point, I think there is no surety for either of them. And, what we've known since at least March 4th is that the superdelegates are going to make the call. Let that one sink in too. This amorphous "the people" have also had every chance to break for one or the other, and they haven't been able to do it, either. That is precisely why superdelegates exist. It is why the electoral model exists. I believe there is no ignoring the fact at this point that the Democratic battle is going to be settled on the Convention floor, even if the "real" decision is made by July 1st, like Howard Dean wants. I believe both Obama and Clinton have no choice but to start directly campaigning for superdelegate backing. The way they frame the remaining nominating contests will be about how the superdelegates view the results, not about the actual results. Clinton may well be able to close the popular vote gap between now and the first week of June. Obama very likely will maintain his delegate lead. Then, they have to face off over which is more important: accrued delegates or accrued votes. The reality post-Pennsylvania is that not much changed on the broadest strokes of the math. However, underneath that, we do see a dramatic divide, and Clinton is not wrong that the tide may in fact be turning. She says this to imply that she is winning now, which may or may not be true. What is actually turning her way is her argument that she is more electable. Again, this does not automatically imply that Obama is unelectable. Going into the upcoming primaries, we'll see what it really means. The case is not as open and shut as either campaign wants us to think.
Everyone has been waiting for the Obama Grand Slam and it has not come. He's had every chance to knock Clinton out of the race, and he can't do it. He's won more states, spend more money by 300%, and racked up a formidable delegate lead. He's clearly the more liberal, and clearly attracts a more educated crowd. This presumption however may be the problem: the very condescending implication that just because people with PhD's like him better, he'd be a better president. His lack of ability to close the deal with working class white voters is a very serious weakness, and one that is getting underscored a little heavier with each passing contest.
I don't think it says he would lose in November. I do believe that Democrats are going to vote Democrat in November, and the GOP is at a huge disadvantage. However, I do think that Clinton represents a known quantity, and stands a much better chance of avoiding "buyer's remorse" as President. She has not promised to salvage American souls. She has not promised to bring everyone together like a Coke commercial. She has taken a good deal of flak for negative campaigning (ignoring, again, that Obama has done exactly the same) but in reality, her campaign promises have stayed rooted in reality. She has said, "I will fix NAFTA, I will get health care for every American, and I will dovetail economic fixes with environmental fixes." Honestly, I think both of them are offering rhetoric on Iraq and not much else. They both say they are committed to ending the Iraq problem, and I honestly don't think it matters who did or didn't vote for it. It only matters what they will do, and they will do just about the same thing in that area. Obama's "change and hope" chant is starting to sound hollow, particularly after his clumsy handling of the "gods and guns" situation. He truly exposed an elitist and condescending view of the working class, the way only someone who started there and rose above it can.
Since the Pennsylvania primary, it has become abundantly clear to me that the Democratic race is no longer about the primaries. It is about convincing the superdelegates who to support. Likely, this has been true since Super Tuesday, but there were some fairly large states still to vote at that point, so we could tell ourselves it was about "the people." Now, we can spend the next 6 weeks micro-analyzing primary results, exit polls, and beating to death horses that we've already been riding for a year. There are no new arguments. There are no new news stories. The Al Gore rumors are cropping up again. The "will Dems destroy themselves" arguments are flying again. The Florida and Michigan arguments are getting the scabs picked off again.
I think the only safe and logical place for the Democratic battle to go is towards McCain and towards the issues. We've had a very big departure, as both Democratic candidates waded into a mud slinging fest between March 4th and April 22nd, the full spectrum of Silly Season. We all knew it was coming, both Dems and the GOP all warned about it, and yet we have the audacity to act surprised when it did. Come on. At this point, we have seen both Obama and Clinton multiple times get booed when they started ripping into each other, or even hinting that they might. Everyone's sick of it. The real damage to the Democratic campaign in November is not what either one of the current Democratic candidates may say and do to each other, but what they are doing to the image of the campaign itself. If they allow themselves to completely dissolve into further bickering and cherry picking of he-said/she-said, the image of Democrats in general is going to get hurt, maybe critically hurt. It's time to listen to the boos and refocus.
Eventually, either Clinton or Obama is going to be the Democratic nominee.
Let that one sink in for a second. At this point, I think there is no surety for either of them. And, what we've known since at least March 4th is that the superdelegates are going to make the call. Let that one sink in too. This amorphous "the people" have also had every chance to break for one or the other, and they haven't been able to do it, either. That is precisely why superdelegates exist. It is why the electoral model exists. I believe there is no ignoring the fact at this point that the Democratic battle is going to be settled on the Convention floor, even if the "real" decision is made by July 1st, like Howard Dean wants. I believe both Obama and Clinton have no choice but to start directly campaigning for superdelegate backing. The way they frame the remaining nominating contests will be about how the superdelegates view the results, not about the actual results. Clinton may well be able to close the popular vote gap between now and the first week of June. Obama very likely will maintain his delegate lead. Then, they have to face off over which is more important: accrued delegates or accrued votes. The reality post-Pennsylvania is that not much changed on the broadest strokes of the math. However, underneath that, we do see a dramatic divide, and Clinton is not wrong that the tide may in fact be turning. She says this to imply that she is winning now, which may or may not be true. What is actually turning her way is her argument that she is more electable. Again, this does not automatically imply that Obama is unelectable. Going into the upcoming primaries, we'll see what it really means. The case is not as open and shut as either campaign wants us to think.
Wednesday, April 23, 2008
Pennsylvania Very Good for Clinton, Dems In General
One thing the Pennsylvania primaries made very clear: the GOP really is going to have to struggle to keep up. Both Democrats each individually drew more votes yesterday than the total Republican voters between all GOP candidates (Ron Paul and Mike Huckabee were both on the PA ballot for the GOP, and got crushed by McCain, of course.) Just over 804,000 voters participated in the GOP primary, versus 2.3 Million voters on the Democrat side. That means Democrats outnumbered Republicans at the polls almost 3-to-1.
Another thing that seems clear: Obama's $11 million dollar act of desperation won him a lopsided victory in Philadelphia. If you look at the county level results, Clinton demolished him in the state wide contest. The majority of her victories are in the 60-75% range, with Obama taking the urban demographic by a 14 point lead. Once more, Jay Cost at RealClearPolitics.com has already published a very thorough analysis of the PA demographics here, which demonstrates Clinton's true success in Pennsylvania. She exceeded expectations, and once again did what they said she needed to do: score a double digit victory. And, just like every other time, as soon as Clinton jumps another hurdle they put another one in front of her.
Something that should not be ignored is that as of yesterday, Clinton closed the popular vote gap, and pulled ahead. How, you ask? Yes, with those pesky little impatient states Florida and Michigan. Even if delegates never get seated from the two contested states, the voters cannot be ignored. Can you imagine the GOP media heyday? "Democrats don't like to count all the votes." The only reason FL and MI have not been settled yet is because Obama keeps saying no. He doesn't want those states to count, because it is becoming increasingly clear that they erase his popular vote lead, something he desperately needs in order to keep his front-runner status. His electability was already in question, and now that Clinton has cinched up another critical big, working class state, it is in dire jeopardy. I honestly cannot see how the superdelegates could get behind Obama if his electability is seriously challenged, and it has been. The Obama campaign is still pounding on the "can't pass me in delegate count" drum, but the fact is, Clinton can pass him in the delegate count, so long as she maintains her superdelegate lead, which she is doing. She's hanging onto it by the skin of her teeth, but she's doing it.
Obama made a huge stand in Pennsylvania, even going so far as to briefly pontificate that they might pull off a win in the Keystone State. By a multi-million dollar long shot, the Obama campaign staged the biggest, most expensive, most intense campaign for Pennsylvania, and in the end could not deny Clinton a double digit win. Obama has accused Clinton of throwing the kitchen sink at him, but it looks to me like it was the other way around, and he still lost. Clinton won every major demographic in Pennsylvania, even taking the post graduate vote which usually goes to Obama. She also demolished him on the issues, beating him on the Economy (the biggest issue in PA and in the election overall by far) by 16 points, and Health care by 8. Obama took Iraq by 10 points, and still maintained his lead in young voters. The working class, and women surged out in favor of Clinton, giving her a smashing lead in the area of 25-30 points. Obama managed to draw the averages down to 10 points by taking Philadelphia whose population is heavily disproportionate to the rest of the state. Was it a well spent 11 million? When it's all said and done, I doubt it. I think the huge struggle which resulted in a still-resounding loss says all it needs to say.
