Showing posts with label superdelegates. Show all posts
Showing posts with label superdelegates. Show all posts

Thursday, April 24, 2008

It's Time To Listen To The Boos

So, Sen. Obama claims to be the Great Unifier. Much of his campaign is premised on drawing people together, working for shared prosperity and shared goals. This is code for, "I will encourage and employ bipartisan policy in my Presidency." Ignoring the fact that, in our current political climate, this means huge disagreements, massively organized power struggles and endless bickering about balance and representation... I find it curious that Sen. Clinton is getting slammed for using "Republican" tactics in her Democratic campaign. Further, I find it curious that she is getting slammed for already being closer to the center than Obama. I wonder exactly what the Most Liberal Senator In America's plan is for drawing the GOP into his loving embrace?

Everyone has been waiting for the Obama Grand Slam and it has not come. He's had every chance to knock Clinton out of the race, and he can't do it. He's won more states, spend more money by 300%, and racked up a formidable delegate lead. He's clearly the more liberal, and clearly attracts a more educated crowd. This presumption however may be the problem: the very condescending implication that just because people with PhD's like him better, he'd be a better president. His lack of ability to close the deal with working class white voters is a very serious weakness, and one that is getting underscored a little heavier with each passing contest.

I don't think it says he would lose in November. I do believe that Democrats are going to vote Democrat in November, and the GOP is at a huge disadvantage. However, I do think that Clinton represents a known quantity, and stands a much better chance of avoiding "buyer's remorse" as President. She has not promised to salvage American souls. She has not promised to bring everyone together like a Coke commercial. She has taken a good deal of flak for negative campaigning (ignoring, again, that Obama has done exactly the same) but in reality, her campaign promises have stayed rooted in reality. She has said, "I will fix NAFTA, I will get health care for every American, and I will dovetail economic fixes with environmental fixes." Honestly, I think both of them are offering rhetoric on Iraq and not much else. They both say they are committed to ending the Iraq problem, and I honestly don't think it matters who did or didn't vote for it. It only matters what they will do, and they will do just about the same thing in that area. Obama's "change and hope" chant is starting to sound hollow, particularly after his clumsy handling of the "gods and guns" situation. He truly exposed an elitist and condescending view of the working class, the way only someone who started there and rose above it can.

Since the Pennsylvania primary, it has become abundantly clear to me that the Democratic race is no longer about the primaries. It is about convincing the superdelegates who to support. Likely, this has been true since Super Tuesday, but there were some fairly large states still to vote at that point, so we could tell ourselves it was about "the people." Now, we can spend the next 6 weeks micro-analyzing primary results, exit polls, and beating to death horses that we've already been riding for a year. There are no new arguments. There are no new news stories. The Al Gore rumors are cropping up again. The "will Dems destroy themselves" arguments are flying again. The Florida and Michigan arguments are getting the scabs picked off again.

I think the only safe and logical place for the Democratic battle to go is towards McCain and towards the issues. We've had a very big departure, as both Democratic candidates waded into a mud slinging fest between March 4th and April 22nd, the full spectrum of Silly Season. We all knew it was coming, both Dems and the GOP all warned about it, and yet we have the audacity to act surprised when it did. Come on. At this point, we have seen both Obama and Clinton multiple times get booed when they started ripping into each other, or even hinting that they might. Everyone's sick of it. The real damage to the Democratic campaign in November is not what either one of the current Democratic candidates may say and do to each other, but what they are doing to the image of the campaign itself. If they allow themselves to completely dissolve into further bickering and cherry picking of he-said/she-said, the image of Democrats in general is going to get hurt, maybe critically hurt. It's time to listen to the boos and refocus.

Eventually, either Clinton or Obama is going to be the Democratic nominee.

Let that one sink in for a second. At this point, I think there is no surety for either of them. And, what we've known since at least March 4th is that the superdelegates are going to make the call. Let that one sink in too. This amorphous "the people" have also had every chance to break for one or the other, and they haven't been able to do it, either. That is precisely why superdelegates exist. It is why the electoral model exists. I believe there is no ignoring the fact at this point that the Democratic battle is going to be settled on the Convention floor, even if the "real" decision is made by July 1st, like Howard Dean wants. I believe both Obama and Clinton have no choice but to start directly campaigning for superdelegate backing. The way they frame the remaining nominating contests will be about how the superdelegates view the results, not about the actual results. Clinton may well be able to close the popular vote gap between now and the first week of June. Obama very likely will maintain his delegate lead. Then, they have to face off over which is more important: accrued delegates or accrued votes. The reality post-Pennsylvania is that not much changed on the broadest strokes of the math. However, underneath that, we do see a dramatic divide, and Clinton is not wrong that the tide may in fact be turning. She says this to imply that she is winning now, which may or may not be true. What is actually turning her way is her argument that she is more electable. Again, this does not automatically imply that Obama is unelectable. Going into the upcoming primaries, we'll see what it really means. The case is not as open and shut as either campaign wants us to think.

Friday, March 28, 2008

A Triangulated Battle

So what exactly are these dire consequences to the Democratic party if Clinton and Obama drag their horse race out five more months? I don't think it is that the two are "destroying each other." I don't think it is lasting bitterness on behalf of the eventual loser's supporters. I don't think it is that the superdelegates are going to crash and burn modern democracy if they don't follow the popular vote. All of this bickering and hostility and mud slinging will be instantly forgotten once the nomination is awarded.

