Do the ends justify the means? It certainly looks like the defeat of Nancy Pelosi will be the end of the "torture gate" scandal, whose means I find very questionable.
This morning, the Washington Post is indirectly pointing the finger at White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel and President Obama for allowing CIA chief Leon Panetta to bluntly accuse Pelosi of lying. They say such a blatantly (un?)political attack on a fellow Democrat could only have come from the top down, particularly considering Panetta's D. C. savvy. They say it is the same thing the Bush White House did to Trent Lott. At the same time, Politico is publishing an article called, "Conditions for a coup in Congress," implying Pelosi may be challenged, and shut out, as Speaker this year. They posit that Rep. Steny Hoyer (D-MD) would be more palatable to the White House as Speaker. They also claim it is the same thing the Clinton White House did to Newt Gingrich.
Up to this point I have defended Speaker Pelosi in this "torture gate" mess. I maintain still that she had little to do with it and that she has been scapegoated by the GOP and the former Administration. However, someone reminded me the other day that it was Pelosi who said impeachment (of Bush) was "off the table" at a time when there was considerable Congressional and popular support for such a move, and time to accomplish it. Perhaps she had little power to stop waterboarding in 2002, but she had ample power to stop George Bush in 2006, and hold the entire Administration accountable for the whole ball of wax. Instead, she opted for personal gain (using her political capitol to get elected Speaker) and refused to allow impeachment proceedings to even reach an exploratory committee. She could have stopped them. Who knows? If she had been successful, even moderately, she could have been President by now. (And people accused Hillary Clinton of being complicit with the Bush administration because of one vote...)
Again, do the ends justify the means? Possibly. When you look at the whole ball of wax, just maybe. This could all blow over, too. But it looks to me that it is steadily blowing up. Maybe my wish will come true. But what monster's head will grow back in Pelosi's place? She was such a good, loyal lap dog to President Obama when he was campaigning, up to and including making snide comments to the press about his primary challengers (and fellow Democrats.) But once she realized he would not return the favor in kind, she turned on him a little. Congress has not offered the rubber stamp they could, that's certain. And although they talk tall about how that is not the goal, and not what anyone wants... yeah, right. Every President wishes Congress would just do their will. Maybe Steny Hoyer already made some promises... or maybe Congress, and the White House are finally just sick of her.
Showing posts with label steny hoyer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label steny hoyer. Show all posts
Monday, May 18, 2009
Saturday, February 7, 2009
Still My Way Or The Highway For Pelosi
Did I say something nice about Nancy Pelosi yesterday? Allow me to take it back. Yes, I said she was "mending fences" and "taking a placating tone."
Not so much. Pretty much the moment word came out of the Senate that a deal on the stimulus had been reached, and enough GOP Senators swayed to the side of passage, she's at it again. Note that I believe the dial was turned way up on the rancor over this bill by her refusal to allow regular House rules to come to order, and for this bill to receive the daylight and due process a trillion dollar appropriations bill should get.
So, Pelosi says, "I'll restore regular rules once this stimulus bill is passed." This should be read: once I get my way, I'll throw you a bone. So, the bill passes the House. No regular rules. The Senate indicates they have reach a passable agreement, and Pelosi is already threatening to ruin it by reinserting everything the opponents of the bill hate. President Obama has called for this legislation to be on his desk by Friday the 13th. I don't see regular order in the House any time soon. And Pelosi has already let her favorite attack dog, David Obey off the chain.
I honestly don't know what kind of game Pelosi thinks she is playing. She's not doing herself any favors with anyone at this point, except her personal amen chorus of Appropriations Committee Chairman David Obey and House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer. Note that when Hoyer tried to advocate on behalf of Democratic House members asking for normal rules to be resumed, Pelosi quickly brought him to toe. The party line in the House is not the party line any more, it's the Pelosi line. Now that it appears the stimulus bill will be bounced back to the House for a joint conference session, the President has to protect his hard-fought-for bill from the meddling of his own party. All of this could have been avoided if Pelosi had allowed regular rules to resume in the House at the onset of the 111th Congress, which she gave a clear sign she had no intention of doing with her first edict. Pelosi and Obama have both jibed the GOP with comments about how "we won," and it looks more every day like rubbing salt in the wound is more important than actually getting anything done. Of course, the GOP isn't acting much better or more mature, but would you? If someone was constantly scoffing at your failures, telling you what a wreck you made of things and systematically destroying your ability to get anything done, and shutting you out of a process you have legal right and imperative to participate in? News flash, Nancy: we are still a two-party government. The GOP didn't get fired in November, and if you're not careful, you'll be lucky to be House Minority Leader by 2010.
Not so much. Pretty much the moment word came out of the Senate that a deal on the stimulus had been reached, and enough GOP Senators swayed to the side of passage, she's at it again. Note that I believe the dial was turned way up on the rancor over this bill by her refusal to allow regular House rules to come to order, and for this bill to receive the daylight and due process a trillion dollar appropriations bill should get.
So, Pelosi says, "I'll restore regular rules once this stimulus bill is passed." This should be read: once I get my way, I'll throw you a bone. So, the bill passes the House. No regular rules. The Senate indicates they have reach a passable agreement, and Pelosi is already threatening to ruin it by reinserting everything the opponents of the bill hate. President Obama has called for this legislation to be on his desk by Friday the 13th. I don't see regular order in the House any time soon. And Pelosi has already let her favorite attack dog, David Obey off the chain.
I honestly don't know what kind of game Pelosi thinks she is playing. She's not doing herself any favors with anyone at this point, except her personal amen chorus of Appropriations Committee Chairman David Obey and House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer. Note that when Hoyer tried to advocate on behalf of Democratic House members asking for normal rules to be resumed, Pelosi quickly brought him to toe. The party line in the House is not the party line any more, it's the Pelosi line. Now that it appears the stimulus bill will be bounced back to the House for a joint conference session, the President has to protect his hard-fought-for bill from the meddling of his own party. All of this could have been avoided if Pelosi had allowed regular rules to resume in the House at the onset of the 111th Congress, which she gave a clear sign she had no intention of doing with her first edict. Pelosi and Obama have both jibed the GOP with comments about how "we won," and it looks more every day like rubbing salt in the wound is more important than actually getting anything done. Of course, the GOP isn't acting much better or more mature, but would you? If someone was constantly scoffing at your failures, telling you what a wreck you made of things and systematically destroying your ability to get anything done, and shutting you out of a process you have legal right and imperative to participate in? News flash, Nancy: we are still a two-party government. The GOP didn't get fired in November, and if you're not careful, you'll be lucky to be House Minority Leader by 2010.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)