Watching the post primary coverage last night, something struck me as very apropos. While Clinton was giving her victory speech the crowd started chanting, "Yes we will, Yes we will, Yes we will!" Later, watching Obama's speech, the crowd was chanting, "Yes we can, yes we can, yes we can!" I immediately thought to myself, Yep, maybe Obama can, but Clinton will. Clinton avoided discussing Obama almost completely in her victory speech except to acknowledge that it was a hard fought battle on both sides. When it appeared she was going to say something negative, she got booed, but it quickly turned back to loud cheering when she plugged her website and made a plea for donations. Another thing that is clear, even Clinton supporters are tied of the negative campaigning. Obama's post primary speech consisted mostly of his new stump points, which are largely anti-Clinton, and barely veiled.
Anyone who was ready to write Clinton off got another nasty surprise. In less than 12 hours, the Clinton campaign is reporting $3.5 million in donations, she has regained her national head-to-head win over McCain, and she's added another key state to her big state strategy. The punditry is calling it everything from a big win to a stalemate, but I believe the reality is this is a major win for Clinton. Her biggest campaign strength, electability, just got a massive injection of validity and her momentum has gone from a slow roll to a steady gait.
Another thing that seems clear: Obama's $11 million dollar act of desperation won him a lopsided victory in Philadelphia. If you look at the county level results, Clinton demolished him in the state wide contest. The majority of her victories are in the 60-75% range, with Obama taking the urban demographic by a 14 point lead. Once more, Jay Cost at RealClearPolitics.com has already published a very thorough analysis of the PA demographics here, which demonstrates Clinton's true success in Pennsylvania. She exceeded expectations, and once again did what they said she needed to do: score a double digit victory. And, just like every other time, as soon as Clinton jumps another hurdle they put another one in front of her.
Something that should not be ignored is that as of yesterday, Clinton closed the popular vote gap, and pulled ahead. How, you ask? Yes, with those pesky little impatient states Florida and Michigan. Even if delegates never get seated from the two contested states, the voters cannot be ignored. Can you imagine the GOP media heyday? "Democrats don't like to count all the votes." The only reason FL and MI have not been settled yet is because Obama keeps saying no. He doesn't want those states to count, because it is becoming increasingly clear that they erase his popular vote lead, something he desperately needs in order to keep his front-runner status. His electability was already in question, and now that Clinton has cinched up another critical big, working class state, it is in dire jeopardy. I honestly cannot see how the superdelegates could get behind Obama if his electability is seriously challenged, and it has been. The Obama campaign is still pounding on the "can't pass me in delegate count" drum, but the fact is, Clinton can pass him in the delegate count, so long as she maintains her superdelegate lead, which she is doing. She's hanging onto it by the skin of her teeth, but she's doing it.
Obama made a huge stand in Pennsylvania, even going so far as to briefly pontificate that they might pull off a win in the Keystone State. By a multi-million dollar long shot, the Obama campaign staged the biggest, most expensive, most intense campaign for Pennsylvania, and in the end could not deny Clinton a double digit win. Obama has accused Clinton of throwing the kitchen sink at him, but it looks to me like it was the other way around, and he still lost. Clinton won every major demographic in Pennsylvania, even taking the post graduate vote which usually goes to Obama. She also demolished him on the issues, beating him on the Economy (the biggest issue in PA and in the election overall by far) by 16 points, and Health care by 8. Obama took Iraq by 10 points, and still maintained his lead in young voters. The working class, and women surged out in favor of Clinton, giving her a smashing lead in the area of 25-30 points. Obama managed to draw the averages down to 10 points by taking Philadelphia whose population is heavily disproportionate to the rest of the state. Was it a well spent 11 million? When it's all said and done, I doubt it. I think the huge struggle which resulted in a still-resounding loss says all it needs to say.
Watching the post primary coverage last night, something struck me as very apropos. While Clinton was giving her victory speech the crowd started chanting, "Yes we will, Yes we will, Yes we will!" Later, watching Obama's speech, the crowd was chanting, "Yes we can, yes we can, yes we can!" I immediately thought to myself, Yep, maybe Obama can, but Clinton will. Clinton avoided discussing Obama almost completely in her victory speech except to acknowledge that it was a hard fought battle on both sides. When it appeared she was going to say something negative, she got booed, but it quickly turned back to loud cheering when she plugged her website and made a plea for donations. Another thing that is clear, even Clinton supporters are tied of the negative campaigning. Obama's post primary speech consisted mostly of his new stump points, which are largely anti-Clinton, and barely veiled.
Anyone who was ready to write Clinton off got another nasty surprise. In less than 12 hours, the Clinton campaign is reporting $3.5 million in donations, she has regained her national head-to-head win over McCain, and she's added another key state to her big state strategy. The punditry is calling it everything from a big win to a stalemate, but I believe the reality is this is a major win for Clinton. Her biggest campaign strength, electability, just got a massive injection of validity and her momentum has gone from a slow roll to a steady gait.
Labels:
barack obama,
campaign 2008,
GOP,
hillary clinton,
US Politics
Sunday, April 20, 2008
Clinton Leads In 14-State Survey
On Thursday, April 17th, SurveyUSA released 14 state level head-to-heads comparing McCain vs. Clinton and McCain vs. Obama. While both Democrats soundly beat McCain, the results dramatically favor Clinton. The 14 states surveyed represent 27.5% of states and 38.5% of available electoral votes. The sampling is slightly heavier than the average nationwide electoral count, and only 3 Red states are polled. It is certainly not a perfect sample, but it is geographically decent cross section. Before I get into any details, let me say, I think the news is not as dire as it looks for McCain, and overall it is very reassuring news for Democrats. However, I also believe it demonstrates strong support for Clinton's greater electability claim.
Here are a few highlights from the results: (A simple percentage list can be found here.)
No matter how you cut the data, it looks better for Clinton. By electoral weight, she performs nearly 20% stronger than Obama. I can hear the argument already, "Obama is ahead in the Democratic race, and they both win, so Obama must be the nomineee." I find two things wrong with that. First of all, Obama's lead could still be lost, and the electability argument is going to figure in. Second, I believe the loud and clear Democratic mission is: we must have a Democratic president; if we are taking no chances, we should pick the person who performs the strongest against McCain. These 14 states definitely do not tell the whole story, and there are still 9 more nominating contests that will no doubt greatly effect the outcome. But, as I've said, I believe the data greatly favors Clinton.
Here are a few highlights from the results: (A simple percentage list can be found here.)
- 3 Red states were polled (Alabama, Kansas & Virginia), 8 Blule States (California, Iowa, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New Mexico, New York, Oregon and Wisconsin) and 3 Swing States (Kentucky, Missouri and Ohio.)
- Overall, in electoral value, Clinton beats McCain, 77%-23%
- Overall, in electoral value, Obama beats McCain, 57%-43%
- Overall, Clinton takes 1 Red state and 2 swing vs. McCain
- Overall, Obama takes 1 Swing State vs. McCain
- Overall, McCain takes 1 swing and 1 blue vs. Clinton, and 2 swing and 1 blue vs. Obama
- Clinton and McCain are tied in Wisconsin, but Obama wins by 5 points.
- There are 4 states that only 1 Democrat wins.
1 for Obama who takes Iowa by 7 points, but McCain beats Clinton by 6 points.
3 for Clinton: New Mexico by 3 points, McCain beats Obama by 6; Ohio by 11 points, McCain beats Obama by 2; and the big upset, Red State Virginia, where Clinton demolishes McCain by 16 points, but McCain beats Obama by 8 points. - Virginia is also the only state that shows a significant variance from the Democratic primaries. Obama left Clinton in the dust in Virgina, beating her by 29 points in the Feb 12th Democratic primary. But, in the SUSA head-to-head, Clinton steals Virginia by a long way, and Obama loses it by a convincing margin. Florida polls also show Clinton having a very good chance of beating McCain as well, whereas Obama loses Florida by nearly 12 points.
- Overall, of the 14 polled, Clinton performs better in both Red and Swing states
- Of the 14 states, Clinton wins 5 states (California, Massachusetts, New York, Ohio and Virgina) by double digits and wins 10 overall. Obama has no double digit wins, but 4 states he wins by 9 points (Minnesota, Missouri, New York and Oregon) and wins 8 overall.
No matter how you cut the data, it looks better for Clinton. By electoral weight, she performs nearly 20% stronger than Obama. I can hear the argument already, "Obama is ahead in the Democratic race, and they both win, so Obama must be the nomineee." I find two things wrong with that. First of all, Obama's lead could still be lost, and the electability argument is going to figure in. Second, I believe the loud and clear Democratic mission is: we must have a Democratic president; if we are taking no chances, we should pick the person who performs the strongest against McCain. These 14 states definitely do not tell the whole story, and there are still 9 more nominating contests that will no doubt greatly effect the outcome. But, as I've said, I believe the data greatly favors Clinton.
Saturday, April 19, 2008
Morning Bits & Pieces
Obama gives Clinton the finger. Yeah, he did. You know he did.