Calls for either Clinton or Obama to drop out have been soundly booed, even by party leadership. Even though the media is focusing on Howard Dean's call for delegates to endorse, he specifically identified his time line as after the primary season. This week, big money Clinton supporters threw down the gauntlet to Nancy Pelosi and basically said if she openly endorses Obama before the Convention, they won't open their wallets to House Democrats. MoveOn.org went wild over this and issued a rebuke. Pelosi seems to have rejected this threat, but also flexed her claws over threats to House Democrats, which tells me she takes it seriously. No matter what happens, I believe the message is loud and clear: no one is dropping out yet.

What the party leaders are afraid of is triangulation. I have long felt that voters are evaluating all three presidential candidates on a continuum from left to right, independent of party affiliation. Both the Democrats and the GOP are experiencing disturbing trends of defection. The Democratic party considers GOP defectors a success and view the Dems who are showing sympathies to McCain a sign that the internal race is harming the cause. I find it to be an exciting phenomenon, and a clear indicator that American voters are engaged in the political process. I believe this phenomenon is benefiting the Democratic party, but only because they are the only potent national venue where change is endorsed.

I also believe a sub-textual fear is that if Clinton gets the nomination, resentful voices will say Republicans tipped the balance. If that is true, it also calls into question the motives of GOP defectors, which Rush Limbaugh has already paved the road for. "Triangulation" is a dirty word to most Democrats, and it was a major bone of contention between the party and Bill Clinton. Regardless, I believe it cannot be ignored that Obama, Clinton and McCain represent a liberal-moderate-conservative scale, in that order. All scandals aside, all analysis of race, gender, and age (again, in that order) aside, what we see right now are three very viable, intelligent, and prepared candidates, all of whom have a very distinct Presidency mapped out.

Reality is finally intruding on the '08 election cycle. The economy is swiftly emerging as the big election issue. All three candidates have begun platforming economic plans, solutions to the mortgage crisis, and dovetailing their personal campaign slants in. Obama is subtly inserting his Change theme into his economic position. Clinton is doing the same with Health Care, arguably her strongest position, smartly using it as her launching pad for the rest of her economic plans. And, McCain is splashing foreign relations broadly across his whole strategy, and doing some very impressive image spinning. Both Democrats have started to focus on McCain instead of each other, which tells me, the General Election has begun.

Increasingly, I see Clinton and Obama drawing the knife edge closer instead of further apart. Currently, in head-to-heads, Obama has regained his visible lead over McCain, according to RealClearPolitics.com. However, less than one point separates all of them, and both Democrats come in at exactly 45.0%, showing they both perform the same in a head-to-head. The undecided percentages, and the margin or error erases any determining call. Pennsylvania and North Carolina have re-polarized after a few days flux toward Clinton, and are now mirrors of each other again, with the split hovering around 50-30, favoring Clinton in Penn and Obama in NC. Clinton is standing to gain more in Pennsylvania, but she has a harder climb than Obama, so the delegate-smaller state of NC is still a considerable win for Obama, too. Once more, an eye for an eye. Again, according to RCP, factoring in Florida, Michigan and estimates from states that do not report exact totals, the popular vote total is split almost exact down the middle, separated by less than 1 percent, around 200,000 votes. Depending on any number of factors from visceral things like money to the completely spontaneous, Clinton could easily make up that difference. Jay Cost has made a very compelling and thorough analysis of how the popular vote count could vary dramatically. Both have suffered very nasty blows to their image and are both still standing. Both have spouses who have been unpalatable to their campaigns. Both have had inverted victories, hedging into each other's bases equally. I believe even the Democratic voting pattern shows equal-opposite strengths. Clinton performs well with big working class states, and Obama performs well in caucuses and broadly with white men. Both inspire so much loyalty that their supporters are willing at least to threaten defection. Both represent a contradiction to the Democratic party. Clinton's sense of entitlement to the presidency is fairly consistent with the party sentiment, but find the attitude distasteful coming from Clinton. Obama represents change and coalition, but the risks involved in backing him are considerable. The true significance of the Wright scandal is that race had to come up eventually, and it will again.

Every high profile Democrat has reinforced the push for unity behind whoever wins the nomination. I believe the reason Howard Dean has said July 1st will be his personal deadline for all delegates to make up their minds is because he fears not the Convention, but a brokered convention, which is when the really ugly fighting would start. The "Al Gore Shadow Candidate" rumor is popping up again, and I still don't believe it. But, I do believe people are doing the math and realizing that even the superdelegate vote could split in such a way that neither candidate got the 2025 magic number. It could happen.

Everyone already knew this, but now that it is happening, they are realizing that instead of preventing it, they should be planning for it. Preventive strategies have failed, instead fueling the debates. Democratic leadership now has to lean toward preparing for the superdelegates to take center stage, exercise their best judgment, select a nominee, and do all of this in the most politic possible way. Doing so by July 1st gives six weeks to test the waters for the presumed nominee. Someone has to concede eventually, and if buyers remorse is going to set in, better it be while there is still an option: before the Convention. Clinton is poised for a big win in Pennsylvania, one that will net her momentum for coming wins, a delegate gain, and a major proof in her "more electable" argument. Rightly, she could at this point throw Obama's words back at him in answer to his campaign calls for her to drop out, "Why would I drop out? I'm winning." Both know the pitfalls and advantages of the frontrunner - underdog symbiosis, and both are exercising them daily. Clinton is suffering very bad right now as the underdog, but this plays directly into her comeback phenomenon. The worse it looks for her, the greater even a small victory looks. Conversely, Obama is riding the wave of his near to insurmountable lead, returning to his grand oratory style, and writing speeches that are already headed for the history books. But, he has also found out that being in the lead, even in the presumed winner's slot, does not shield him from major blows to his image or questions of his integrity, in fact it intensifies the desire for scrutiny of both. Coming out of the recent round of battle bruised but still swinging is good for him, but he should be careful to think it's over. He may have won the battle, but the war is still very much on.

McCain has realized he can't stay out of the fray. Clinton and Obama if nothing else, are giving each other excellent practice rounds. As I have said in a previous article, Clinton and Obama represent very different challenges to McCain. His answer to this is to begin positioning himself as the President people expect. Now that he has gotten the Bush endorsement, he has also begun to distance himself from Bush politics, which both Democrats have harshly criticized. McCain knows his weaknesses, and he is sidestepping them rather well. He has come across as calm, confident, and eloquent, and that is the real danger. Both Democrats have begun, by necessity to respond to McCain's forays against them, and this has drawn attention to all three as serious options. Like it or not, the presidential race is currently three-way. It is incumbent on Democrats to narrow the field to two, but all three are campaigning for President, and all three are drawing their own unique following. I believe this is what accounts for the seemingly strange movements in party affiliation and in cross-over voting. Allow me to reiterate that I find this exciting and interesting, and I see it as a sign that Americans overall are more interested in who is President, not in what party wins.

Monday, March 24, 2008

Clinton's Path To The Nomination: Clearer Than You Think

I find it interesting that the majority of people who are writing about Clinton's "path to the nomination" are mostly Clinton eulogists. These essays read like this, "Clinton needs to achieve this long list of unlikely victories and then will still have to face a hostile elective body in Denver who clearly prefer Obama." They then go on to point out that Clinton's only real hope is that Obama will do something to tank his own campaign and make himself unpalatable to the DNC. Then, and only then, will Clinton have a chance of swaying the superdelegates to back her, and by then, the image of the Democratic party in general will be so trashed that McCain will sweep the election, and everyone will be sorry they didn't speak out louder for Obama. They're already plating up a big, healthy meal of buyer's remorse, when no one's been bought yet. In light of all this, I think it is far and away time to see a Clinton-favoring "path to the nomination."

Of course these eulogies started popping up as soon as Clinton achieved what everyone said she needed to achieve: big wins on March 4th. Everyone from both campaigns, to the media, to the DNC said this was the "firewall." She passed that firewall with flying colors. And, in spite of accusations that Clinton is capitalizing on the Wright scandal, the more likely reality is that March 4th gave Clinton momentum for Pennsylvania. She was already in the lead in the Keystone State, and her lead started to grow immediately after March 4th. Yes, the Wright scandal probably helped, and Clinton cannot be blamed for passively benefiting from it. More likely, the Wright situation is helping her more in North Carolina, where Obama's lead has been drastically shortened. Three weeks ago, Penn and NC looked like mirror images of each other, now it's a landslide for Clinton in Penn and a narrow win for Obama in NC. Since the beginning or March, the head-to-head schematic has started to slide Clinton's way, too, with the "vs. McCain" results no longer favoring Obama (which they were by 5 points) and with Clinton performing better against McCain. In that race, Obama has lost nearly 6 points and Clinton has gained 3. That is a 9-point variance, which is outside most margins of error.

So, what is Clinton's path to the nomination?

Florida and Michigan

While the pundits are calling the likelihood of nothing happening in FL and MI towards re-votes a "blow" to Clinton, I think this is a media-created fallacy. First of all, a re-vote in either state presents the very real chance that Obama could close the gap. Campaign schematics are different, the media coverage is different, only 25% of the original candidates are still standing, and Obama is seen as a much more serious option than he was pre-Edwards drop out. Second, if nothing happens in the two contested states, and the DNC continues their shut out of those delegates, they still represent 1.2 million votes for Clinton. Official or not, those votes close the gap. With FL and MI included, the popular vote total only favors Obama by 0.3%. Anyone who tries to claim that those votes should not count should also check their cries for the popular vote to be respected. Regardless of a rule that disenfranchised millions of American voters because governmental bureaucracy made a bungle, votes are still votes.

Big States Strategy and Electoral Strategy

These two are related, and are a very normal and typical general election strategy. In spite of the nit picking about the importance of such and such demographic and arguments about who can turn red states blue, the simple fact remains that Clinton has performed the strongest in the big states and that she leads in electorate strength. Barring a huge reversal in Pennsylvania, that argument will be almost unchallengeable by April 22. Obama has cleaned house in small states and in caucuses. And, in spite of creative math supported by questionable arguments that Obama appeals to swing voters more than Clinton, big states decide the general election, and the general election is not run caucus-style. Yes, there are states that are so blue that any Democrat will carry them, but that is true of Clinton too. Also, Texas is the major big-state stronghold for Republicans, and there is a very compelling case that Clinton would be much more competitive in Texas than Obama. I'm not sold that Democrats could take Texas at all, but stranger things have happened. If 700,000 Latinos come out to vote on Election Day in Texas like they did on March 4th, we might see an upset in Texas. An area where Clinton has an arguable advantage is in voter empowerment, and in energizing her ground game at the last minute.