Ace Smith Deployed to NC. The news is quoting him saying that Clinton could not win NC, it would be the "upset of the century." Downplaying NC, of course. Same thing Obama did with PA. What's interesting about this is Ace Smith himself, who I personally believe is Clinton's secret weapon. He's delivered for her every time. Deploying him to North Carolina is a pretty interesting move. It says something to the amount of damage control they feel they need to do there. It also says something about the open primary structure, which has often favored Clinton, and which Smith is an adept at working with.
Ace Smith Deployed to NC. The news is quoting him saying that Clinton could not win NC, it would be the "upset of the century." Downplaying NC, of course. Same thing Obama did with PA. What's interesting about this is Ace Smith himself, who I personally believe is Clinton's secret weapon. He's delivered for her every time. Deploying him to North Carolina is a pretty interesting move. It says something to the amount of damage control they feel they need to do there. It also says something about the open primary structure, which has often favored Clinton, and which Smith is an adept at working with.
Labels:
barack obama,
campaign 2008,
hillary clinton,
US Politics
Thursday, April 17, 2008
Democratic Debacle or Debate?
I'll admit: I watched American Idol from 9-10 last night, and used the Philadelphia debate as my flip channel. So, for the last hour of the debate, I had to depend on the Internet and the media coverage afterwards.
A few observations:
American Flag lapel pins? Come on. I'm not an Obama fan, but the moderators should not have allowed that question. How does it have even the slightest significance? I suppose, we have had to listen to months and months of commentary about Clinton's pantsuits and hairstyles, so giving 5 minutes to Obama's accessories isn't all that bad. But, it was a sneaky way to put him on the defensive about something that should be a non-issue. If you want to question his patriotism, question it. There's plenty of material. But let's leave out the stupid wardrobe questions.
As a Clinton fan, it was a little refreshing to see a debate where the moderators were out for Obama blood for a change. I haven't watched every debate, but the many I have watched have most often featured moderators going after Clinton with both barrels, while they turn the soft focus lens on Obama. The only productive outcome of this I can see (other than personal satisfaction) is that, for a change, we saw Obama scrambling to reply instead of being able to retreat to the shadows and watch Clinton get obliterated. Obama was denied his Cheshire Cat moment last night, something I have always despised. It may have been unfair to Obama, but pretty much every other debate has treated Clinton that way. A taste of his own medicine can't be that bad.
I agree with the loudest buzz out there that there were no real substantive policy questions until the second hour. When those came, I think both answered them with aplomb and depth, but quickly descended into bickering over the details of execution. At least they debated something.
I noticed that Clinton used just about every line that has ever gotten her laughter or a standing ovation in past events. She also plugged her website at every possible opportunity. She also seemed much more prepared than Obama. I'm not sure if this is because the moderators were relatively relentless on him, or because he really wasn't prepared. I'm not sure how you could go into that debate, in the current climate of the presidential race, unprepared. At times it seemed like the moderators were trying to bait him, and his indignation did carry over into the Q&A's after. It's a bitter pill to swallow, but Obama has smugly watched Clinton choke it down so many times, I can't really feel sorry for him.
Just like the Austin debate 6 weeks ago, I think if there was a winner, it was the moderators. Clinton came off as more prepared, more eloquent (seems hardly possible), and more willing to show remorse for her "gaffes." The fact that she actually said she was embarrassed by the Bosnia thing tipped the balance in my mind. Clinton often says she has apologized for something when she really hasn't, but this time, she really did. Obama came across as unapologetic (something usually ascribed to Clinton), stiff and caught off guard. Before it was over, he was showing some signs of genuine anger, and it was pretty clear he'd rather be anywhere else. As for any real debate, I think it was a tie. I don't know why anyone would expect anything different at this point.
A few observations:
American Flag lapel pins? Come on. I'm not an Obama fan, but the moderators should not have allowed that question. How does it have even the slightest significance? I suppose, we have had to listen to months and months of commentary about Clinton's pantsuits and hairstyles, so giving 5 minutes to Obama's accessories isn't all that bad. But, it was a sneaky way to put him on the defensive about something that should be a non-issue. If you want to question his patriotism, question it. There's plenty of material. But let's leave out the stupid wardrobe questions.
As a Clinton fan, it was a little refreshing to see a debate where the moderators were out for Obama blood for a change. I haven't watched every debate, but the many I have watched have most often featured moderators going after Clinton with both barrels, while they turn the soft focus lens on Obama. The only productive outcome of this I can see (other than personal satisfaction) is that, for a change, we saw Obama scrambling to reply instead of being able to retreat to the shadows and watch Clinton get obliterated. Obama was denied his Cheshire Cat moment last night, something I have always despised. It may have been unfair to Obama, but pretty much every other debate has treated Clinton that way. A taste of his own medicine can't be that bad.
I agree with the loudest buzz out there that there were no real substantive policy questions until the second hour. When those came, I think both answered them with aplomb and depth, but quickly descended into bickering over the details of execution. At least they debated something.
I noticed that Clinton used just about every line that has ever gotten her laughter or a standing ovation in past events. She also plugged her website at every possible opportunity. She also seemed much more prepared than Obama. I'm not sure if this is because the moderators were relatively relentless on him, or because he really wasn't prepared. I'm not sure how you could go into that debate, in the current climate of the presidential race, unprepared. At times it seemed like the moderators were trying to bait him, and his indignation did carry over into the Q&A's after. It's a bitter pill to swallow, but Obama has smugly watched Clinton choke it down so many times, I can't really feel sorry for him.
Just like the Austin debate 6 weeks ago, I think if there was a winner, it was the moderators. Clinton came off as more prepared, more eloquent (seems hardly possible), and more willing to show remorse for her "gaffes." The fact that she actually said she was embarrassed by the Bosnia thing tipped the balance in my mind. Clinton often says she has apologized for something when she really hasn't, but this time, she really did. Obama came across as unapologetic (something usually ascribed to Clinton), stiff and caught off guard. Before it was over, he was showing some signs of genuine anger, and it was pretty clear he'd rather be anywhere else. As for any real debate, I think it was a tie. I don't know why anyone would expect anything different at this point.
Sunday, April 13, 2008
Is Obama Tanking Himself On Purpose?
Wild Speculation Warning.
There's an interesting dovetail going on that has not gotten much notice. There is a fair argument that they are unconnected, and they may be, but I don't think so. I see Obama making big blunders while simultaneously smoothing the path for Clinton with his own words.
I have a laundry list of gripes about Barack Obama. Regardless of those, one thing I find good and refreshing about him is that he is intelligent, well spoken and insightful. At least I thought so until he called small town Pennsylvanians "bitter." His attempt to quell the flames only fanned them. What no one will say (yet) is that Obama has in essence said that the middle class is so ignorant they can't see the big picture so they "cling" to incidental issues like guns and god. Apparently he's forgotten that religious tolerance and the right to bear arms are staples of the American cultural diet. Anyone who says that I cling to my religion out of bitterness or fear has lost my vote.
I have often and harshly criticized Obama's arrogance. I believe he has crossed the line at this point from arrogance to snobbery. I hate to sound like a Clinton parrot, but he really has exposed himself as "elitist and out of touch." He's brought the same doom on himself that John Kerry did, and just like Kerry, he did it with his own words. And, like it or not, words are fair game. There is nothing wrong with Clinton or McCain jumping on it. This is a contest. And, it's not one about who runs the fastest or jumps the highest. It's about character, actions, and words. It's about convincing Americans that you are the right person to be President. What you say, and how you say it, matters. What if it was Clinton who had said something like that? Obama and the media would have ripped into her so hard she might actually be writing a concession speech by now.
Notice that this time Obama is not saying it's "fair game" (like he did over Wright.) Why? Because he knows he's in trouble over this. And he knows he said it, so he doesn't have the sidestep defense. Also, letting Clinton jump all over Wright at least gave the opportunity for her to make some kind of racist bungle. With this one, not so much. This was a gift, wrapped with a bow and hand delivered to Clinton. This could be the end of Barack Obama '08.
I'm not ready to write Obama's political obituary. People said Wright was going to sink him (and he still might) and it didn't. People said Ferraro was the end of Clinton, and before it was all said and done, Ferraro actually looked right. Both candidates have shown great elasticity and great alacrity in dealing with major blows to their campaigns. But, this is a very big blunder for Obama, and one that is going to reflect in the Pennsylvania primary nine days from now.
Here's why I ask, "Is Obama tanking himself on purpose?"
John McCain
Foremost, I believe John McCain is showing himself to be a much more formidable opponent against Obama than against Clinton. While national head-to-heads would have you believe otherwise, in state results, Clinton wins more often than Obama. Clinton also performs the strongest with the Jewish vote (i.e., Florida), Hispanics and the working class, very strong. These are critical demographics where McCain is much more competitive with Obama. McCain is also obliterating Obama on foreign relations, comprehensive views of Iraq, and on Clinton's campaign staple, experience. Democrats are largely wearing blinders to McCain's true popularity, but like it or not, Mac has stepped up to the plate and is hitting run after run. I'll say it again: I have been warning against John McCain for two years, saying he has a very real chance of winning.