Swing States and "pink" states

The swing states are: Ohio, West Virginia, Kentucky, Tennessee, Missouri, Arkansas, and Louisiana. They represent 71 electoral votes which is 13% of the nationwide electorate and 26% of the required majority to win. Based on a combination of results and poll projections, Clinton beats Obama in the swing states by 10 points. I believe there is also a strong argument that Clinton could take Florida, a "pink" state. She is performing much better in head-to-heads than Obama in the Sunshine State, she won the Florida primary by a very convincing margin, versus McCain's narrow win over Romney. If Clinton can hang onto her Latino base and regain the white male vote, she could give McCain a run for his money in taking Florida's 25 electoral votes. The other pink states are: Georgia, Arizona, Colorado, and Montana. In terms of the Democratic race, those states are split in half with Georgia and Colorado for Obama and Arizona and Montana for Clinton (Montana projected.) Of the pink states other than Florida, only Georgia has much electoral weight, and in fairness to Obama, I do think he would stand a fair chance of taking Georgia, but he would lose Florida which would cut into his net gain pretty seriously.

The Money Myth

"Obama outspends Clinton." "Obama raises more money than Clinton." The fact however, is that since the beginning of March, Clinton has been raising at least a million a day, and when they sent out panicked calls for donations last week, they raised over 2 million on 1 day. I do not see that kind of push from Obama, who is currently coasting on financial advantage based on higher debt on the Clinton side. Also, Clinton is much more financially prepared for the general election, by more than a 3-to-1 margin. Both Democrats have left McCain in the dust financially. If Clinton can get to the general election, she will have a huge financial advantage. Obama would have to focus on fund raising, whereas Clinton would be much more agile because of her money lead. In the general election funds, Clinton is ahead of McCain 7-to-1 whereas Obama is ahead just over 2-to-1. Obama is blowing through money very fast right now trying to regain his momentum, outspending Clinton by over a million a day. While that makes him look like he is winning, it is literally costing him. If Clinton can stay financially afloat for the next 5 weeks, the financial schematic will look very different by June. By that time, the Clinton campaign will have paid off its debt, and Obama will be struggling to keep his lead against McCain and the GOP who will no doubt open their wallets wide. Clinton has also been slammed for her big-donor strategy, which I cannot fathom being a bad idea. With big, cash-flushed donors on her side, there is a much greater chance that when push comes to shove, Clinton will be able to keep her lead, versus Obama's "grassroots" financial support. If I was in dire straights for money, I'd ask my rich friends for money before my poor ones.

General Election Focus and the Issues

I believe that Clinton has been focusing on general election strategies from the start: take the big states, build up a big general election fund, stay centrist on the issues. Clinton is appealing to the wallet -- economy, housing, health care. Obama is appealing to the spirit -- change, cooperation, reform.

I think it is clear at this point that the working class prefers Clinton, and in the end, her positions on keeping your house and getting medical care will win the day. While it has come out that Clinton apparently "misrepresented" her position on NAFTA, I still think that one goes to (or against) Obama. Clinton held pro-NAFTA meetings while Bill was president, and NAFTA was widely seen as a good move for the US economy. Clinton has said that NAFTA is hurting the economy now, and said that she would use opt-out threats to renegotiate NAFTA terms. Obama pretty much said the same thing, but it also came out that his campaign strategists knew this was just rhetoric and didn't really mean it. So, 10 years ago Clinton said, "Let's do NAFTA." Now it's not working out, and she acknowledges this and wants to fix it. Obama just looks like a liar in this case, whereas Clinton has a much stronger argument that, "We tried it, it didn't work out as planned. We can fix it."

As for Iraq, people think that Obama has a better plan because he opposed the war from the start. This is another media-created fallacy. Just because Clinton voted to authorize the war doesn't mean that today, five years later, in a completely different political climate, Clinton is not capable of coming up with a reasonable solution. Also, the likelihood that Iraq is going to get worse before it gets better is still very real. Pro-Iraq sentiment is at an all time high again. Even though liberals won't acknowledge it for the most part, the troop surge worked. I believe Clinton's Iraq position is also a general election strategy to appeal to moderates who support the war effort (even if they opposed it originally) but want to see progress toward withdrawal. Obama's anti-war stance is much stronger and louder, and that may not be a strength against McCain, although it presents more contrast. Clinton and McCain are both on the Armed Services Committee, which begs the question, who knows more about Iraq? Probably Clinton. Couched together with her very real point that Obama has been seriously negligent in his duties as the chair of the sub committee on Europe, Clinton comes out looking much more prepared to deal with Iraq, Afghanistan and Iran.

The Superdelegate Myth

The prevalent attitude at this time is the the superdelegates favor Obama. Currently, Clinton is holding a 14% lead in superdelegate support. Clinton has had superdelegate majority since the beginning. Obama is closing that lead, but he is doing so with his primary and caucus numbers, not with unpledged "defectors" as the media is portraying. The main myth that is being perpetrated is that the superdelegates are in some way going to automatically support Obama based on "large" popular vote leads. First of all, I don't see much of a large lead, and it is getting smaller. Florida and Michigan are going to count in the arguments, even if they don't count in the math, and that erases Obama's "big lead." The superdelegates are not bound to the popular vote, otherwise their function would be what? Nothing. Superdelegates exist because of the obvious need for discernment in the nomination process. If Clinton can convince superdelegates that she is the right one for the job, there is nothing wrong with that. In fact, the pundits are already saying that this is exactly what she has to do. When all the primaries are over, and the nominating process enters its final stages, either one of them is going to need the superdelegate contingent to get their majority. Obama has to campaign for their support, too, but you don't see anyone saying he shouldn't. The superdelegates are voters in the nominating process just like the pledged ones, and arguably their role is more important at this stage, since neither candidate is going to win without them.