Clearing The Path For Clinton
Obama said Wright was fair game. Obama said Hillary should not drop out. Obama said the primaries should run to the end. It could be argued that statements like these are designed to make him look more confident, or to assist in changing the tone of the Democratic race toward friendly. I don't think so. I think it's too late for anyone to think this race is friendly. Fairness, maybe. Friendly, hardly. The irony here is that the Democratic race has been friendly, compared to what the General is really going to be like. Again, Democrats are wearing blinders. If they really think the GOP and veiled McCain operatives are going to be nice about things like Wright and flip-flopping on gun control, they need to have another cup of coffee. At this point Clinton needs to stay in the race so that there is an option. As much as there is a fear that the Dem race is going to hurt the campaign overall, I believe there is equal fear that Democrats will lose if they choose a candidate who is too liberal, or too distanced from the working class. Obama distanced himself from the working class this weekend, a long distance.
Long Strategy
What if McCain wins? Barack Obama will not run against him in '12. If that were the case, Al Gore or John Kerry would be running now. Democrats particularly (even more so than the GOP) don't re-nominate last cycle's loser. They don't even seem to have the "runner up" mentality that the GOP has (which has been pretty effective if you look at trends.) McCain's image and his strength in the polls are altering the Democratic reality. The surety of a Democratic win in November is no longer sure, and I believe it has little to do with the long Democratic battle and much to do with McCain's general appeal. Again, like it or not, McCain is popular and he has bipartisan appeal. Obama really doesn't, and he is losing what he might have had. McCain looks more progressive on issues you would never expect from a Republican like immigration and government reform. Obama talks about using bipartisan policy and procedure while holding the record as the "most liberal" Senator in the country. The only way he is going to actually get any bipartisan support is by rejecting the Democratic agenda which at this time is rabidly anti-GOP. Don't hold your breath.
So, set yourself up for a graceful exit. Let Clinton take the fall in the fall. Sweep the Democratic primaries in '12 and kick out McCain. If that doesn't happen, and Clinton wins, it would be very easy for Obama to be cast as the "natural successor" of Clinton. I've said it before, I'll say in now: Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama can both be President, if they do it in the right order. A couple more terms in the Senate, or a successful stretch in a key administration role would easily position Obama for a true landslide down the road.
Tank But Don't Destroy
There is a line to walk. While Michelle Obama has said that there will only be one chance to vote for Obama, implying he would not run again, this is malarkey. It's very clear that Obama is upwardly mobile in government, interested in being a reformer and a decision maker, and intent on positioning himself as a liberal unifier. The campaign is not over, Obama is still holding a technical lead, and lacking any new contests to see a change (or not) in the balance, there is no reason for him to openly give signs that he might quit. However, there are very good reasons to start paving the road for post-campaign image. If Obama allows himself to be totally destroyed, it's over. This is not really the case for Clinton, who can fairly claim that there really isn't anything they can say about her she hasn't heard. The likelihood of Obama becoming a flash in the pan is much higher than for Clinton, whose name alone is a brand, and whose husband will still be an ex-President no matter what happens. Even if Obama does win the nomination, he needs to tread carefully around the Clinton machine.
In conclusion, let me say again that this is wild speculation on my part. But, I stand by my belief as well that Barack Obama really cannot win the General election. Not any more. He's alienated the working class. It cannot be ignored. The conservatives are also going to destroy him over Wright, and I believe he may have hurt himself in the black demographic, too. Call it swift boating. Call it dirty politics. Call it what you want. I don't pretend that it's not any of those things. But, I also don't pretend that those things are not real, with real effects, and real consequences. I could be wrong, but I think the truth will be told in the exit polls on April 22.
There's an interesting dovetail going on that has not gotten much notice. There is a fair argument that they are unconnected, and they may be, but I don't think so. I see Obama making big blunders while simultaneously smoothing the path for Clinton with his own words.
I have a laundry list of gripes about Barack Obama. Regardless of those, one thing I find good and refreshing about him is that he is intelligent, well spoken and insightful. At least I thought so until he called small town Pennsylvanians "bitter." His attempt to quell the flames only fanned them. What no one will say (yet) is that Obama has in essence said that the middle class is so ignorant they can't see the big picture so they "cling" to incidental issues like guns and god. Apparently he's forgotten that religious tolerance and the right to bear arms are staples of the American cultural diet. Anyone who says that I cling to my religion out of bitterness or fear has lost my vote.
I have often and harshly criticized Obama's arrogance. I believe he has crossed the line at this point from arrogance to snobbery. I hate to sound like a Clinton parrot, but he really has exposed himself as "elitist and out of touch." He's brought the same doom on himself that John Kerry did, and just like Kerry, he did it with his own words. And, like it or not, words are fair game. There is nothing wrong with Clinton or McCain jumping on it. This is a contest. And, it's not one about who runs the fastest or jumps the highest. It's about character, actions, and words. It's about convincing Americans that you are the right person to be President. What you say, and how you say it, matters. What if it was Clinton who had said something like that? Obama and the media would have ripped into her so hard she might actually be writing a concession speech by now.
Notice that this time Obama is not saying it's "fair game" (like he did over Wright.) Why? Because he knows he's in trouble over this. And he knows he said it, so he doesn't have the sidestep defense. Also, letting Clinton jump all over Wright at least gave the opportunity for her to make some kind of racist bungle. With this one, not so much. This was a gift, wrapped with a bow and hand delivered to Clinton. This could be the end of Barack Obama '08.
I'm not ready to write Obama's political obituary. People said Wright was going to sink him (and he still might) and it didn't. People said Ferraro was the end of Clinton, and before it was all said and done, Ferraro actually looked right. Both candidates have shown great elasticity and great alacrity in dealing with major blows to their campaigns. But, this is a very big blunder for Obama, and one that is going to reflect in the Pennsylvania primary nine days from now.
Here's why I ask, "Is Obama tanking himself on purpose?"
John McCain
Foremost, I believe John McCain is showing himself to be a much more formidable opponent against Obama than against Clinton. While national head-to-heads would have you believe otherwise, in state results, Clinton wins more often than Obama. Clinton also performs the strongest with the Jewish vote (i.e., Florida), Hispanics and the working class, very strong. These are critical demographics where McCain is much more competitive with Obama. McCain is also obliterating Obama on foreign relations, comprehensive views of Iraq, and on Clinton's campaign staple, experience. Democrats are largely wearing blinders to McCain's true popularity, but like it or not, Mac has stepped up to the plate and is hitting run after run. I'll say it again: I have been warning against John McCain for two years, saying he has a very real chance of winning.
Clearing The Path For Clinton
Obama said Wright was fair game. Obama said Hillary should not drop out. Obama said the primaries should run to the end. It could be argued that statements like these are designed to make him look more confident, or to assist in changing the tone of the Democratic race toward friendly. I don't think so. I think it's too late for anyone to think this race is friendly. Fairness, maybe. Friendly, hardly. The irony here is that the Democratic race has been friendly, compared to what the General is really going to be like. Again, Democrats are wearing blinders. If they really think the GOP and veiled McCain operatives are going to be nice about things like Wright and flip-flopping on gun control, they need to have another cup of coffee. At this point Clinton needs to stay in the race so that there is an option. As much as there is a fear that the Dem race is going to hurt the campaign overall, I believe there is equal fear that Democrats will lose if they choose a candidate who is too liberal, or too distanced from the working class. Obama distanced himself from the working class this weekend, a long distance.
Long Strategy
What if McCain wins? Barack Obama will not run against him in '12. If that were the case, Al Gore or John Kerry would be running now. Democrats particularly (even more so than the GOP) don't re-nominate last cycle's loser. They don't even seem to have the "runner up" mentality that the GOP has (which has been pretty effective if you look at trends.) McCain's image and his strength in the polls are altering the Democratic reality. The surety of a Democratic win in November is no longer sure, and I believe it has little to do with the long Democratic battle and much to do with McCain's general appeal. Again, like it or not, McCain is popular and he has bipartisan appeal. Obama really doesn't, and he is losing what he might have had. McCain looks more progressive on issues you would never expect from a Republican like immigration and government reform. Obama talks about using bipartisan policy and procedure while holding the record as the "most liberal" Senator in the country. The only way he is going to actually get any bipartisan support is by rejecting the Democratic agenda which at this time is rabidly anti-GOP. Don't hold your breath.
So, set yourself up for a graceful exit. Let Clinton take the fall in the fall. Sweep the Democratic primaries in '12 and kick out McCain. If that doesn't happen, and Clinton wins, it would be very easy for Obama to be cast as the "natural successor" of Clinton. I've said it before, I'll say in now: Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama can both be President, if they do it in the right order. A couple more terms in the Senate, or a successful stretch in a key administration role would easily position Obama for a true landslide down the road.