If find no compelling argument that Obama's case is any stronger than Clinton's. The two are still in a dead heat, and Obama is currently suffering. If Clinton had experienced the horrible week Obama just had, the opinion would be that it was over for her. The fact that she has hung on, is gaining in the head-to-heads and is closing the gap in states that were "Obama Country" a week ago, is certainly not a sign that she should quit. It is a very strong sign that she could turn it around. Clinton has come back every time it has looked like it was over. There is more evidence to support the idea that she can come back again, rather than she won't. This battle aint over til it's over. Clinton very well may win the argument that she is more electable, and that is going to win the nomination. Democratic party leaders have made it very clear that their priority is a Democratic win in November, and whoever demonstrates a stronger elective case by August will be the nominee.

Tuesday, March 18, 2008

They tried to make me go and re-vote and I said, "No, no, no."

Florida Democrats have spoken, and they say, "No do-over." This has the media in a tussle over it, calling it a "blow" to Clinton and crying about the woes of the Florida delegation. Meanwhile, DNC member Jon Ausman has filed a petition with the DNC Rules & Bylaws Committee challenging the charter's verbiage and arguing for the inclusion of both Florida and Michigan. First, let me say, I'm not sure how this is a "blow" to Clinton, who clearly won Florida. If the DNC is already responding to Florida's reticence to have another go at it, there is certainly hope at least that Florida will be included, and if it is, it will be as-is. I really doubt the 50/50 argument will go anywhere. Second, let me say, I can't believe that Florida and Michigan are still being lumped together. Michigan was a whole different schematic, and hopefully Democratic leadership will acknowledge that.

Sunday, March 16, 2008

McCain Already Acting Like President

Someone should knock on the Democratic party's door and remind them that the competition is on the other side of the aisle, and right now it's on the other side of the pond for a fundraiser.

It would sound something like this, "Hello? Yes. I was wondering if you have seen Senator McCain?" No, they haven't.

Why?

Because he is in Iraq "assessing the troop surge." It can't be too bad a PR trip, with more than half the foreign-deployed US military being in Iraq. McCain is traveling under the auspice of the U.S. Senate Armed Services Committee, and the visit is his 8th in 5 years. McCain is pro-Iraq, but has criticized the Bush administration's handling of the war. Now that the troop surge McCain advocated is working, he is free to capitalize on being right, and gets the Bush stamp of approval. McCain is a popular candidate in the military demographic. While Senator McCain's official role on this trip is legitimate, there is no doubt the timing is political. Senators Clinton and Obama are tangling like angry cats, no one can hear over the din, and McCain strolls off to Iraq to start personally handling the war.

Also in McCain's palm pilot over the next week are meetings with Jordanian King Abdullah, Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, British Prime Minister Gordon Brown and French President Nicolas Sarkozy. While he is jaunting around the globe meeting with important world leaders and reinforcing the GOP agenda, Clinton and Obama will be busily destroying each other, nearly oblivious. The fighting between Clinton and Obama has created such a thick smoke screen that McCain doesn't even have to be in the country to campaign. The GOP and Bush are free to start a phased transition of control from Bush to McCain. As far as they are concerned, he is President-elect. I have no doubt that McCain is willing to adopt the Bush agenda in exchange for a bully pulpit endorsement.

Who's to say Clinton and Obama could not present a united front against McCain while still continuing their own campaigns? I think it is perceived as impossible at this time because of the vice-presidential bickering, which both have said is premature, but were forced to discuss it anyway. Both Democrats shied away from the VP question because they both knew that it was going to lead to trouble. But, the media and the pundits pushed the issue and they capitulated. This sparked off the latest infighting that has now escalated to name calling. See, it is so fascinating even I get distracted talking about it, and forget what I was really talking about: John McCain.

I'm going to say this every chance I get, until I'm heard: do not underestimate John McCain. In the most recent head-to-heads, all three presidential candidates are in a dead heat. But, it's sliding McCain's way against Obama, and Clinton's way against McCain. A week ago, Obama beat McCain in head-to-heads by 5 points, and Clinton was losing by 2 points. The head-to-head schematic is sliding back toward where it was in December, with Clinton the clear winner. But, it's much closer this time. As I said, it's a dead heat, less than 1 point separating any of them. That's excellent news for McCain and the GOP, and should be a dire warning to Democrats that their assumed victory in November is in jeopardy.

How do Democrats bail the ship? I think the answer is simple. Go back in time. Not literally, but back to when the Democratic race was about the issues. It didn't seem like it at the time, but it was. I'd love to hear one of Obama's inspirational speeches right now. I'd love to hear Clinton croaking on about health care and heartfelt moments with single mothers. Both campaigns are losing track of their core platforms and they need to get back to them.

I think there are signs that both want to, signaled by a willingness to participate in 2 debates, in spite of the obvious risks of what topics could come up. No doubt, there will be mutually agreed upon topics to be left alone. We need to see some "Democratic unity" between Clinton and Obama, something they have both shown when they appear together. If they are smart, and they both are, they will use their considerable media networks to author the upcoming debates to focus on the general election and the issues, not the identity of the candidates.

Democratic leadership has already indicated that the entire nominating process is going to be allowed to play out, up to and including the likelihood of the superdelegates deciding the race, with or without popular backing. What happens is going to be allowed to happen. So, for any Democratic candidacy to survive McCain's bid for the Oval Office, Clinton and Obama need to shape up. Instead of the race or gender card, it's time for someone to play the good sportsmanship card. It is possible to run a polite campaign. Classic principles of debate could and should be applied to the Democratic race right now. Clinton and Obama should bury the hatchet, shake hands, and agree to keep it clean. The GOP kept their process clean and focussed on the issues, and produced a nominee who is much stronger than anyone anticipated.

I was warning about McCain two years ago, and all of my arguments are coming true. I said McCain was a popular war hero with a long Congressional career, foreign relations expertise and a moderate image that would resonate with Independents and swing voters. Congratulating myself for predicting McCain's win is not what I want to do, and would be a hollow reward. I would much rather the attitude that Democrats are guaranteed to win in November be immediately dismissed. Fueled by Bush's deplorable image domestically and worldwide, and by the prevalent idea that Bush stole the presidency from Gore, Democrats feel a sense of entitlement to the Presidency. This is a terrible attitude to take toward actually winning.

Even though Clinton is getting slammed for being willing to do anything to win, I don't think anyone would damn her for using the same strategies against McCain. Conversely, if Rev. Wright flung a few honkey comments at McCain, probably everyone would chuckle and forget it. People delight in the humiliation of public figures, and as long as the fighting looks fair, all bets are off. There is a subtle but strong eye-for-an-eye current running in the Democratic campaign anyway. I think Dems will be willing to overlook almost anything as long as it helps secure a Blue president. America was founded on many Classical principles, and our government, a republic, was modeled after Classical and Roman deliberative bodies. I don't think party leadership even cares who the nominee is at this point, as long as one of them fairly wins the argument.

Wednesday, March 12, 2008

Florida, Michigan, and electibility

Back to Florida and Michigan again. The issue has been fairly consistent throughout, but now that particularly Florida Democrats are getting involved, offering strategies for inclusion, the debate is becoming real. I think Michigan's party leaders are probably watching to see how the wind blows before putting forth an offer to the DNC. Michigan and Florida represent very different problems, in spite of their being lumped together in the debate. Let's talk about both on their own.

Florida

Florida gets to go first for a few reasons. Being the "more important" state in the general election pretty much trumps. Florida's issues are also a lot less complex. All candidates were on the ballot. Clinton and Obama both followed the rules, or broke them depending on how you look at it. Both held fundraising events in Florida and made private appearances only. Both ran national ads only in Florida. The claim that there was "no campaigning" in Florida by either candidate is a conceit. There was no ground game in Florida. Since both Democratic survivors shared this handicap, I don't think it matters. The main issue is rules, which Florida state Dems broke by moving their primary date forward, and were duly penalized by having their delegates to the Democratic National Convention stripped. Now, because of the finger-breadth differences in votes and delegates in many races, the overwhelming pressure from all sides is to count every vote. So, how do we do that without just trashing the rules?

I believe Clinton was a little presumptive to hold an event in Florida the day of the primary, and if she had not done that, the debate would be even less complicated. Conversely, I believe being present to claim a big popular victory in an electorate-rich state is a long-term campaign strategy, and a smart one. Florida is a Red-Swing state, and a double-digit lead in a three-way contest (Edwards' last contest was Florida) is a big win that demonstrates electibility. Dems in any other election cycle would be thrilled to see such a strong performance by any candidate. Obviously Florida "mattered" since a third-place showing was Edwards sign of the times to drop out.

I am torn on the idea of a re-vote. It seems fair, but is it? The prevalent push at the moment is toward a mail-in vote. This opens the door to so many potential disasters, I honestly can't imagine how Howard Dean and the DNC could agree to it. Paper ballots and Florida have a very bad reputation since 2000. I've also said this before, and will reiterate it here: there will be no re-votes in November. Florida voters knew Florida was a "beauty contest" and they still came out in record numbers. The popular vote is winning the argument all over the place, and 1.7 million voters in the Democratic race should not be ignored. But, what do you do with the other six candidates? Sure, they're out now, but they weren't then, and Edwards is still technically in. There is no way to effectively reconstruct campaign conditions.

I don't think it would be too much of a political problem for the DNC to simply say, "Florida was conducted according to the rules save for timing, which is the state's right to decide. Considering the cost of re-votes, and the potential issues of fairness involved, we have ruled to include Florida's results as-is and will authorize Florida's state party to award delegates proportionally, based on their state's rules. Michigan will be addressed individually, based on its unique situation." Really, there is plenty of legal precedent for respecting the will of state governments over federal authority. I believe there are two fair resolutions to the Florida situation: either include Florida as-is, or don't include them at all. Inclusion of Florida as-is would not put precedent forward to do the same in Michigan, as I believe it is plain that Michigan is a different issue.

Michigan

Michigan poses a different problem all together. Let me start by pointing out, Hillary Clinton was not the only candidate on the Michigan ballot. However, Barack Obama and John Edwards (and Joe Biden and Bill Richardson) were not. So, only 50% of the Democratic candidates were represented. The claim that there was "no campaign" in Michigan is a lot heavier than the claim in Florida. Edwards urged voters to vote "uncommitted" because write-ins would not be counted. 40% of the primary vote going to "uncommitted" certainly indicates that voters knew this, and made an informed choice. This also makes the argument for a re-vote a lot stronger in Michigan.