Tank But Don't Destroy
There is a line to walk. While Michelle Obama has said that there will only be one chance to vote for Obama, implying he would not run again, this is malarkey. It's very clear that Obama is upwardly mobile in government, interested in being a reformer and a decision maker, and intent on positioning himself as a liberal unifier. The campaign is not over, Obama is still holding a technical lead, and lacking any new contests to see a change (or not) in the balance, there is no reason for him to openly give signs that he might quit. However, there are very good reasons to start paving the road for post-campaign image. If Obama allows himself to be totally destroyed, it's over. This is not really the case for Clinton, who can fairly claim that there really isn't anything they can say about her she hasn't heard. The likelihood of Obama becoming a flash in the pan is much higher than for Clinton, whose name alone is a brand, and whose husband will still be an ex-President no matter what happens. Even if Obama does win the nomination, he needs to tread carefully around the Clinton machine.
In conclusion, let me say again that this is wild speculation on my part. But, I stand by my belief as well that Barack Obama really cannot win the General election. Not any more. He's alienated the working class. It cannot be ignored. The conservatives are also going to destroy him over Wright, and I believe he may have hurt himself in the black demographic, too. Call it swift boating. Call it dirty politics. Call it what you want. I don't pretend that it's not any of those things. But, I also don't pretend that those things are not real, with real effects, and real consequences. I could be wrong, but I think the truth will be told in the exit polls on April 22.
Labels:
barack obama,
campaign 2008,
hillary clinton,
john mccain,
US Politics
Monday, April 7, 2008
Staffing Changes Before Another Big Primary
Well, giving the pink slip to Patti Solis Doyle in favor of Maggie Smith seemed to work. Why not show Mark Penn the door too? In spite of the media claims that this is in some way sudden or shocking, there have actually been a list of gripes about Penn since the beginning. Mark my words -- before the end of the week they will be asking, "Was replacing Penn too little too late?" It wasn't when the Doyle-Williams transition happened, and it probably won't be this time, either. Clinton is already the presumed winner in Pennsylvania. With Texas, Ohio, and Rhode Island, it was a lot closer.
I think this is really about Maggie Williams, who knows if she had been at the reigns from the start, would be sitting at the head of a very different campaign, one that was winning by a long shot. But more than that, I believe it is a subtle message from the campaign overall that they are aware, willing and able to make big changes if those changes have merit. I think Penn crossed the line with Clinton, and she finally gave in to months of pressure to cut Penn loose. Obviously, his pro-free trade meetings with Columbian officials makes it look like Clinton is doing exactly what Obama did with the Canadian scandal. And, not giving Obama a chance to trash her over it, she shoved Penn off the bus and put the pedal to the metal. There are fairly substantiated rumors that after March 4th, Maggie Williams was pushing for nearly the entire campaign staff to resign or reapply, asserting a very strong message that loyalty to her was required for success inside the campaign machine. Clinton seems to have put the kibosh on mass firings, calling it unnecessary, but I'm certain the message was loud and clear: forget Patti, this is Maggie talking, and you better listen. No doubt Mark Penn was fairly immune to this, so if there is any victory in the Penn departure, it is for Williams.
But it could be for everyone. Penn's mainstay in campaign messaging was policy and electability over passion. First of all, I really don't think Clinton needs much bolstering on policy. Even her strongest detractors know she is a walking encyclopedia of policy. Her published policy promises are also by far more flushed out than Obama's (which does not make his less real, just less detailed). She can quote statistics and economic trends with the same ease as most people can recite the alphabet. And, electability? Honestly, I think that argument is stupid. Yes, I think Clinton is more electable than Obama, but I don't see any convincing evidence that either of them stands a better chance than the other against McCain. And the electability argument is not going to win any primaries. It may win the Convention, but it has so little to do with the popular vote and getting it, that it may well be time for Penn to have a sponge shoved in his mouth.
Now, passion on the other hand, is an entirely different ballgame, and it is one that I see Clinton finally wading into. Her campaign events are getting more emotionally charged. Her speeches are getting more Obama-like. (Ironically, his are getting more Clintonesque, as they are slowly adopting each other's platforms.) We are seeing news reports of "thousands" coming to Clinton events. Women are starting to wake up from their daze and realize they are about to count out the first viable woman for president. This "any woman but Hillary" thing is ridiculous -- what other woman? The only female politicians I could imagine having a chance for the Oval Office other than Clinton are Senator Olympia Snowe who is a Republican, Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, who is a Republican, or Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi, who may be popular now because people think she opposes Clinton, but trust me, that would get thrown in her face like napalm by feminists if she tried it. It would take about 5 minutes for the media to pick up on that one: "Pelosi trashes Clinton then tries to pick up her bid."
Clinton has plenty of passion, and it has been a largely untapped resource in her campaign strategy. She had allowed Penn to author nearly her entire visible campaign, and has left her to try to insert her own passions and her own causes mostly without help. I believe everyone knows that Hillary Clinton cares about children. She also cares about poverty. She has given some very passionate speeches about health care and the state of the world, but they have been brushed under the carpet. I think everyone would love to see a rhetoric-heavy, sermon style speech from Hillary, and she could give one. So what if her voice breaks and she sounds shrill. Bill is one of the best orators in the world, and if she let him write a speech for her, I think we would see a very different reaction to her.
Clinton's only outlet up to this point has been self-effacing humor. I think the crowning moment so far has been when she told Jay Leno that she was afraid she was going to be late for her interview with him because she was "pinned down under sniper fire." It's not the first time she has embraced criticisms of herself, and it gives light to her claims that she is already vetted, and that there is really nothing they can say about her that will give her pause. Chelsea Clinton also threw down the gauntlet by responding to questions about the Lewinsky scandal with, "It's none of your business." She followed up by saying, "...I'm sure there are things you consider private to your family, too. This is private to my family." This is ironic of course because every single detail of the Lewinsky situation is known by the world, right down to the pornographic play-by-play. What I think was accomplished by this was a very clear message from the campaign: "We are not going to let you drag Hillary through the mud for what Bill did more than 10 years ago. Find some new material."
While there is a perception that there is unlimited material for Clinton haters, I don't see much coming up. Detractors are trying as hard as they can to find something truly dishonest or shady in the Clinton tax information, and they can't. They are trying to come up with convincing evidence that Obama is going to win Pennsylvania, and they can't. They are trying to downplay the importance of Pennsylvania, and they can't. They are trying to make it look like Clinton is the cause of the problems in Michigan and Florida, and they can't. They are trying to make it look like Clinton is losing her middle class support, but they can't. Clinton shook off the Ferraro problem. She shook off the Bosnia problem. She made a preemptive strike on what could have been a Columbia problem. And now, the polls are normalizing again, and her leads in Pennsylvania and Indiana are growing again.
Clinton is not replacing Penn. Maggie Williams has stated that Geoff Garin and Howard Wolfson will step into the one man role together. They make an interesting pair, being very involved in free trade on one side, and very opposed on the other. I doubt their stances on free trade have much to do with their selection overall. I think Garin getting a bigger campaign presence is the big word. He is a big name inside the AFL-CIO, who represent a major Clinton stronghold: the working class and unions. Wolfson was one of the major players in the Clinton campaign already, but in another area all together. He was already Communications Director for the campaign, and has been a very strong voice for Clinton's experience, and Obama's lack of it. Wolfson also got his campaign notoriety by launching attacks on the Obama campaign for alleged misconduct in Texas. Put these two in a blender, with an ability to book double the hours of one person, and you get a very different message than the one Penn was offering.
I believe we are going to see a newly energized Clinton message, with a new slant toward the emotional issues of the campaign, and a freer speaking Hillary who doesn't retreat to policy and statistics so quickly. Clinton has shown that she is agile on her feet and capable of responding to unanticipated questions, but has never had the opportunity to really free form. The idea is that she would tank herself if she did, but I doubt it. Every time a glimpse of the unscripted, real, visceral Hillary has peeked through, people have loved it. The tears in New Hampshire were the extreme end of that spectrum, but I believe one of Clinton's main disadvantages up to this point has been her lack of connection with people, sharply contrasted to Obama's already legendary ability to connect. A realer Hillary is on the rise. Watch for it.