But what does it mean? Did Edwards win 40% of the Michigan vote? The uncommitted idea was his. I think the idea that people voted for Clinton because she was the "only candidate" is so full of holes there is no way it could go anywhere. In every race Clinton has won except 2, she has done so in the 50+ percentage area, so the Michigan results, at a time when Clinton was still perceived as the front runner, are pretty much in line with expectations. I know that argument is weak, but the argument that all uncommitted votes would or should go to Obama is weaker. Also, what were they supposed to do in Michigan? Not vote? If Clinton had pulled herself from the Michigan ballot, would they have canceled the primary? I doubt it.

So what do they do about Michigan? Did it give Clinton "false momentum"? If it did, Edwards and Obama are certainly to be thanked for it. Michigan was a beauty contest, but state Democrats obviously didn't think so. Why would you remove yourself completely from a ballot when you knew your opponent was not going to? The following-the-rules-good-faith-move argument only holds so much water, and in the end will probably hurt more than help. Edwards and Obama not being on the Michigan ballot has completely muddied the waters in that state and has created a lose-lose for everyone. This is an election. If you want to win you put yourself on the ballot. Attempts to characterize Clinton as greedy or underhanded because she wanted to compete in a state primary are little more than slur tactics. The conceit that there will be "no campaign" just because the DNC says so is ridiculous. The primary still happened -- isn't that the point of scheduling early -- Democrats in Michigan still came out and voted, and obviously at least 40% of them were listening to the campaign rhetoric, since they followed advice and voted uncommitted.

Michigan is a problem though. The problem is not that Hillary Clinton "broke faith" and stayed on the ballot. Obviously Obama and Edwards learned from that mistake, and quickly put themselves on the Florida ballot. (Giving more credence to Florida's validity, too, or to the hypocrisy of all of them, depending on how you look at it.) The problem is, we don't know who all those uncommitted people would have voted for. In terms of the general election, Michigan is an electorate-rich state as well, but it's a Blue state and I think whoever wins the nomination will carry Michigan. The state's overall importance is more inside the Democratic race than in the larger general election schematic. The "split them 50/50" argument is ridiculous. Clinton won more than 50% of the vote, and giving more than the uncommitted vote percent (40%) to Obama would show clear favoritism. The idea that all the uncommitted votes would have gone to Obama is bunk, since it was Edwards who pushed for it. And, with Edwards out, his supporters do not automatically go to Obama or to Clinton, as we have clearly seen since. I think there are two solutions for Michigan, too: either organize a statewide re-vote, or leave them out.

Other Early Voting States

Nevada and South Carolina had early primaries, too, and were not penalized by the DNC. So, the "rules" don't hold much credence in this case. A voice vote only was held to authorize primary / caucus advance dates and the argument was that Nevada and South Carolina are more representative of minorities, and would give a broader scope to early primary returns. Iowa and New Hampshire have traditionally been allowed to hold early primaries as well, based on the argument that small states should get their voice heard over the din of big events like Super Tuesday. But, we all know that big states pretty much decide the general election. Having an early litmus test of big states is not such a bad idea.

I honestly believe that the real issue is that Clinton clearly won 3 of 5 early voting states. Including Michigan she won 4 of 6. At this point in the campaign, if Obama had won the majority of them, it would be over, Clinton would be out, and the controversy would be moot. The fact that Florida and Michigan draw the race to a true razor-thin difference, is the difference. The media has struck its blow on this one and cast Clinton as the "desperate" and "manipulative" underdog who will "do anything to win." This has made her look like she wants something unfair. Let's not forget that Clinton is the one advocating for a system of inclusion, and Obama is the one who keeps saying no. Why? Because it's bad news for him. Poor Obama. His "overwhelming lead" (which he does not have) would be challenged. His poor performance in big states would be sharply underscored. He would be challenged to really prove that he can win, instead of coasting on small state wins and lopsided victories in demographics that are not representative of the general election turnout.

Obama's arrogance on these matters is monumental. Currently he is holding an 8% lead in delegates, which could easily be erased between now and June. He is holding only a 5% lead in the popular vote, which drops to less than 3% if Florida is included. And, in the most recent head-to-heads, where now both Clinton and Obama beat McCain, Obama only performs better than Clinton by 0.3%, a difference that is meaningless. The two are in a statistical dead heat, and yet Obama is trumpeting all over the news that he is "the clear front runner" and "obviously winning." I've said this one before too, but here it is: it aint over til it's over, and it isn't over til Denver. Superdelegates are going to decide this nomination, and they are not going to be bound solely by the popular vote. Even Nancy Pelosi would not say she would follow her constituency in her decision as a superdelegate. If the leading Democrat in the country as of this time is not willing to advocate for the popular vote, I'd say that argument is now moot. Clinton is leading in superdelegates by 13%, and that balance is a lot more likely to swing the nomination, unless the popular vote dramatically swings in favor of one or the other.

Also, claims that Clinton is using GOP tactics against Obama are just hype. She has been calling herself more qualified, and ripping on Obama's abilities as commander-in-chief for a very long time. The fact that McCain is doing it, too, does not logically prove that Clinton is doing the same thing. It only proves that two people believe they would be better than him. Clinton is getting slammed for using divisive tactics and called (basically) a bitch for "trashing another Democrat." Isn't accusing Clinton of "using the Rove playbook" the exact same thing? Isn't an uncooperative attitude toward Florida and Michigan re-votes just as nasty? Please. This is a presidential campaign, and a very critical one for Democrats. Every candidate is pulling every stop to win. That's the bottom line. Also, Clinton's words are coming back -- and ringing very true -- get ready, it's just started. If Obama can't survive some relatively polite negative campaigning from Clinton, he'll be crying in his beer once McCain gets going. Come on. The 3am ad? The commander-in-chief bickering? Those are small beans compared to how fast and deep the GOP is going to rip into either Democrat once the nomination is sealed.

Sunday, February 17, 2008

Superdelegates Will Be Superdelegates

We've heard a lot of talk about superdelegates. We've seen an interesting contradiction, too: superdelegates are lauded as critical to the 2008 presidential nominating race, while simultaneously under fire as "undemocratic" and being called to task to follow the popular vote. For the first time for some Democrats, the Republican delegate system of winner-takes-all might be making more sense. But, the DNC supports the superdelegate system, and the proportional awarding of delegates. It looks more democratic.

Is democracy supposed to be driven by mob mentality? Are presidential candidates supposed to be selected based on pop images and biases created by competitive television networks? I don't think so, and neither does the DNC; that is why superdelegates exist. This is not Survivor or American Idol, the steady diet of the "youth vote" that is supposedly the voice of a new America. This presidential election is not going to take place on Google or Facebook or SodaHead.com. In November, it will be winner-takes-all, no revotes, no more debates.

So who are these "superdelegates" anyway? They are a small handful of former Presidents and Vice Presidents, all of the current State Governors, all current Senators and State Representatives, a small handful of former members of Congress, and a long list of DNC members who represent respected and dedicated Democrats selected at the state level. Calling the superdelegates "undemocratic" is an insult to the hard work, conviction, and loyalty these people have shown to America and to democracy. Many of these people are elected officials, empowered through our votes, through our confidence, and through our government process, to make choices. If we don't like those choices, we elect someone else. Yes, they have an obligation to serve the best interests of the nation. Yes, they should be considering the popular voice. But, at the end of the day, they should also be allowed to vote their conscience just like every other citizen. Both Democratic candidates are campaigning for their support, not just one.

The superdelegates represent a check and balance system inside the Democratic Party, and they should not be turned into puppets with no real function. The same people who are criticizing Sen. Clinton for wanting to "change the rules" of the Michigan & Florida primaries are also calling for the rules to be changed, a much bigger rule, with much more dramatic outcome. This is hypocrisy at its best.

I very much doubt that the DNC is going to support any kind of change in the delegate process midway through an election. The superdelegates also represent a very corporeal power base for Democrats; these people are the DNC, and there is very little to indicate they are unhappy with the process, only with unseen problems in the plan. If a concession is made by the DNC Chair to admit shut-out states, there will be even less indication that such a change would be supported. Admission of the two contested states would be a move toward supporting delegates, pledged and unpledged. And if they stand firm on Michigan and Florida, there is an equal case that the rules work and are being upheld.

One way or another, the superdelegates are going to have their voice. There is more evidence to support the system than to challenge it. The Democratic Party's delegate process is modeled on the U.S. Electorate. In 2000, in spite of an outcry of protest literally heard around the globe, Al Gore obeyed the will of the Electorate, being unable to produce legal precedent otherwise, and conceded the presidency to Bush. Al Gore is one of the superdelegates, and no doubt his opinion counts. It is clear he is already in private meetings with senior party members, and likely has had some collaboration with John Edwards concerning their shared silence. I have said before that I believe Edwards is more aligned with Clinton than Obama. I also believe that in spite of strained relations with the Clintons, Al Gore will also weigh in for Hillary, preferring her stance on climate change and nuclear power to Obama's.

I believe what the ephemeral voice of the DNC is leaking, that a brokered convention will not be allowed to come to pass. Coming out the victor of a brokered convention would hurt the whole campaign. Clinton would look like a greedy power broker, and Obama would look like a risk. As I have said in a previous article, the DNC has already sent an email on its public contact list saying that they believe a nominee will be identified "before August." I believe it is clear everyone is waiting to see what will happen between now and March 4th, maybe the end of April. If Clinton is able to break Obama's winning streak, and takes the lead again, which she is predicted to do for the most part, the decision will be a lot easier. The same for Obama if his momentum holds. If it remains too close to call, then senior party members will get involved. They will not risk appearing heavy handed by speaking too soon. These elusive "party elders" need to be seen as the mediators and saviors of the process in order to pass fairness muster.

In her remarks at the Wisconsin Democratic Party Founders Gala last night, Feb. 16th, she said (paraphrase, as the transcript is not yet available), "On the day the moving van pulls up to the back door of the White House, and George Bush and Dick Cheney hand over the keys..." We should remember that that day is what the whole nation is waiting for. She also said that the Republican party should be so embarrassed by the Bush Administration that they should not even tender a candidate, but they're going to. That remark drew thunderous applause, the kind usually heard at Obama events. I've said this over and over, but it cannot be said enough: the GOP is going to serve up John McCain, a hard, overhand serve. Hillary Clinton has the iron to stand up to McCain, but I believe that Obama's popularity cult would prove flimsy armor.