I think this is really about Maggie Williams, who knows if she had been at the reigns from the start, would be sitting at the head of a very different campaign, one that was winning by a long shot. But more than that, I believe it is a subtle message from the campaign overall that they are aware, willing and able to make big changes if those changes have merit. I think Penn crossed the line with Clinton, and she finally gave in to months of pressure to cut Penn loose. Obviously, his pro-free trade meetings with Columbian officials makes it look like Clinton is doing exactly what Obama did with the Canadian scandal. And, not giving Obama a chance to trash her over it, she shoved Penn off the bus and put the pedal to the metal. There are fairly substantiated rumors that after March 4th, Maggie Williams was pushing for nearly the entire campaign staff to resign or reapply, asserting a very strong message that loyalty to her was required for success inside the campaign machine. Clinton seems to have put the kibosh on mass firings, calling it unnecessary, but I'm certain the message was loud and clear: forget Patti, this is Maggie talking, and you better listen. No doubt Mark Penn was fairly immune to this, so if there is any victory in the Penn departure, it is for Williams.
But it could be for everyone. Penn's mainstay in campaign messaging was policy and electability over passion. First of all, I really don't think Clinton needs much bolstering on policy. Even her strongest detractors know she is a walking encyclopedia of policy. Her published policy promises are also by far more flushed out than Obama's (which does not make his less real, just less detailed). She can quote statistics and economic trends with the same ease as most people can recite the alphabet. And, electability? Honestly, I think that argument is stupid. Yes, I think Clinton is more electable than Obama, but I don't see any convincing evidence that either of them stands a better chance than the other against McCain. And the electability argument is not going to win any primaries. It may win the Convention, but it has so little to do with the popular vote and getting it, that it may well be time for Penn to have a sponge shoved in his mouth.
Now, passion on the other hand, is an entirely different ballgame, and it is one that I see Clinton finally wading into. Her campaign events are getting more emotionally charged. Her speeches are getting more Obama-like. (Ironically, his are getting more Clintonesque, as they are slowly adopting each other's platforms.) We are seeing news reports of "thousands" coming to Clinton events. Women are starting to wake up from their daze and realize they are about to count out the first viable woman for president. This "any woman but Hillary" thing is ridiculous -- what other woman? The only female politicians I could imagine having a chance for the Oval Office other than Clinton are Senator Olympia Snowe who is a Republican, Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, who is a Republican, or Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi, who may be popular now because people think she opposes Clinton, but trust me, that would get thrown in her face like napalm by feminists if she tried it. It would take about 5 minutes for the media to pick up on that one: "Pelosi trashes Clinton then tries to pick up her bid."
Clinton has plenty of passion, and it has been a largely untapped resource in her campaign strategy. She had allowed Penn to author nearly her entire visible campaign, and has left her to try to insert her own passions and her own causes mostly without help. I believe everyone knows that Hillary Clinton cares about children. She also cares about poverty. She has given some very passionate speeches about health care and the state of the world, but they have been brushed under the carpet. I think everyone would love to see a rhetoric-heavy, sermon style speech from Hillary, and she could give one. So what if her voice breaks and she sounds shrill. Bill is one of the best orators in the world, and if she let him write a speech for her, I think we would see a very different reaction to her.
Clinton's only outlet up to this point has been self-effacing humor. I think the crowning moment so far has been when she told Jay Leno that she was afraid she was going to be late for her interview with him because she was "pinned down under sniper fire." It's not the first time she has embraced criticisms of herself, and it gives light to her claims that she is already vetted, and that there is really nothing they can say about her that will give her pause. Chelsea Clinton also threw down the gauntlet by responding to questions about the Lewinsky scandal with, "It's none of your business." She followed up by saying, "...I'm sure there are things you consider private to your family, too. This is private to my family." This is ironic of course because every single detail of the Lewinsky situation is known by the world, right down to the pornographic play-by-play. What I think was accomplished by this was a very clear message from the campaign: "We are not going to let you drag Hillary through the mud for what Bill did more than 10 years ago. Find some new material."
While there is a perception that there is unlimited material for Clinton haters, I don't see much coming up. Detractors are trying as hard as they can to find something truly dishonest or shady in the Clinton tax information, and they can't. They are trying to come up with convincing evidence that Obama is going to win Pennsylvania, and they can't. They are trying to downplay the importance of Pennsylvania, and they can't. They are trying to make it look like Clinton is the cause of the problems in Michigan and Florida, and they can't. They are trying to make it look like Clinton is losing her middle class support, but they can't. Clinton shook off the Ferraro problem. She shook off the Bosnia problem. She made a preemptive strike on what could have been a Columbia problem. And now, the polls are normalizing again, and her leads in Pennsylvania and Indiana are growing again.
Clinton is not replacing Penn. Maggie Williams has stated that Geoff Garin and Howard Wolfson will step into the one man role together. They make an interesting pair, being very involved in free trade on one side, and very opposed on the other. I doubt their stances on free trade have much to do with their selection overall. I think Garin getting a bigger campaign presence is the big word. He is a big name inside the AFL-CIO, who represent a major Clinton stronghold: the working class and unions. Wolfson was one of the major players in the Clinton campaign already, but in another area all together. He was already Communications Director for the campaign, and has been a very strong voice for Clinton's experience, and Obama's lack of it. Wolfson also got his campaign notoriety by launching attacks on the Obama campaign for alleged misconduct in Texas. Put these two in a blender, with an ability to book double the hours of one person, and you get a very different message than the one Penn was offering.
I believe we are going to see a newly energized Clinton message, with a new slant toward the emotional issues of the campaign, and a freer speaking Hillary who doesn't retreat to policy and statistics so quickly. Clinton has shown that she is agile on her feet and capable of responding to unanticipated questions, but has never had the opportunity to really free form. The idea is that she would tank herself if she did, but I doubt it. Every time a glimpse of the unscripted, real, visceral Hillary has peeked through, people have loved it. The tears in New Hampshire were the extreme end of that spectrum, but I believe one of Clinton's main disadvantages up to this point has been her lack of connection with people, sharply contrasted to Obama's already legendary ability to connect. A realer Hillary is on the rise. Watch for it.
Sunday, April 6, 2008
Gender Hits The Campaign Trail
Finally. I've read a few hints here and there that pundits think Clinton "should be" playing the gender card. Obviously, with Obama trying as hard as he can not to play the race card it seems like the wrong concept. I still think it is the right one, and a very valid one. I still believe that in terms of social change and positive impact, electing a woman president is a bigger deal. The "historic" element of the 2008 presidential campaign has finally been blown wide open (it was really there all the time) so why not capitalize on it? Obama is certainly capitalizing on his "brilliant" handling of the race question with his "genius" speech.
At any rate, you be the judge. Gender is hitting the Clinton campaign:
Unfair double standard hurts Sen. Clinton
Will Hillary Clinton Lose Because Of Her Gender?
Democratic women who support Clinton rallied in front of the State House
Men, it's not your place to tell Clinton to quit the race
At any rate, you be the judge. Gender is hitting the Clinton campaign:
Unfair double standard hurts Sen. Clinton
Will Hillary Clinton Lose Because Of Her Gender?
Democratic women who support Clinton rallied in front of the State House
Men, it's not your place to tell Clinton to quit the race
Labels:
campaign 2008,
hillary clinton,
US Politics,
women in politics
Saturday, April 5, 2008
Campaign Strategy, But Whose?
OK, enough with the "Clinton should quit" stuff.
She's not going to. Everyone knows it. Barack Obama has cleared the path for her by saying he agrees the primary season should be allowed to play out. He even said mentioning Wright was fair game. Howard Dean, even Nancy Pelosi who seems to prefer Obama, have said all states are going to be heard before any decisions are made. Clinton passed the March 4 firewall, now the media is crying for her to drop out before the next nominating contest? One she is going to win? Come on.
There is also a fairly tangible sense of disappointment in the reporting of Clinton tax returns which were released yesterday. I think everyone was hoping for some new scandal to bite into, but there isn't. The only thing they can come up with so far is basically a claim that Bill Clinton is overpaid for his speeches. Big deal. The summary of the last 7 years of their tax returns also show that they paid taxes and made charitable contributions at a higher rate than taxpayers at their income level.
Now, lacking any sort of supporting data or calls from actual leaders in the Democratic party, the new media spin is, "Can Obama knock Clinton out without winning Pennsylvania?" Um, no. He can't. Not even St. Obama could pull off that miracle. Since when did winning a major nominating contest equal dropping out? Clinton is poised to win 3 out of 4 of the coming contests, and I would put money on her gaining significant momentum, in spite of the return of Obama to the spot of media darling. More like media bankroller, considering how much more money he is throwing the networks.
There is one interesting argument going around that says Obama could go for a knockout punch in PA, but the likelihood of him getting one is so small that he should back off and not waste his momentum there. If he appears to have mounted the biggest offensive of his campaign in PA, and still loses, it would look very bad for him, whereas, if he does what he has done: closes the gap significantly and then lets the chips fall where they may, there is less impact to his overall performance view. I'm not sure it's true, but it makes sense. I still think that is a gamble, but I can agree that it is a safer one than trying to score a knock out this late in the race, when everyone across the board pretty much has agreed there can't be one.
What's really going to happen, according to me is: the rest of the primaries are going to be carried out. Each candidate is going to focus their efforts on the areas that support their own case for party backing. The final agreements will be reached over Florida and Michigan. Then, the party meta structure will step in and the race will be decided with fair but quick positioning. We could still see some arguing all the way to August, and in spite of fears that it will be Clinton who causes it, I would not be surprised to see Obama complaining to the Credentials committee. Before this is all said and done, regardless of who gets the nomination, I would bet that Obama is going to be called the one who "will do anything to win."
She's not going to. Everyone knows it. Barack Obama has cleared the path for her by saying he agrees the primary season should be allowed to play out. He even said mentioning Wright was fair game. Howard Dean, even Nancy Pelosi who seems to prefer Obama, have said all states are going to be heard before any decisions are made. Clinton passed the March 4 firewall, now the media is crying for her to drop out before the next nominating contest? One she is going to win? Come on.
There is also a fairly tangible sense of disappointment in the reporting of Clinton tax returns which were released yesterday. I think everyone was hoping for some new scandal to bite into, but there isn't. The only thing they can come up with so far is basically a claim that Bill Clinton is overpaid for his speeches. Big deal. The summary of the last 7 years of their tax returns also show that they paid taxes and made charitable contributions at a higher rate than taxpayers at their income level.
Now, lacking any sort of supporting data or calls from actual leaders in the Democratic party, the new media spin is, "Can Obama knock Clinton out without winning Pennsylvania?" Um, no. He can't. Not even St. Obama could pull off that miracle. Since when did winning a major nominating contest equal dropping out? Clinton is poised to win 3 out of 4 of the coming contests, and I would put money on her gaining significant momentum, in spite of the return of Obama to the spot of media darling. More like media bankroller, considering how much more money he is throwing the networks.
There is one interesting argument going around that says Obama could go for a knockout punch in PA, but the likelihood of him getting one is so small that he should back off and not waste his momentum there. If he appears to have mounted the biggest offensive of his campaign in PA, and still loses, it would look very bad for him, whereas, if he does what he has done: closes the gap significantly and then lets the chips fall where they may, there is less impact to his overall performance view. I'm not sure it's true, but it makes sense. I still think that is a gamble, but I can agree that it is a safer one than trying to score a knock out this late in the race, when everyone across the board pretty much has agreed there can't be one.
What's really going to happen, according to me is: the rest of the primaries are going to be carried out. Each candidate is going to focus their efforts on the areas that support their own case for party backing. The final agreements will be reached over Florida and Michigan. Then, the party meta structure will step in and the race will be decided with fair but quick positioning. We could still see some arguing all the way to August, and in spite of fears that it will be Clinton who causes it, I would not be surprised to see Obama complaining to the Credentials committee. Before this is all said and done, regardless of who gets the nomination, I would bet that Obama is going to be called the one who "will do anything to win."
Labels:
barack obama,
campaign 2008,
hillary clinton,
US Politics
Thursday, April 3, 2008
Morning Bits & Pieces
The Florida and Michigan delegations are moving toward solutions.
Interestingly, as Obama is closing the gap in Pennsylvania, head-to-head matchups are favoring Clinton again.
Interestingly, as Obama is closing the gap in Pennsylvania, head-to-head matchups are favoring Clinton again.
Labels:
barack obama,
campaign 2008,
hillary clinton,
US Politics
Friday, March 28, 2008
A Triangulated Battle
So what exactly are these dire consequences to the Democratic party if Clinton and Obama drag their horse race out five more months? I don't think it is that the two are "destroying each other." I don't think it is lasting bitterness on behalf of the eventual loser's supporters. I don't think it is that the superdelegates are going to crash and burn modern democracy if they don't follow the popular vote. All of this bickering and hostility and mud slinging will be instantly forgotten once the nomination is awarded.
Calls for either Clinton or Obama to drop out have been soundly booed, even by party leadership. Even though the media is focusing on Howard Dean's call for delegates to endorse, he specifically identified his time line as after the primary season. This week, big money Clinton supporters threw down the gauntlet to Nancy Pelosi and basically said if she openly endorses Obama before the Convention, they won't open their wallets to House Democrats. MoveOn.org went wild over this and issued a rebuke. Pelosi seems to have rejected this threat, but also flexed her claws over threats to House Democrats, which tells me she takes it seriously. No matter what happens, I believe the message is loud and clear: no one is dropping out yet.
What the party leaders are afraid of is triangulation. I have long felt that voters are evaluating all three presidential candidates on a continuum from left to right, independent of party affiliation. Both the Democrats and the GOP are experiencing disturbing trends of defection. The Democratic party considers GOP defectors a success and view the Dems who are showing sympathies to McCain a sign that the internal race is harming the cause. I find it to be an exciting phenomenon, and a clear indicator that American voters are engaged in the political process. I believe this phenomenon is benefiting the Democratic party, but only because they are the only potent national venue where change is endorsed.
I also believe a sub-textual fear is that if Clinton gets the nomination, resentful voices will say Republicans tipped the balance. If that is true, it also calls into question the motives of GOP defectors, which Rush Limbaugh has already paved the road for. "Triangulation" is a dirty word to most Democrats, and it was a major bone of contention between the party and Bill Clinton. Regardless, I believe it cannot be ignored that Obama, Clinton and McCain represent a liberal-moderate-conservative scale, in that order. All scandals aside, all analysis of race, gender, and age (again, in that order) aside, what we see right now are three very viable, intelligent, and prepared candidates, all of whom have a very distinct Presidency mapped out.
Reality is finally intruding on the '08 election cycle. The economy is swiftly emerging as the big election issue. All three candidates have begun platforming economic plans, solutions to the mortgage crisis, and dovetailing their personal campaign slants in. Obama is subtly inserting his Change theme into his economic position. Clinton is doing the same with Health Care, arguably her strongest position, smartly using it as her launching pad for the rest of her economic plans. And, McCain is splashing foreign relations broadly across his whole strategy, and doing some very impressive image spinning. Both Democrats have started to focus on McCain instead of each other, which tells me, the General Election has begun.
Increasingly, I see Clinton and Obama drawing the knife edge closer instead of further apart. Currently, in head-to-heads, Obama has regained his visible lead over McCain, according to RealClearPolitics.com. However, less than one point separates all of them, and both Democrats come in at exactly 45.0%, showing they both perform the same in a head-to-head. The undecided percentages, and the margin or error erases any determining call. Pennsylvania and North Carolina have re-polarized after a few days flux toward Clinton, and are now mirrors of each other again, with the split hovering around 50-30, favoring Clinton in Penn and Obama in NC. Clinton is standing to gain more in Pennsylvania, but she has a harder climb than Obama, so the delegate-smaller state of NC is still a considerable win for Obama, too. Once more, an eye for an eye. Again, according to RCP, factoring in Florida, Michigan and estimates from states that do not report exact totals, the popular vote total is split almost exact down the middle, separated by less than 1 percent, around 200,000 votes. Depending on any number of factors from visceral things like money to the completely spontaneous, Clinton could easily make up that difference. Jay Cost has made a very compelling and thorough analysis of how the popular vote count could vary dramatically. Both have suffered very nasty blows to their image and are both still standing. Both have spouses who have been unpalatable to their campaigns. Both have had inverted victories, hedging into each other's bases equally. I believe even the Democratic voting pattern shows equal-opposite strengths. Clinton performs well with big working class states, and Obama performs well in caucuses and broadly with white men. Both inspire so much loyalty that their supporters are willing at least to threaten defection. Both represent a contradiction to the Democratic party. Clinton's sense of entitlement to the presidency is fairly consistent with the party sentiment, but find the attitude distasteful coming from Clinton. Obama represents change and coalition, but the risks involved in backing him are considerable. The true significance of the Wright scandal is that race had to come up eventually, and it will again.
Every high profile Democrat has reinforced the push for unity behind whoever wins the nomination. I believe the reason Howard Dean has said July 1st will be his personal deadline for all delegates to make up their minds is because he fears not the Convention, but a brokered convention, which is when the really ugly fighting would start. The "Al Gore Shadow Candidate" rumor is popping up again, and I still don't believe it. But, I do believe people are doing the math and realizing that even the superdelegate vote could split in such a way that neither candidate got the 2025 magic number. It could happen.
Everyone already knew this, but now that it is happening, they are realizing that instead of preventing it, they should be planning for it. Preventive strategies have failed, instead fueling the debates. Democratic leadership now has to lean toward preparing for the superdelegates to take center stage, exercise their best judgment, select a nominee, and do all of this in the most politic possible way. Doing so by July 1st gives six weeks to test the waters for the presumed nominee. Someone has to concede eventually, and if buyers remorse is going to set in, better it be while there is still an option: before the Convention. Clinton is poised for a big win in Pennsylvania, one that will net her momentum for coming wins, a delegate gain, and a major proof in her "more electable" argument. Rightly, she could at this point throw Obama's words back at him in answer to his campaign calls for her to drop out, "Why would I drop out? I'm winning." Both know the pitfalls and advantages of the frontrunner - underdog symbiosis, and both are exercising them daily. Clinton is suffering very bad right now as the underdog, but this plays directly into her comeback phenomenon. The worse it looks for her, the greater even a small victory looks. Conversely, Obama is riding the wave of his near to insurmountable lead, returning to his grand oratory style, and writing speeches that are already headed for the history books. But, he has also found out that being in the lead, even in the presumed winner's slot, does not shield him from major blows to his image or questions of his integrity, in fact it intensifies the desire for scrutiny of both. Coming out of the recent round of battle bruised but still swinging is good for him, but he should be careful to think it's over. He may have won the battle, but the war is still very much on.
McCain has realized he can't stay out of the fray. Clinton and Obama if nothing else, are giving each other excellent practice rounds. As I have said in a previous article, Clinton and Obama represent very different challenges to McCain. His answer to this is to begin positioning himself as the President people expect. Now that he has gotten the Bush endorsement, he has also begun to distance himself from Bush politics, which both Democrats have harshly criticized. McCain knows his weaknesses, and he is sidestepping them rather well. He has come across as calm, confident, and eloquent, and that is the real danger. Both Democrats have begun, by necessity to respond to McCain's forays against them, and this has drawn attention to all three as serious options. Like it or not, the presidential race is currently three-way. It is incumbent on Democrats to narrow the field to two, but all three are campaigning for President, and all three are drawing their own unique following. I believe this is what accounts for the seemingly strange movements in party affiliation and in cross-over voting. Allow me to reiterate that I find this exciting and interesting, and I see it as a sign that Americans overall are more interested in who is President, not in what party wins.
Calls for either Clinton or Obama to drop out have been soundly booed, even by party leadership. Even though the media is focusing on Howard Dean's call for delegates to endorse, he specifically identified his time line as after the primary season. This week, big money Clinton supporters threw down the gauntlet to Nancy Pelosi and basically said if she openly endorses Obama before the Convention, they won't open their wallets to House Democrats. MoveOn.org went wild over this and issued a rebuke. Pelosi seems to have rejected this threat, but also flexed her claws over threats to House Democrats, which tells me she takes it seriously. No matter what happens, I believe the message is loud and clear: no one is dropping out yet.
What the party leaders are afraid of is triangulation. I have long felt that voters are evaluating all three presidential candidates on a continuum from left to right, independent of party affiliation. Both the Democrats and the GOP are experiencing disturbing trends of defection. The Democratic party considers GOP defectors a success and view the Dems who are showing sympathies to McCain a sign that the internal race is harming the cause. I find it to be an exciting phenomenon, and a clear indicator that American voters are engaged in the political process. I believe this phenomenon is benefiting the Democratic party, but only because they are the only potent national venue where change is endorsed.
I also believe a sub-textual fear is that if Clinton gets the nomination, resentful voices will say Republicans tipped the balance. If that is true, it also calls into question the motives of GOP defectors, which Rush Limbaugh has already paved the road for. "Triangulation" is a dirty word to most Democrats, and it was a major bone of contention between the party and Bill Clinton. Regardless, I believe it cannot be ignored that Obama, Clinton and McCain represent a liberal-moderate-conservative scale, in that order. All scandals aside, all analysis of race, gender, and age (again, in that order) aside, what we see right now are three very viable, intelligent, and prepared candidates, all of whom have a very distinct Presidency mapped out.
Reality is finally intruding on the '08 election cycle. The economy is swiftly emerging as the big election issue. All three candidates have begun platforming economic plans, solutions to the mortgage crisis, and dovetailing their personal campaign slants in. Obama is subtly inserting his Change theme into his economic position. Clinton is doing the same with Health Care, arguably her strongest position, smartly using it as her launching pad for the rest of her economic plans. And, McCain is splashing foreign relations broadly across his whole strategy, and doing some very impressive image spinning. Both Democrats have started to focus on McCain instead of each other, which tells me, the General Election has begun.
Increasingly, I see Clinton and Obama drawing the knife edge closer instead of further apart. Currently, in head-to-heads, Obama has regained his visible lead over McCain, according to RealClearPolitics.com. However, less than one point separates all of them, and both Democrats come in at exactly 45.0%, showing they both perform the same in a head-to-head. The undecided percentages, and the margin or error erases any determining call. Pennsylvania and North Carolina have re-polarized after a few days flux toward Clinton, and are now mirrors of each other again, with the split hovering around 50-30, favoring Clinton in Penn and Obama in NC. Clinton is standing to gain more in Pennsylvania, but she has a harder climb than Obama, so the delegate-smaller state of NC is still a considerable win for Obama, too. Once more, an eye for an eye. Again, according to RCP, factoring in Florida, Michigan and estimates from states that do not report exact totals, the popular vote total is split almost exact down the middle, separated by less than 1 percent, around 200,000 votes. Depending on any number of factors from visceral things like money to the completely spontaneous, Clinton could easily make up that difference. Jay Cost has made a very compelling and thorough analysis of how the popular vote count could vary dramatically. Both have suffered very nasty blows to their image and are both still standing. Both have spouses who have been unpalatable to their campaigns. Both have had inverted victories, hedging into each other's bases equally. I believe even the Democratic voting pattern shows equal-opposite strengths. Clinton performs well with big working class states, and Obama performs well in caucuses and broadly with white men. Both inspire so much loyalty that their supporters are willing at least to threaten defection. Both represent a contradiction to the Democratic party. Clinton's sense of entitlement to the presidency is fairly consistent with the party sentiment, but find the attitude distasteful coming from Clinton. Obama represents change and coalition, but the risks involved in backing him are considerable. The true significance of the Wright scandal is that race had to come up eventually, and it will again.
Every high profile Democrat has reinforced the push for unity behind whoever wins the nomination. I believe the reason Howard Dean has said July 1st will be his personal deadline for all delegates to make up their minds is because he fears not the Convention, but a brokered convention, which is when the really ugly fighting would start. The "Al Gore Shadow Candidate" rumor is popping up again, and I still don't believe it. But, I do believe people are doing the math and realizing that even the superdelegate vote could split in such a way that neither candidate got the 2025 magic number. It could happen.
Everyone already knew this, but now that it is happening, they are realizing that instead of preventing it, they should be planning for it. Preventive strategies have failed, instead fueling the debates. Democratic leadership now has to lean toward preparing for the superdelegates to take center stage, exercise their best judgment, select a nominee, and do all of this in the most politic possible way. Doing so by July 1st gives six weeks to test the waters for the presumed nominee. Someone has to concede eventually, and if buyers remorse is going to set in, better it be while there is still an option: before the Convention. Clinton is poised for a big win in Pennsylvania, one that will net her momentum for coming wins, a delegate gain, and a major proof in her "more electable" argument. Rightly, she could at this point throw Obama's words back at him in answer to his campaign calls for her to drop out, "Why would I drop out? I'm winning." Both know the pitfalls and advantages of the frontrunner - underdog symbiosis, and both are exercising them daily. Clinton is suffering very bad right now as the underdog, but this plays directly into her comeback phenomenon. The worse it looks for her, the greater even a small victory looks. Conversely, Obama is riding the wave of his near to insurmountable lead, returning to his grand oratory style, and writing speeches that are already headed for the history books. But, he has also found out that being in the lead, even in the presumed winner's slot, does not shield him from major blows to his image or questions of his integrity, in fact it intensifies the desire for scrutiny of both. Coming out of the recent round of battle bruised but still swinging is good for him, but he should be careful to think it's over. He may have won the battle, but the war is still very much on.
McCain has realized he can't stay out of the fray. Clinton and Obama if nothing else, are giving each other excellent practice rounds. As I have said in a previous article, Clinton and Obama represent very different challenges to McCain. His answer to this is to begin positioning himself as the President people expect. Now that he has gotten the Bush endorsement, he has also begun to distance himself from Bush politics, which both Democrats have harshly criticized. McCain knows his weaknesses, and he is sidestepping them rather well. He has come across as calm, confident, and eloquent, and that is the real danger. Both Democrats have begun, by necessity to respond to McCain's forays against them, and this has drawn attention to all three as serious options. Like it or not, the presidential race is currently three-way. It is incumbent on Democrats to narrow the field to two, but all three are campaigning for President, and all three are drawing their own unique following. I believe this is what accounts for the seemingly strange movements in party affiliation and in cross-over voting. Allow me to reiterate that I find this exciting and interesting, and I see it as a sign that Americans overall are more interested in who is President, not in what party wins.
Labels:
barack obama,
democrats,
DNC,
general election,
GOP,
hillary clinton,
john mccain,
superdelegates,
US Politics
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)